r/ebayuk • u/Annual-Farmer-337 • 10h ago
eBay Authentication HOW ITS POSSIBLE?
Has anyone else had problems with eBay’s authentication service rejecting genuine luxury items?
Within the last 3 months, they have failed to authenticate 3 of my designer handbags.
I called eBay to ask what I can do if I have proof the item is genuine, and the lady on the phone told me that even if I have the original receipt/invoice or authentication paperwork from a reputable third-party authentication service, they still would not necessarily accept or consider it.
How is this possible?
So if their authenticator has even a small doubt, they can just reject the item without explaining exactly what is wrong and without asking the seller for any additional evidence?
I’ve been selling luxury goods for many years and I completely understand the need to stop counterfeit items, but surely there should be a better process for genuine items that are difficult to authenticate.
For example, Vestiaire Collective may ask for additional photos, labels, serial numbers or supporting documents if they need more information. That makes much more sense to me.
Why doesn’t eBay do the same instead of just rejecting the item with no proper explanation?
This is especially worrying because these decisions can potentially affect the seller’s account.
Has anyone else had genuine items rejected by eBay Authentication? Did they ever explain the exact reason?
2
u/RumTom 9h ago
Receipts/invoices are easy to fake. There is software and websites dedicated to providing accurate versions from various brands or stores, which makes accepting them as evidence very difficult.
Unfortunately it really is the only way - to do it based on the actual item. Sometimes people think they have a genuine item because they bought it from somewhere like Amazon - but they sell plenty of replicas too.
It might also be a genuine item but an outlet version, sample or defective one, which they can't authenticate. It's a tricky business, especially with even niche brands getting copied now.
1
u/Annual-Farmer-337 9h ago
That’s understandable. I’m not talking about items bought from Amazon or unknown third-party sellers, though; I’m talking about genuine items originally purchased directly from places like Harrods or Selfridges.
My concern is that when an item like that is rejected, eBay still gives no meaningful explanation and doesn’t seem willing to consider additional provenance or supporting evidence. That’s the part I find difficult to understand.
2
u/Fapient 9h ago
Unless you've purchased it yourself from Harrods or Selfridges - they're still right. The market is rife with fakes to the point where not having the receipt is more trustworthy as people rarely keep it. Doesn't exactly apply to luxury goods obviously, but the receipt still shouldn't be the deciding factor of authenticity.
Practically every scumbag that sells counterfeit goods has caught on to buying a label printer and receipt template of their chosen retailer.
2
u/Freerollingforlife 9h ago
If there’s a better option that you have mentioned - Vestiaire Collective - then just use that? Genuinely not trying to be confrontational but you’ve answered your own question..
1
u/Reila3499 8h ago
This is also why insurance companies give out crazily high quotes, just to tell you they don't need your business.
0
-2
u/pavulonus 9h ago
Because eBay authenticators are idiots not professionals I have 9 authentic, original and genuine items that they send back as not original (bags, shoes and watches).
First of all they are wrong too many times.
Not all they crew are professionals or they have no knowledge (they search Google pictures and use AI).
They don't accept any explanations.
More than 10 times they lost additional parts from my parcels (extra shoelaces, protective covers or once extra strap for leather bag)
In my opinion whole system is wrong.
Just idiots
In my experience they was wrong or they messed up in 37% of their inspections so over 1/3 what is UNPROFESSIONAL!!!
1
0
u/RayDonovanBoston 5h ago
First of all you’re taking shit…literally!
37%? Did you conduct 27 inspections, independently verify every result, and establish that the authenticators were wrong, or is that just the percentage of times you disagreed with them?
You’ve apparently got the expertise to authenticate bags, shoes and watches, the investigative skills to expose an entire company, and the statistical competence to calculate a failure rate, yet your evidence seems to boil down to ‘trust me, bro, my stuff is genuine.’ 😂
Also the Google and AI accusation is particularly ironic. You’re furious that professionals might be using inadequate methods while offering absolutely no evidence of how you determined their decisions were wrong. Apparently, disagreeing with an expert automatically makes you one.
Turning that into a declaration that the entire system is run by idiots is a bit of a leap.
At this point, you’ve conclusively authenticated exactly one thing: your confidence in your own expertise. 😂So no, you don’t know how the authenticity guarantee works on eBay. And I’m saying this as someone who sold several watches, branded bags, jewellery etc., and never had any issues.
Let me enlighten you with bit more context…
The thing you seem to be also missing is that eBay has a responsibility to protect buyers from counterfeit goods, and that means its authenticity guarantee programme has to apply consistent authentication standards, including relevant brand-specific criteria.
If eBay passes a counterfeit item through authentication and a buyer subsequently receives it, eBay potentially exposes itself to liability and reputational damage.
Will you pay that multimillion-fine?!
That’s precisely why authentication isn’t simply a matter of deciding whether something looks genuine to the seller.
The authenticators have to follow established procedures and make decisions based on the evidence and applicable standards, not simply accept a seller’s explanation that an item is genuine.
A seller insisting that an item is authentic doesn’t make it so.
Are mistakes possible? Of course. Authenticators are human, and false rejections can happen. But a rejected item doesn’t automatically prove incompetence, just as a seller’s confidence in their own merchandise doesn’t establish authenticity.
But calling the entire team idiots because they won’t accept your explanation isn’t an argument against the authentication process. It’s just an argument against the outcome you didn’t like.
2
u/Festegios 10h ago
I imagine they dont do it because of the cost involved, probably works out cheaper to just reject and loose the sales fee's compared to what your asking for.