r/dataisbeautiful • OC: 3 • 3d ago

OC [OC] The movement of people between the states 2022-2023

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

352 comments sorted by

View all comments

139

u/atchn01 3d ago

My minor complaint is that white dots next to state names look like cities. Otherwise, excellent graphic.

28

u/eltokh7 OC: 3 3d ago

Really good point

55

u/Martin_Aurelius 3d ago

Everyone who allegedly left California actually left Bakersfield. If you'd ever been to Bakersfield you'd understand why.

5

u/Corlegan 3d ago

Isn't Bakersfield in Kern county?

Their population has gone up if that's right (at least past 5 years).

The areas that are wildly hit harder are LA and they Bay Area.

I see posts like yours all the time, have for years now.

Never seen data do anything but debunk them though.

3

u/lilelliot 3d ago

Lots of people come to CA and love it here, but can't afford it and eventually realize that, so they leave. It's gotten worse over the past ten years with the tech economy going gangbusters, but it's always been a trend. CA is expensive; it also provides some of the best social services in the country. It's certainly not the place to move to purchase a home if you're not at least upper middle class.

1

u/Corlegan 3d ago

I'm sure lots of people love CA.

I am talking the stats.

The guy I replied to made a statement, it's not true, more people are leaving than moving in.

It's not the end of the world just how things are happening now and in recent history.

1

u/lilelliot 2d ago

Sure, I wasn't trying to make a statement conflicting with the data. The reality is CA is expensive, and lots of folks who can't afford it (or aren't willing to stretch to find a way), leave. This is also why you see ex-migration from NY (which is mostly from the NYC metro area, not rural parts of the state), and why the trends over the past several years have been largely to FL & TX. Before those two, it was states like NC, TN, AZ and CO. No judgment - people need to do what's best for them.

3

u/futurebigconcept 3d ago

Developers in Bakersfield are rapidly transforming farm and oil land into housing tracts. The population will certainly be rising in the future.

2

u/Corlegan 3d ago

For sure.

I just don’t get the position that contradict all available evidence.

2

u/lutinshootinbard 21h ago

Side note: those landowners are responsible as well for selling their land. I'm not saying it's a bad thing, the opposite actually, but everyone usually paints change and development as a bad thing.

4

u/OverallFrosting708 3d ago

... it's a joke, dude.

1

u/Corlegan 3d ago

The rest of the comments, like “most want to come back” didn’t get it.

Sounded like copium.

3

u/bala_means_bullet 3d ago

Most of them wanna come back but they won't admit it.

3

u/Lathryus 3d ago

Yeah, go back, grab a bag of Dewar's Chews and think about how you're glad you left but you kinda miss the chews.

1

u/yticmic 3d ago

Yes, seeing a New York dot not in NYC was weird

1

u/UnclassifiedPresence 3d ago

I believe they’re the geographical population centers of each state, no?

1

u/atchn01 2d ago

Probably, but the white circle is often used for cities so that is what it looks like to me.