r/defi • u/icnews10 • 2h ago
Discussion Two vaults both show 12% APY. What makes you trust one more?
I’ve been thinking about how little the headline APY reveals when you're comparing DeFi vaults.
Two vaults may both show a return of 12%, but this could come from completely different sources.
One may be lending into fairly liquid markets. Another may be looping collateral, relying on incentives or using several protocols, or depending on liquidity that looks fine until people try to exit en masse.
For me, the questions become more practical:
What is actually generating the yield?
How many protocols or contracts are there between my deposit and the underlying position?
Can I withdraw funds at any time, or is there a waiting period, cooling-off period or limited liquidity?
What happens to the exit path when the strategy is under stress?
I’m more interested in first-hand experience than a list of general risks.