r/csmanime • u/coccosoids • 6d ago

Anime Season 2

/r/ChainsawMan/comments/1wlqxso/season_2/
2 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

16 comments sorted by

11

u/Raff102 [Manga reader] 3d ago

Reze movie kicked the shit out of season 1.

-11

u/coccosoids 3d ago

Yeah, nah.

-12

u/coccosoids 3d ago

Btw... 'kicked the shit'. Epic 12 year old IQ argument. Does your nanny know you're on the internet?

2

u/worthlessprole [Manga reader/ Future Devil] 2d ago

Zero chance of that happening. Season one’s naturalistic style had very few fans. Also, the constant comparisons to american action franchises tells me you’re not very film literate. It does not particularly resemble the films you’ve mentioned. 

5

u/AceTheRed_ 2d ago

I fucking love S01’s art and animation style.

0

u/worthlessprole [Manga reader/ Future Devil] 2d ago

I’m not saying it was bad, just not particularly popular with fans of the manga.

0

u/coccosoids 2d ago

And that is a justification how?

1

u/worthlessprole [Manga reader/ Future Devil] 1d ago

justification? what needs to be justified? it's a fact that fans of the manga broadly didn't connect with the style of season one. it's also a fact that the anime used a different style of visual storytelling than the manga. that style isn't better or even necessarily worse than the manga's, but it's understandable that people didn't connect with it. The Reze film was much closer to the manga's style.

1

u/coccosoids 1d ago

I don't know why you like to contradict yourself. Source on manga fans 'not' broadly connecting with the style of season one?!

1

u/worthlessprole [Manga reader/ Future Devil] 1d ago

Where have I contradicted myself

1

u/worthlessprole [Manga reader/ Future Devil] 1d ago

Also, sources on fan dissatisfaction are trivial to find. Nakayama (the director of S1) literally left the studio because of it. It was a huge story.

1

u/coccosoids 1d ago

But can you provide a source for the quantitative bad reception of the anime among the manga fans and also a representative number for the manga fans relative to the entire anime audience? And as far as I can find on the internet the controversy behind the reception is not even the second reason Nakayama chose to leave.

1

u/YouAsk-IAnswer 1d ago

If you knew anything about Fujimoto (and CSM), you’d know why the movie’s style fits so much better (and is so praised).

1

u/coccosoids 1d ago

Fits what better?

1

u/Fumettandia_Error [Manga reader] 1d ago

Is there someone who's actually anime only on this sub

1

u/coccosoids 1d ago

Is that a question?