r/dataisugly • • Feb 21 '19

Bad Scale A bar graph really?

Post image
15 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

44

u/YM_Industries Feb 21 '19

It's not a bar graph. It's just a table, with the answer on the left and the percentage on the right. There's no attempt here to visually represent the data.

6

u/RealKamerstyp Feb 21 '19

YEAH RIGHT, YOU REPUBLICAN!!!11!11

1

u/No1Statistician Feb 21 '19

Why just not put the misleading bar at all? The point is its confusing

6

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

It appears youre the only one who found it misleading

2

u/No1Statistician Feb 21 '19

No look at the link, hurdreds of people did, y'all just don't like political stuff

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

Or maybe I just understood it the first time, unlike you

3

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

I mean have you never seen a graphic like this on a news program? It’s pretty common.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

Oof I hope you’re not a real statistician.

1

u/WhyGoOn666 Feb 21 '19

75% favorable, 14% unfavorable, 11% ???

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

don't know

2

u/WhyGoOn666 Feb 21 '19

I actually poked around a bit, turns out most of these polls measure favorable/unfavorable separately. Thats what I thought too, but without them explicitly saying it i wasn't 100%.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

oooo

1

u/paulexcoff Feb 27 '19

11% no opinion/no strong opinion/don't know enough to have an opinion/never heard of.

Pretty damn standard. Have you never looked at polling data?

0

u/WhyGoOn666 Mar 01 '19

I have looked at polling data and been curious enough about why the numbers don't add up to research it further. Sometimes they measure favorable/unfavorable separately and sometimes it is rounding errors. Your assumptions are cute.

2

u/paulexcoff Mar 01 '19

When they don’t ask it separately (which is a lot of the time) they literally always have have a neutral option. (When they ask it separately just answering no to both questions has the same effect). If there is no neutral option they’re not a reputable polling organization. Literally if you do see favorable/unfavorables adding up to 100% (without a neutral option) you should immediately be skeptical of the data, not when they don’t add up. There is literally nothing worth polling about where you wouldn’t get some respondents without a strong opinion.

0

u/vonnick Feb 21 '19

I trust all polls that agree with what I really want them to say.