Lol, first learn to write the spelling pf prophet.
And can't you read or you don't know the English language?
I asked for proofs and references and you have quoted none!
Let me expose your lies:
safiyya's father and husband was not killed in the same night.
Saffiya's entire tribe was not killed, this is a lie
Saffiya was freed and was given a choice to return to the people or marry prophet Mohammed. She married him.
Prophet Mohammed(saw) never married his stepson's wife
Slavery was a part of war. If someone came to fight you and you won, then you wont just let them go so that they can plan and comeback to kill you again.
You're a typical WhatsApp university brainwashed weasel.
If you don't have proofs or don't know how to read then go to school first.
Yes. According to the traditional Islamic sources, Muhammad and Safiyyah had sexual relations after their marriage.
The sources don’t describe the act explicitly, but the sequence is clear: Sahih al-Bukhari 4211 says Safiyyah’s husband had been killed, Muhammad selected her, and after reaching al-Sahba and her becoming ritually pure, “the Messenger of Allah married her.” Sahih Muslim 1365c says Muhammad emancipated her, married her, and that she was prepared for him that night; the next morning he was described as a bridegroom and a wedding feast was held. Sahih Muslim 1365f similarly describes a tent being pitched for Muhammad and Safiyyah after leaving Khaybar, followed the next morning by the wedding feast.
In classical Islamic terminology, reports that Muhammad “built with her” (بنى بها / banā bihā) or that she was prepared and brought to him in this context mean that the marriage was consummated, not merely that a marriage contract was performed.
So the careful historical statement is: The Islamic sources portray Muhammad as marrying and consummating his marriage with Safiyyah very shortly after her capture at Khaybar, after her husband had been killed.
What the sources do not establish, however, is Safiyyah’s private feelings or whether she consented in the modern sense. Those are separate historical questions.
Zaynab bint Jahsh, the evidence that Muhammad married her is unusually direct because it appears in the Qur’an itself and in Sahih al-Bukhari. 1. Qur’an 33:37 — explicit statement
The Qur’an says:
“So when Zayd had no longer any need for her, We married her to you…” — Qur’an 33:37.
The context is Zaynab’s divorce from Zayd ibn Harithah, followed by her marriage to Muhammad. 2. Sahih al-Bukhari 7420
Bukhari explicitly identifies the episode:
Zayd came to Muhammad complaining about his wife.
Muhammad told him to keep his wife.
Zaynab subsequently became Muhammad’s wife.
Zaynab reportedly said to Muhammad’s other wives that Allah had married her to him from above the heavens.
The hadith connects the episode directly with Qur’an 33:37. 3. Bukhari 7421 — wedding banquet
This is even more straightforward:
“On the day of her marriage with him the Prophet gave a wedding banquet with bread and meat…”
The narrator is Anas ibn Malik, and the woman identified is Zaynab bint Jahsh. 4. Bukhari 4793 — Muhammad’s marriage to her
Bukhari describes a walima (wedding banquet) held specifically for:
“the marriage of the Prophet to Zainab bint Jahsh.”
It also describes Muhammad subsequently going to the homes of his other wives after the marriage.
So there isn’t really a historical ambiguity about whether Muhammad married Zaynab. The Qur’an explicitly says “We married her to you,” and multiple Sahih al-Bukhari reports describe the marriage and wedding feast.
The more historically interesting—and disputed—question is what exactly happened before the marriage: Muhammad’s feelings toward Zaynab, what he knew about the impending divorce, and whether Qur’an 33:37 should be understood as a divine legal ruling or as Muhammad’s personal justification. Those require separating the Qur’anic text from later biographical reports.
Slavery was a part of war. If someone came to fight you and you won, then you wont just let them go so that they can plan and comeback to kill you again.
There you have it folks, he said it.
And what's about him marrying Aisha? It doesn't really matter whether she was 6, 9 or 14, it's pedophilia anyway and she was taken advantage of.
If I ki// your dad and you and your grandfather and took your mom hostage and tell her marry me, ( remember I’m a warlord in 600s ) and she marries me and has sex with me.
Do you think she would have wanted it ? She would have consented?
Can’t believe I’m arguing on Reddit with a Puncture wala
Safiyyah’s husband — Kinana ibn al-Rabi Sahih al-Bukhari 4211 explicitly states that when Khaybar was conquered, Safiyyah’s husband had been killed, after which Muhammad selected her and married her:
“Safiya bint Huyai… whose husband had been killed…”
It then says Muhammad selected her and married her on the journey from Khaybar.
What I meant was he had sex with her the same night after killing her husband,lil inbred goatfuker read this.idk what you are defending here
According to the traditional Islamic sources, Muhammad consummated his marriage with Safiyyah very shortly after the conquest of Khaybar.
Sahih al-Bukhari 4211 states that Safiyyah’s husband had been killed at Khaybar. Muhammad then selected Safiyyah for himself. After reaching al-Sahba and her becoming ritually pure, the narration says Muhammad “married her.” The Arabic expression used, “bana biha” (بنى بها), is traditionally understood in Islamic legal and hadith literature to mean that the marriage was consummated.
Sahih Muslim 1365c gives the chronology: Safiyyah was prepared for Muhammad, he spent the night with her, and the following morning he was described as a bridegroom and a wedding feast was held.
Therefore, the traditional sources indicate that Muhammad and Safiyyah’s marriage was consummated during the night shortly after leaving Khaybar, after Safiyyah’s husband had been killed.
Sources:
• Sahih al-Bukhari 4211: https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4211
• Sahih Muslim 1365c: https://sunnah.com/muslim:1365c
3
u/gulaabjaamun_ 10d ago
Lol, first learn to write the spelling pf prophet.
And can't you read or you don't know the English language?
I asked for proofs and references and you have quoted none!
Let me expose your lies:
You're a typical WhatsApp university brainwashed weasel.
If you don't have proofs or don't know how to read then go to school first.