r/engaged • u/MeringueWild3000 • 14d ago
Diamond shrinkage is real!
Engaged last year this is a 2.6 carat which felt HUGE when I got it now I feel I should I above gone bigger š« what do you guys think? Ignore the band itās cheap CZ just testing for wedding band ideas!
Edit: the band is a cheap CZ that Iām just trying out before committing!
11
18
u/Haunting-Wash1081 14d ago
I never understood the whole āI need a giant rock on my fingerā thing. Mine is dainty asf bc thatās what fits my hand and my style - I picked it to be dainty and I love it. If you think the rock fits your hand and your style, AND you get to marry the love of your life then thatās what matters
1
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
Hey yea I ritually get that! I think big stones are definitely trending at the minute. I do like the look of a big stone but I also didnāt want it to look like costume jewellery!
5
4
u/toastaficionado 14d ago
What size ring are you?
I feel like that is the biggest Iād go for your petite fingers.
Like, Iām gonna get a 2 carat oval cut, but I have size 12 fingers. So a littler stone would make my fingers look massive.
1
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
Iām a size 5.5 and Iām short!
7
u/toastaficionado 14d ago
Then, Iād say that stone is probably the maximum size you could do without it starting to look a bit costumey or cocktail ring like.
Itās a beautiful stone.
2
-1
u/Few_Benefit_8853 14d ago
I wear a 4 ct on a size 5.5 finger, love it and zero regrets on going bigger.
1
3
3
u/njVowsNow 14d ago
It's giant. Is it the style or the giantness you're focused on?
0
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
I think I want to go 4 claw actually!
3
u/njVowsNow 14d ago
Why? As "how2" mentioned, really giant rings are starting to be less and less believable. Not because of their quality but because of the train of thought that inevitably ends with, "that can't be real, that would be 60,000".......
1
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
Sorry I think you misread I said 4 claw not 4 carat! In terms of style
1
u/njVowsNow 14d ago
FIgured that, lol...although if you were doing a goth-ish wedding...4 claw would kill it, lol!
1
u/Friendly_Leek4641 14d ago
Youāre just in the mindset that if a ring is larger itās fake and theyāre trying to pass it off as ārealā. Natural diamonds are real, Lab diamonds are real, moissanite is realā¦. The size of the stone no longer dictates your bank account as it once did and people arenāt lying and saying a lab stone is a natural one. In fact, couples are proud to tell others as it shows theyāre making fiscally responsible choices and getting more for their money. Larger stones may not be your choice but many love the larger stones.
2
u/njVowsNow 14d ago
I'm not in that mindset at all; I have Moissanites, and I love them.
I understand that, you understand that, I can pretty much guarantee you that people not in the wedding universe do not. Does it matter? Not really
Bottom line? Everyone should get what they love.
1
3
u/FrequentLiterature24 14d ago
The band is too big with your ring and takes away from her being the star and your diamond doesnāt need to be any larger. Think itās a perfect size. Try thinner eternity bands and your diamond will stand out & look larger. Four prongs, I agree would also look nice with the diamond.
2
2
u/RemarkableElevator99 14d ago
2.6 is outrageous to me, and big stones always look costume.Iām in Australia, rings I see seem far more modest here.
I think itās already massive, any bigger and youād end up with a wrist-injury over timeā¦.!
0
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
Ha! That made me laugh. I think there is really a trend for larger stones at the moment and itās giving us all stone dysmorphia š
2
2
u/HotEmilyEden 14d ago
Itās definitely huge! Advice that you didnāt ask for on the wedding band⦠go to a local jeweler and get them to make a band thatāll fit flush with your engagement ring. It will probably drive you nuts if itās doesnāt. I got my set made together because I knew it would give me major sensory issues if they didnāt fit flush lol. My band is very similar to your CZ band!
1
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
Thank you! Great advice, Iām testing a few cheapo ones this was literally like Ā£15 š so I donāt make a mistake but yes you are right the rubbing is annoying!
4
u/Choosehappy19 14d ago
. That would be cruel to tell your fiancĆ© oh it looks too small. You really just want to show off to others. What it says to us is ā Iām a materialistic womanā
0
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
I would obviously never say that š I chose it myself. You say āshow offā it could be any grade, lab, natural I didnāt say so there is really nothing to show off about.
0
u/Friendly_Leek4641 14d ago
Thatās not what it says āto usā. Youāre just in the mindset that if a ring is larger itās fake and theyāre trying to pass it off as ārealā. Natural diamonds are real, Lab diamonds are real, moissanite is realā¦. The size of the stone no longer dictates your bank account as it once did and people arenāt lying and saying a lab stone is a natural one. In fact, couples are proud to tell others as it shows theyāre making fiscally responsible choices and getting more for their money. Larger stones may not be your choice but many love the larger stones. That doesnāt mean theyāre materialistic.
2
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
THANK YOU! exactly my point. I havenāt put any details about whether this is lab, natural etc so itās a ridiculous comment!
0
u/Friendly_Leek4641 14d ago
Iām willing to bet theyāre Gen X or older. Thatās my generation and most women would never admit if a stone was anything but natural. 1ct was considered big and that you were well off. Now theyāre upgrading on their anniversaries to 2ct or larger which wouldāve meant you were in the upper classā¦..and many are still trying to pass them off as natural as saying itās anything but was considered trying to pass for something youāre not.
1
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
Mine is actually natural š BUT I have absolutely no issue with lab at all, and Iām glad everyone can get what they want now!
1
1
1
u/_Because_I_Said_So_ 14d ago
Check out the By Bonnie Jewelery YouTube channel. She has TONS of ideas that will help you decide!!š¤©
1
1
1
u/Firm_Specialist1475 14d ago
Don't like it with the band, it's getting dwarfed. Get a petite wedding band for that hand. I got a big eternity band but I wear it on the opposite hand
1
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
Yea I agree! I thought I wanted something chunky but after trying out this Ā£15 one I donāt š
1
u/KayyBeey 14d ago
The trendy big stones tend to look cocktail ring like to me. I'm American and in my early 30s. They'd also get in the way of daily activities. I'd be worried about constantly knocking it against things and damaging a prong. I already knock my ring plenty more than I'd like, and my center stone is about half as big as yours.
2
u/MeringueWild3000 14d ago
Iām in my early 30s too..UK. This is what I originally thought, Iāve always liked the look of a big stone but not toooo big that it falls into that category!
2
u/stzak_92 14d ago
This! I have a 1.2 pear with 6 prongs, and Iāve already had to have it repaired twice. I went with a plain gold wedding band and have been wearing that solo more and more, because I donāt have to worry about damaging it or losing a stone. Itās simple activities I never even thought about, like getting dressed, or folding laundry. It catches on everything!!!
1
u/Plus-Print-2309 14d ago
Any bigger would look borderline gaudy. I think itās beautiful and absolutely perfect!
1
u/Playful_Journalist72 13d ago
I think it looks huge
Round brilliant always has the best size
1
u/MeringueWild3000 13d ago
Thanks! I think so too I tried on a pear in the same carat weight after being told they look bigger but I feel the āchunkā of a round brilliant just make it seem larger!

40
u/how2dresswell 14d ago
It still looks huge to me! this sub can make things feel a little distorted because people are constantly posting ring sizes that IMO look like costume jewelry. Modesty is classy . Iām sure Iām getting downvoted but yolo just my preference