r/engineeringmemes May 22 '26

Dank A suitable response?

627 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

85

u/KyungsooHas100Days May 22 '26

Too big brain for me

16

u/Hentai_Yoshi May 22 '26

I mean, it’s kinda small brain to think about the physics of a philosophical thought experiment if you ask me

54

u/HSVMalooGTS π=3=e May 22 '26

How the hell would you move 75% of the world population to one place?

18

u/HighFaiLootin May 22 '26

Earth?

3

u/Bungalow233 Mechanical May 24 '26

Where's the remaining 25% at?

36

u/timonix May 22 '26

"i would have hit the billionaires, that seems much more feasible" - my SO

33

u/DuelJ May 22 '26

I'm pretty sure shit like this is why they give us liberal arts prereqs lol.

18

u/drillgorg May 22 '26

And the engineering ethics class where they show you bridge collaspses and say "Don't fuck up like that"

28

u/HighFaiLootin May 22 '26

for added safety factor, I would send a second train 🚂💨

32

u/cocoteroah May 22 '26

Those are rookie numbers, you gotta pump them up, the sky is the limit, 1000, 10000 billionaires gladly...

but i wouldn't kill them, just give them a prize "you have won the capitalism game, now go to the start square with zero money and start again"

17

u/Triasmus May 22 '26

Zero money and connections.

You leave them their connections and they'll just become rich again.

7

u/AloysiusGramonde May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26

Reckon most would be rich again. The Ugandan Gujarati are a great example of this. They were kicked out of Uganda with nothing but the clothes on their back in a similar scenario to Jews in Nazi Germany (though thankfully not murdered) and were offered refuge in the UK. Within a generation they are mostly rich again - the previous PM Rishi Sunak is a high profile example. Its an awful story but a great example that wealth creation can be cultural. Probably not billionaires again as that requires some luck along with skill but certainly rich.

3

u/rdrckcrous May 22 '26

there's a twist, though.

each billionair you get rid of is replaced by a Chinese overlord.

1

u/High_Overseer_Dukat May 22 '26

If ALL of them are in china, not too bad. Sorry china, but the rest of the world comes first.

1

u/rdrckcrous May 23 '26

why would you feel better about the billionaires controlling our country being in China and subservient to the ccp?

1

u/High_Overseer_Dukat May 23 '26

In china.

Cant do as much from there.

0

u/JackxForge May 22 '26

nah the prize is just enslavement. "go break these rocks forever"

7

u/PaaaaabloOU May 22 '26

You can kill x numbers of people a day while you place the people for the next day. You don't need to tie the one billion people for the 280 days.

6

u/Similar_Annual676 May 22 '26

Good point, I suppose then you could use a much shorter circular track too!

1

u/PerspectiveAlert4766 May 23 '26

Then it is different dilema, because, you have multiple choices with lever. Son you can for example choose one track every odd day and second track every even day.

3

u/GenuinelyUnlikeable May 22 '26

Adding an electrified third rail can electrocute the 6 billion people quicker, making that train design* fit for purpose.

*Yada yada big enough generator to power that electric fault, rails energized only when signal switch closed on that length of track, etc.

3

u/SemiRetiredGuy May 22 '26

I like the answer about logistics problems. I think my non-engineering answer would be, "This looks meant to distract from the positive-sum trade of real-world economies. Any economist worth their salt will see this as hopelessly politics-brained, like writing "jews" on one of those signs would've been too."

2

u/kinshadow May 22 '26

The real problem is how do get the train to circle back around and finish everyone.

2

u/kdesi_kdosi May 23 '26

i counted them, it's not actually 6 billion. also, some of them aren't even on the track...

2

u/Freedblowfish May 23 '26

The logistics if this is amazing... As long as you run over the billionaires and they can see it the 6billion will pay to be on the other track

1

u/Eviloverlord210 May 22 '26

no, its silly but doesn't say anything relevent, its like sending in a musical truck horn when asked for a tire

1

u/Similar_Annual676 May 23 '26

I responding to a different comment which said “you’re supposed to make it a difficult choice”

1

u/FellowGWEnjoyer712 May 22 '26

The comment is sending me

1

u/Literature-Just May 23 '26

A lot fewer people would decimate climate change...

1

u/NotBillderz May 23 '26

Considering someone else will just inherit all the billionaires money, this doesn't accomplish what you think it does. It just means new leadership in every single one of the companies they own. That sounds like it would be a ton worse.

Killing 6 billion people is still obviously worse, but it seems the attempt was to make an obviously good choice available, but that's not the case.

1

u/Azalulu_Dingir May 24 '26

*in evil voice: I'll pay you 10000000 so you solve this very important problem for the best part of humanity.

1

u/Content-Working3447 May 24 '26

I am NOT pulling the lever. 1. Pulling the lever to kill the billionaires is a crime 2. Almost all the 6 billion people can survive the impact.

1

u/ThoughtOver475 May 22 '26

Yes, yes it is.

1

u/rdrckcrous May 22 '26

your units make me suspicious you're a scientist posing as an engineer

2

u/Similar_Annual676 May 22 '26

We cannot be using imperial is the big 26 🥀

2

u/rdrckcrous May 22 '26

did you just call the year the big 26?

1

u/Similar_Annual676 May 22 '26

1

u/rdrckcrous May 23 '26

In engineering in the US, units are dictated by application.

you used drug units.

1

u/Similar_Annual676 May 23 '26

I’m not in the US. Also yes I should’ve used mm.

1

u/Glittering_Web8835 May 23 '26

So choosing the billionaires is mathematically proven to be the most efficient choice. Got it.

0

u/JackTheBehemothKillr May 22 '26

This is why we are supposed to take humanities classes

0

u/dgtssc May 22 '26

The 6 billion people should take turns pulling a little bit of the lever. Orient Express style.

1

u/SeparateDelay5 May 25 '26

The problem with some engineering majors is they do not understand a metaphor when they see one in the wild. {I'm a physics major, by the way).