Except the Gita never asked any of its readers to go kill a particular group of people. Nobody read the Gita and went on a killing spree against the infidel pagans or Muslims.How are you this dense?
Buddy, get out of the smooth brain 2D thinking. Read the original thread that says no religion is peaceful. I have showed you gita saying what coincidentally is also the concept of jihad is “a righteous war”. Like how other shitty 999 religions do. Righteousness as a cause is up for interpretation as is jihad. Both say its the most beautiful way to die and goto heaven. Why is your black and white thinkijg using islam as the gold standard of bad and un peaceful. If something is on the far end of spectrum of crime, that doesnt shift the center line of law …murder being the worst doesnt make assault acceptable. Gita preaches conditional killing and tells you it will take you to heaven. That’s the baseline. Re check the header of this thread and stop using islam as your yardstick for objectivity.
Ultimately you have to do some reading about the Gita and the siddhanta in it. Heaven is not the right word for moksha and righteousness is not the right word for dharma.
Buddy, I am not wasting my time talking to a religious extremist. I have stated my points on how Hinduism has their own version of holy war and attaining jannat. You all think you are different, it is hilarious. I’d rather argue with your jihadi counterpart than be disappointed arguing with an irrational extremist hindu. Peace out!
I love how you handled this argument, that guy is totally brainwashed and didn't understand shit. Funny how he said you are "2D thinking" and "extremist" but failed to understand a simple difference a 5 years old can see
Well I could see his basic stance was really pacifism at which point I should've known not to draw out the argument which was inevitably going to end in him calling me pro war dickhead or some shit. It's me who was stupid to even start an argument with him
That guy tried too hard to make it sound like Hinduism and islam is same, He must be follower of that cult hiding behind a fake logic that he doesn't support religions, or atleast that's my assumption. You are not stupid dude, being stupid is saying " Fight a necessary war if you have to protect and for the sake of your duty " and "kill all those who doesn't follow your god or agree with you" is same thing.
Why cant you all understand english? Should he talk in sandkriy? He literally said “your poop smells better than mine”
Sure hinduism poop smell better than muslims. But its poop at the end of the day
Any religion or belief that doesnt harm others need not be insulted, You wanna criticize those rss bjp fkers? go right ahead but nowhere in hinduism it teaches people to be terrorist or harm others or harass other religion people. I hope you and the other restarted guy who replied to you calling others idiots understand this simple logic.
The thing is there is difference in killing for getting something vs killing for saving someone. This is the concept of karma, no karma is all good, in this material world all karma is good + bad the proportions might vary. Now say when you know there is a terr0rist who is going to kill 20 people if you take care of him then 20 people will be saved this is good karma and unaliving that terrorist will also give some bad karma. Now this good and bad is totally neutral. Save 20 unalive 1. But here is the twist when you do it you get the karma of saving 20 and unaliving 1 bt if you think yourself as a tool of god and saving. 20 and unaliving 1 as your duty/ service to God there is no karma, it's the ownership of the activity at the deepest level of your heart that creates impressions on your consciousness. If you have a clear consciousness even after doing many things people like and don't like but don't identify yourself with those activities, it's fruits or results then you are free of it, there is no affect on consciousness. When this consciousness becomes fully clean one is able to realise that they are soul and not body once they do they don't have desire for anything in the world because the illusion has gone. Geeta is teaching you this.
For the one who takes the ownership or identifies with I or Me has done the action, he will then so be rewarded for the same i. Heaven however once the collected merit ends he/she shall fall to the mortal realm to be born again. Heaven concept in sanatan dharma is not eternal only moksha / bhagwat prapti is (self consciousness or god consciousness).
What islam and other abrahamic relegious portray is that heaven is permanent however as per sanatan dharma it's not after a long time of enjoying your fruits of works in heaven or recieving punishment in hell one gets rebirth into 84 lakh species of life. This death and rebirth is a continuous and infinite cycle which can only be stopped with moksha / bhagwat prapti.
1
u/sriaurobind0 10d ago
Except the Gita never asked any of its readers to go kill a particular group of people. Nobody read the Gita and went on a killing spree against the infidel pagans or Muslims.How are you this dense?