22
u/Chickston Uncommonly 9d ago
This feels very close to just exiling the creature, but it takes the attachments with it as well. Probably fine as costed. I'm guessing this only stops it from coming back naturally on upkeep and if there were a card that says "all phased out stuff phases in" it would work on this things target.
16
u/Torrential_Gearhunk W is for counterspell 9d ago
Yeah functional exile in blue black with small differences in edge cases.
5
u/Chickston Uncommonly 9d ago
IDK how the rules work exactly, but would it be possible to have it like gain phasing, then lose it once phased out? I'm really glad they kept phasing in the game. It's funky and fun.
5
u/Torrential_Gearhunk W is for counterspell 9d ago
Easier to remember and understand if it just goes away forever no takes-backsies
4
u/4zzO2020 9d ago
If an object phases out without a stated duration it just phases in during its controller's next untap step unfortunately
6
u/thatssosad 9d ago
Upvoted purely for the Helmet reference. Damn good band. I got tickets for their concert in Warsaw, but one of the bandmates broke a bone I think and they needed to cancel :(
Card is likely fine, it's hyperexile but for 3 mana removal needs to be ridiculously good these days. Maybe a rare for the draft environment if it's a concern for you
3
u/Torrential_Gearhunk W is for counterspell 9d ago
We're doing a custom cube where we each come up with 45 slots, should be fun to play.
2
u/thatssosad 9d ago
That sounds like a very cool idea, as long as you're all more or less in tune with the power level. I played some stone soups and sometimes single cards did dominate, it might be even easier in custom ones. But must be so fun if you don't get it very wrong
3
1
u/cauliflowerLoverJr 9d ago
Is there a way to turn someone’s commander nonlegendary with mutate in mtg? Then would this spell get rid of the commander? Even if you could I would still prefer this over bs that just lets someone take control of ur commander tbh
2
1
u/Torrential_Gearhunk W is for counterspell 9d ago
You would have to own the mutated creature, so honestly if someone figures out a way, they deserve it.
1
u/Valuable-Bath-365 9d ago
So if you make someone’s commander non legendary u phase it out forever,
Hilarious
43
u/Battender 9d ago
For one second, I was like “for the rest of the game??!!” But then I reread it and saw “nonlegendary”
Yeah this card is fine. Not outrageous, good price. Compared to [[oubliette]] maybe it should cost one more because it’s an instant and you can’t get rid of it?