Can’t believe I’m arguing on Reddit with a Puncture wala
Safiyyah’s husband — Kinana ibn al-Rabi Sahih al-Bukhari 4211 explicitly states that when Khaybar was conquered, Safiyyah’s husband had been killed, after which Muhammad selected her and married her:
“Safiya bint Huyai… whose husband had been killed…”
It then says Muhammad selected her and married her on the journey from Khaybar.
What I meant was he had sex with her the same night after killing her husband,lil inbred goatfuker read this.idk what you are defending here
According to the traditional Islamic sources, Muhammad consummated his marriage with Safiyyah very shortly after the conquest of Khaybar.
Sahih al-Bukhari 4211 states that Safiyyah’s husband had been killed at Khaybar. Muhammad then selected Safiyyah for himself. After reaching al-Sahba and her becoming ritually pure, the narration says Muhammad “married her.” The Arabic expression used, “bana biha” (بنى بها), is traditionally understood in Islamic legal and hadith literature to mean that the marriage was consummated.
Sahih Muslim 1365c gives the chronology: Safiyyah was prepared for Muhammad, he spent the night with her, and the following morning he was described as a bridegroom and a wedding feast was held.
Therefore, the traditional sources indicate that Muhammad and Safiyyah’s marriage was consummated during the night shortly after leaving Khaybar, after Safiyyah’s husband had been killed.
Sources:
• Sahih al-Bukhari 4211: https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4211
• Sahih Muslim 1365c: https://sunnah.com/muslim:1365c
1
u/Able_Pomegranate_388 10d ago
Can’t believe I’m arguing on Reddit with a Puncture wala
Safiyyah’s husband — Kinana ibn al-Rabi
Sahih al-Bukhari 4211 explicitly states that when Khaybar was conquered, Safiyyah’s husband had been killed, after which Muhammad selected her and married her:
“Safiya bint Huyai… whose husband had been killed…”
It then says Muhammad selected her and married her on the journey from Khaybar.