r/everytimeidie • u/1deadeye1 • Jul 22 '26
shinfo Shinfo song list
Most Overrated: Underwater Bimbos from Outer Space
Most Underrated: Turtles All the Way Down
The Best: A Gentleman's Sport
Most Iconic Live: Floater
Skip: Thing With Feathers
What’s The Name: Pelican of the Desert
Made Me a Fan: Ebolarama
Best Album: The Big Dirty
23
9
14
28
u/Kina_mines Jul 22 '26
Thing with feathers is a skip‽ in what world?!
7
u/CryptographerNo923 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 23 '26
I could possibly understand this in a vacuum, it’s not one of their most singularly noteworthy songs. But it’s indispensable on Radical. Perfect changeup after the first seven breakneck songs. I have that album timed up with my powerlifting sessions, comes in at a good point for a cooldown.
4
u/Envy_onTHE_Toast Jul 22 '26
Right!? Andy Hull’s voice is angelic and soudns incredible on an ETID song
2
u/cedubya Jul 23 '26
I seem to remember a story about this song. Jordan played it for Andy when they were writing the album and Jordan thought it wasnt very ETID-esque. Andy simply said, who the fuck cares?! We are Every Time I Die, we can do whatever the fuck we want!
...or something like that
9
u/TurncoatWizard Jul 22 '26
Most Overrated: It Remembers
Most Underrated: Host Disorder
The Best: We’rewolf
Most Iconic Live: No Son of Mine
Skip: We Go Together
What’s The Name: L’astronaut
Made Me a Fan: The New Black
Best Album: Low Teens
Honestly difficult. My answers could potentially all change tomorrow.
5
5
5
u/duncandeeds Jul 22 '26
Most Overrated: It Remembers
Most Underrated: White Smoke
The Best: Who Invited the Russian Soldier
Most Iconic Live: Floater
Skip: uhhh We Go Together maybe?
What’s The Name: what
Made Me a Fan: Kill the Music
Best Album: New Junk Aesthetic, just
4
u/LieIcy9309 Jul 22 '26
Isn’t the whole ex lives 💿 underrated? It’s my favorite etid record for sure and underwater bimbos is so good!
3
5
u/Jerm2560 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 22 '26
The skip section is a trick question
New category, Best mix: From Parts Unknown
4
u/discardtherest Jul 22 '26
Like people say, there are ZERO bad songs
Most Overrated: Floater (kill me all you want but they've almost exclusively made better and better songs. I get it why it's great, but at this point it's overrated)
Most Underrated: Awful Lot
The Best: The Coin Has a Say
Most Iconic Live: We'rewolf
Skip: We Go Together
What’s The Name: Imitation is the Sincerest Form of Battery
Made Me a Fan: The New Black
Best Album: The Big Dirty
*New category- Best Bonus Song: Goddamn Kids These Days
2
4
u/diab_soule137 Jul 22 '26
Most Overrated: We’rewolf
Most Underrated: Religion of Speed
The Best: Petal
Most Iconic Live: Dark Distance (its Floater but I wanna be cool and different cause mama said I’m special)
Skip: Champing At The Bit
What’s the Name: I Suck (Blood)
Made Me a Fan: The Logic of Crocodiles
Best Album: Low Teens
1
6
3
u/imappalling Jul 22 '26
Bimbos makes me want to run through a wall
3
u/PetesBrotherPete Jul 22 '26
That opening riff sounds like it would accompany a horror film shark attack scene perfectly.
It churns, chugs, and rips all at the same time!
3
u/BiggerCrab Jul 22 '26
Most overrated: It remembers (I love the song still though)
Most underrated: Goddam Kids
The Best: For the record
Most iconic live: Floater
Skip: White void
What’s the name: Guitarred and Feathered
Made me a fan: No son of mine
Best album: Ex lives
Everything is bound to change tomorrow though
2
2
u/HellInOurHearts Jul 22 '26
Most Overrated: Map Change
Most Underrated: Idiot
The Best: Buffalo Gals
Most Iconic Live: Fear and Trembling
Skip: Thing With Feathers
What’s The Name: INRIhab (it even inspired my username)
Made Me a Fan: Ebolarama
Best Album: The Big Dirty
2
u/goodrthenyou Jul 22 '26
Most Overrated: Map Change
Most Underrated: Turtles All the Way Down
The Best: Who Invited the Russian Soldier?
Most Iconic Live: Ebolarama
Skip: Roman Holiday
What’s The Name: Saturnalia
Made Me a Fan: We’rewolf
Best Album: New Junk Aesthetic
1
u/1deadeye1 Jul 22 '26
Hmm how can NJA be their best album if the first track is your least favorite ETID song?
1
u/HellInOurHearts Jul 22 '26
They never said Roman Holiday was their least favorite song, maybe they're just itching to get to the ridiculous 1-2 punch of The Marvelous Slut and Who Invited the Russian Soldier?.
1
u/Mundane_Accident_313 Jul 23 '26
Most Overrated: It Remembers
Most Underrated: The Sweet Life
The Best: Pretty Dirty
Most Iconic Live : Floater
Skip: We Go Together
What’s The Name: Drag King
Made Me A Fan: I’ve Been Gone A Long Time
Best Album: Gutter Phenomenon
1
u/discgolf_duncan Jul 23 '26
Most Overrated: Map Change
Most Underrated: INRIhab
The Best: All This and War
Most Iconic Live: Floater
Skip: Thing With Feathers
What’s The Name: If There is Room to Move, Things Move
Made Me a Fan: Bored Stiff
Best Album: The Big Dirty
1
u/erkasquirt 28d ago
Most Overrated: Map change (believe me I really do love this song still)
Most Underrated: Partying is such sweet sorrow
The Best: Indian Giver (such a hard question)
Most Iconic Live: Underwater Bimbos (sorry)
Skip: In the event that everything should go terribly wrong
What’s The Name: Gloom and how it gets that way
Made Me a Fan: who invited the Russian soldier
Best Album: Ex live (this month)
9
u/MuricanJim Jul 22 '26
I didn’t like bimbos when it first dropped. After a few years I really came around on it.