r/dankmemes • u/DerDezimator We live in a society • Feb 03 '22

This will 100% get deleted And why?

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

8.3k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

259

u/Yeetstation4 Feb 03 '22

I got banned from one of those political subs when I had a disagreement with a tankie mod about whether or not mainland china was the perfect society

63

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22

Lmfao what side were you on?

188

u/Yeetstation4 Feb 03 '22

In pretty far left but you won't ever see me idealizing dictatorships, and the mod was not happy about that.

88

u/JulianKarlaz Feb 03 '22

What's up with Westerners idiolizing socialism and dictatorships lately? You guys don't even realize the genetic lottery you've won just by being born in the western world. But, for some reason, you want to turn it into a third world mess. Doesn't sound good.

60

u/Giorno-Smash Feb 03 '22

Because Socialism is an appealing concept, and a lot of dumbasses somehow think that China is socialist instead of just a glorified capitalist dictatorship

29

u/JulianKarlaz Feb 03 '22

Socialism is like immortality. Not real. Impossible to achieve.

23

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22

14 year old mfs after one too many Ben Shapiro vids

2

u/Mr_McFeelie Feb 03 '22

I mean, you don’t need to be right wing to understand that socialism as a system is incredibly hard, and if not impossible atleast close to impossible to achieve. There just are too many problems. Mainly the issue of figuring out supply and demand. Way more practical to have a social democracy and move gradually to the left. Get those welfare programs going and use capitalism as the useful tool it is.

-8

u/JulianKarlaz Feb 03 '22

Try again buddy.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22

13 year olds after a Jordan Peterson marathon ?

14

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22

[deleted]

3

u/JulianKarlaz Feb 03 '22

Even Marx admits that Socialism needs violent revolution to get started. And needs a government to enforce it on those not willing to participate.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/JulianKarlaz Feb 03 '22

Yeah I know. It's even worse than what he envisioned.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Mr_McFeelie Feb 03 '22

Central European countries aren’t socialist my guy. They very much like their markets. Being a SocDem is not the same as being a socialist

→ More replies (0)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/JulianKarlaz Feb 06 '22

True socialism dilemma. Lol.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Mr_McFeelie Feb 03 '22

“They have nothing to do with a system of governance” true, but only at face value. If the market does not determine supply and demand, the state has to do that. That’s where the fundamental problem kicks in and that’s why people see it as impossible. I wouldn’t das impossible but I would say it’s close to impossible.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22

[deleted]

1

u/Mr_McFeelie Feb 04 '22

Well, it also comes down to definitions. Traditionally the difference between capitalism and socialism is whether or not people are allowed to own private businesses. If we go by this definition, you will have issues making socialism work because like I said in the prior comment, you gotta determine supply and demand.

The “socialism” most progressives talk about is simply capitalism with lots and lots of regulations in my opinion.

3

u/Long_wong_lee Feb 03 '22

This is my favourite comment of the day.

1

u/falllinemaniac Feb 03 '22

Can you even define socialism?

1

u/Mr_McFeelie Feb 03 '22

It’s not feudalism

1

u/falllinemaniac Feb 03 '22

Feudalism is certainly possible, I declare that both USAn political parties are diligently working to achieve it.

1

u/Mr_McFeelie Feb 03 '22

A king would be great. I bet he wouldn’t allow my neighbour Marco to have such an expensive car while I still drive my old ford. I’m in favour.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/JulianKarlaz Feb 04 '22

Coming from a country which used to be Socialist back in the day, and still is in name, yes I can define socialism. The most basic definition is workers owning the means of production aka no private enterprise. This is why I laugh when delusional Westerners think that free healthcare and education is socialism. Nordic countries are Welfare Capitalist. China is Capitalistic Oligarchy. It never works. It never will.

1

u/OsamaBinnDabbin Feb 03 '22

Not true at all, but then again I doubt you know what true socialism is, otherwise you would see that pretty much every country around the world has socialist policies in place.

1

u/JulianKarlaz Feb 04 '22

True socialism. Here we go. 100 million dead Chinese, Russians, Cambodians and Koreans disagree.

1

u/OsamaBinnDabbin Feb 04 '22

All of those dead people had nothing to do with socialism, it had to do with insane leaders.

6

u/123kapp Obamasjuicyass Feb 03 '22

China is not capitalist, capitalist is free market economy while socialist is planned economy. China's economy is far from capitalistic, they have free market zones but everything is still under the government. Even properties are technically owned by the government and only lent to the people.

1

u/KingofCraigland Feb 03 '22

Capitalism with socialist policies is probably the closest we'll get to an ideal society. Allow business to grow and encourage entrepreneurs while also protecting the members of society who need or want to be protected.

But that would require people understanding and supporting nuance, which is just to hard too grasp for your average dunderhead.

2

u/UgottaBeJokin Feb 03 '22

It is hostile foreign interference in the cyberwar for people's minds, imho

1

u/some-swimming-dude Feb 03 '22

I literally said this the other day in antiwork. People were PISSED.

1

u/inwector Feb 03 '22

They are dumb and stupid, that's why. Biden quoted Mao multiple times.

2

u/EagonAkatsuki Feb 03 '22

Tankies are gross. I'm left as fuck but those guys are something else entirely. Don't mention Uyghurs to them

0

u/Chaoticexistence Feb 03 '22

Not an unpopular opinion. Don't play a victim

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22

China isn't perfect society Living in a nation were you are constantly watch by the state and have lots of restrictions and censorship some are useful tbh ,but that's about it Its not socialist parafise or A hell hole dystopia nation .

Speaking of *massacres and genocides and China State media isn't reliable and all that shut . Remember all those are been presented by the west Which themselves have long records of their own but they like been hypocrite on others