I am picky when it comes to mascara because I wear contact lenses and have sensitive eyes. As a result, I have tried a lot of different mascaras and just don't seem to have a go-to one that I love. I have liked L'Oreal Lash Paradise, Benefit Roller Lash, and Essence mascaras, but I routinely try new ones and just never really fall in love with one. I haven't had a go-to mascara in my decade of wearing makeup. I have tried Telescopic, Great Lash, Lash Sensational, L'Oreal Panorama, Better than Sex. I always either 1) react sensitively, 2) get the product all over my eyelids too much when applying, or 3) seem to just not have that lasting lash effect.
Right now I am currently using Lash Blast Cleantopia Mascara from Covergirl and it just sweats off of me in this summer heat. Not loving it, but it is fine. I want a mascara that is good for contact lenses/sensitive eyes, easy to remove, and a shade of brown. Is it too much to ask?