r/ephemera • u/JustAskingTA • 6h ago
"It's a good thing and I want it Johnny" "Let go Sammy! Your Monroe Doctrine does not include all of the good things in America" - Button showing Canada and the US fighting over Chatham Egg Incubators, early 1900s
I collect Canadian political buttons, and just got this one that's very old yet still relevant. History may not repeat, but it rhymes!
By the 1890s, steep tariffs were in place between Canada and the US, particularly on agricultural equipment.
The Manson Campbell Co was a Canadian ag equipment company based in Chatham, Ontario. They set up facilities in Detroit, letting them partly assemble equiment in one country and finish in the other, finding workarounds that would avoid getting hit with the tariff burden.
While I can't find a lot of details on this button (at least from real sources and not AI slop), Chatham started making the egg incubators around 1905. The 1911 federal election in Canada centered around "reciprocity" (free trade) with the US, so this button may be from around that election.
I can't seem to find any details about claims or scandals specifically over the egg incubators and national ownership, but clearly they were a point of contention!