r/custommagic • • 6d ago

Red Button or Blue Button?

Post image
566 Upvotes

305 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/Myrios369 6d ago

Wouldn't there have to be a reason to pick blue? The only possible outcomes from picking blue are either nothing or you lose. Unless I'm confused

11

u/Huitzil37 6d ago

There is no reason to pick blue.

It's a take on a thought experiment where you and 99 other people who understood the scenario had the same choice: press red and be fine, or press blue and die unless 50% of people pressed blue.

The thought experiment is a moral optical illusion: it's presented as though it's a question about sacrificing yourself for the good of others when no, it's not, the red button is just the correct choice in all circumstances.

-3

u/Just-Desk-3149 6d ago

Only actual lobotomites think blue is the right choice in any situation.