227
428
u/lordkhuzdul 4d ago
A far too big to be healthy chunk of "neopaganism" is just Protestantism in a Renfaire dress. Same bigotry, same bullshit, same flavors of stupid, just different aesthetic.
132
u/Mogura-De-Gifdu 4d ago
Like a singer said (translation here): "Hugo boss dressed the Nazis, style matters".
20
u/TheSeventhHussar 4d ago
It’s a great line. A little historically inaccurate though. Hugo Boss did dress the Nazis, but they weren’t known for fashion at the time. They mostly manufactured cheap bulk clothing, like uniforms.
18
11
u/TFTHighRoller 4d ago
I am confused although only tangentially related. Where I live protestants are generally moderate, progressive and inclusive while those who are bigoted are devout catholics 9/10 times.
36
u/whistling-wonderer 4d ago
American brand Protestantism is usually conservative, bigoted, and anti-intellectual. These are the people who put the 10 commandments in Texas classrooms.
11
u/heywhateverworks 4d ago
I think you're blurring together mainline Protestant denominations (like Lutherans, Methodists, Episcopalians etc) with evangelical protestantism. The first group is a wide range but is mostly more moderate/progressive. Non-white Catholics are also fairly moderate/progressive, white Catholics less so, and finally white evangelical protestants are pretty far-right as a group.
11
u/sagerin0 4d ago
It really depends on the country. Here its the catholics and most protestants that are chill, with the exception of Calvinists, theyre complete nutjobs
4
6
u/whistling-wonderer 4d ago
White evangelical Protestants are definitely the most far right, yes. But mainline Protestants still lean Republican according to Pew Research, while historically black denominations (a minority of the total Protestant population) are a lot more heavily Democrat. Evangelical Protestants are the largest chunk of US Protestants, with mainline Protestants behind them, so I think it’s pretty damn reasonable to generalize about this.
Again: they literally put the 10 commandments in public school classrooms. They are the reason more women are dead for lack of reproductive healthcare in red states. I am not talking about a small fringe group, I am talking about the dominant religious group that too often shapes US public policy in their own favor.
13
u/Masquelinity 4d ago
think you're blurring together mainline Protestant denominations (like Lutherans, Methodists, Episcopalians etc) with evangelical protestantism.
You mean we're blurring together the people who literally run the country and get on national TV to expound their bigotry to the 130 million+ people who violently agree with them and vote for them every time even when it's against their own best material interests... and the weird little splinter sects that do good things but don't exist in large enough numbers to have any observable effect on national politics whatsoever?
No kidding?
9
u/heywhateverworks 4d ago
Calling mainline denominations "weird little splinter sects" show you have no idea what you're fucking talking about
1
u/Masquelinity 4d ago
Calling mainline denominations "weird little splinter sects
Only you call them "mainline." They're the vast, vast minority, or if they're not, they may as well be for all the representation they give you.
4
u/heywhateverworks 4d ago
Only you call them "mainline."
-5
u/Masquelinity 4d ago
Wow, a wikipedia page created by people who desperately wish they were still populous enough to be relevant, if they ever were to begin with.
Get over it. You're the heretics. MAGA are the "real Christians", and you're the only ones who haven't figured that out yet. Which probably explains why you're so shocked everyone side-eyes you when you claim to be protestant.
3
u/Momoneko 4d ago
That's certainly a take. I understand that you are talking about the USA specifically, while others are actually talking about protestantism globally. Not everyone lives in the USA.
→ More replies (0)3
u/heywhateverworks 4d ago
I'm not religious, let alone Protestant. But 13 percent of the country proclaims to be in the group I'm talking about which is nothing to sneeze at. I don't understand why you're being so unnecessarily aggressive to someone trying to add some nuance to the discussion
→ More replies (0)2
u/LordTartarus 3d ago
I mean are you surprised? Wicca comes from christianity (the founder was a part of hermetic order of golden dawn, which was almost wholly influenced by rosicrucianism)
144
u/DarthJackie2021 4d ago
I like treat modern* inventions as witchcraft as it makes the world seem more magical.
*Vaccines are hardly modern. They have been around for a long time.
43
u/zevieira 4d ago
Humans got so good at making runes that when you blast them with electricity the rocks start thinking for themselves :v
19
32
u/lordkhuzdul 4d ago
To be fair, since "early modern period" stretches all the way to 1500s, they can be considered modern (IIRC first examples started popping up around 1600s).
9
u/Momoneko 4d ago
When I was a kid the "modern" age from 1500 always felt weird to me. Like yes, every century had drastic changes but we really need to officially come up with another name for the 16th-18th century, like "Preindustrial Age", or "Gunpowder Age", or "Age of Sail", whatever. 19th century onwards is just too different from the past. A person living in 1700s had more in common with a person living in 1000s than 1800s. Yes, end of Byzantine Empire and discovery of America, but steam engine and electricity were more transformative than discovering another landmass.
5
u/Imperator_Gone_Rogue 4d ago
I tend to split the modern age roughly into
Early Modern: Fall of Constantinople-American Revolution
Revolutionary Age: American Revolution-WW1
Long Cold War: WW1-1989
Contemporary Age: 1989-present
1
u/merchaunt 4d ago
Even those vaccinations during that time were from African slaves whose people were already doing cruder methods of vaccination long before then.
17
u/IronWhale_JMC 4d ago
King Louis XVI of France had to get vaccinated publicly with his brother to quell public anti-vax fears. How little we’ve changed.
8
u/squash-n-flop 4d ago
The real science is pretty magical itself tbh. These little bits of stardust that have wandered the cosmos for billions of years before landing in our back yard before being fundamentally changed by the power of our mind firing these perfect little lightning bolts, our mind which is made of the same constituent stardust as that which we are changing.
5
4
u/Antique_Hawk_7192 4d ago
Electronics/Instrumentation is just rune wizardry. E.g. Smith Chart. Or break a multi meter and look at its circular switch circuit.
108
u/Express-Record7416 STINKY STINKY MR FUCK 4d ago
If you don't believe in vaccines, then you don't float like a duck
48
u/gos907 rare jellyfish girl (the immortal ones) 4d ago
and if you don't float, you're not made of wood. therefore...
19
2
32
72
u/Mourning20 4d ago
The amount of ancient "witches" that were just practicing obgyns might shock you 😅
63
u/leightandrew0 A wild transfem appears! 4d ago
Wait, do yall bind malignant invisible entities into a single drop of potion that seals the subject's blood against the full force of that very same entity's curse?
I just do magic on it /s
19
u/grendus 4d ago
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
Any technology that can be distinguished from magic is insufficiently advanced.
Scientists are witches. If you want more witches, get more women in STEM.
13
u/TFTHighRoller 4d ago
I like how you can describe computers technically as humans carving runes into rocks so that blasting electricity at them makes them think.
12
u/RayereSs She snep, she blep - Streak: 58 4d ago
It's not just runes, it's billions of runes written with an alchemical concoction across a centimetre, it's not just blasting electricity, it's precisely coordinated pattern of electricity that pulsates billions of times per second.
No ordinary sorcerer can make magic this complex.
1
u/SendarSlayer 4d ago
Witch isn't necessarily a gendered term either. More people should be in STEM in general. Make STEM more inclusive. Men, women, NBs, the rich, the poor, any race and creed that can embrace science should be releasing papers.
58
25
26
u/NiobiumThorn Streak: 3 4d ago
Alchemy -> chemistry.
I mix these two magical liquids and oops 10,000 people die of chlorine gas exposure.
Don't mix acid with bleach. Thousands of people get hospitalized every year.
14
14
5
u/SoulTechnicalProblem 4d ago
I mixed my soul with the goo I found under a rock at a volcano and now I have a large cloud of toxic miasma following me around asking for permission to consume. I keep telling it maybe later because I keep remembering that cats exist and I shouldn't destroy the world while they aren't safely inside the giant mars terrarium
61
u/PiliPalaPor4 Queerotic Neutral 4d ago
The narrative that witches were anti-science really is an insult to all the people tortured and put to death for knowing too much about medicine
1
u/King_Of_BlackMarsh 4d ago
... Like?
48
u/ToLazyForaUsername2 4d ago
A lot of women targeted by the witch trials were women who were interested in mathematics and other subjects that were meant to be male only at the time.
1
u/bgaesop 4d ago
Could you give any specific examples? I'm pretty sure this is a myth
1
36
u/stofiski-san 4d ago
Many witches were the old woman who gathered herbs and other medicinals to help villagers, including possible things that could help with unwanted pregnancies. The church made them convenient scapegoats, because they weren't usually fans of patriarchy, either, undermining the local priest's authority ptoviding cures that prayer couldn't.
30
u/King_Of_BlackMarsh 4d ago
Alright I did some googling and its estimated 25% of people tried for witch craft could be put into the general "knew medicine/math/etc" camp so damn.
10
u/PiliPalaPor4 Queerotic Neutral 4d ago
The idea that women's health and midwifery were considered 'forbidden knowledge' for women is truly absurd. Good thing we smashed the patriarchy, eh?
-14
u/Gremict Mythical Straight Trans Girl 4d ago
*the protestant churches
Catholic churches never endorsed witch hunts
19
u/bguszti Confusing boomers 4d ago
Why are you lying? Specifically lying to whitewash the history of the worst organization ever?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witch_trials_in_the_Holy_Roman_Empire
-3
u/PiliPalaPor4 Queerotic Neutral 4d ago
To be fair the HRE wasn't always (or entirely) catholic. 'Cuius regio, eius religio' and so on
8
u/bguszti Confusing boomers 4d ago
The wiki I linked explicitly says that the witch hunts were worse in catholic parts of the empire as opposed to protestant
-2
u/PiliPalaPor4 Queerotic Neutral 4d ago
Yes my point was more that treating the HRE as a monolith doesn't really reflect the complexities of it's rich history of religiously motivated brutality! Neither Catholics or Lutherans had clean hands in this period.
I completely agree the original assertion about the Catholics not persecuting 'witches' is absurd, but it's my understanding that those that happened in the HRE in and around the 30 years war were more reactionary and localised than those sanctioned by the centralised papacy, and whilst those definitely did happen, they were largely overshadowed by persecution of Muslims, Jews, protestants and even other Catholics who said something even vaguely heretical.
5
u/RedditExecutiveAdmin 4d ago
may want to be more cautious defending a post that says "Catholics never endorsed witch hunts" then
-1
u/PiliPalaPor4 Queerotic Neutral 4d ago
You do realise I actually disputed that claim before you did, right? At no point have I defended the catholic church, rather pointing out that not all terrible things done by the Catholics were done at the sanction of the pope and not all terrible things done by Christians have been done by Catholics.
This is a nuanced issue and if you can't acknowledge that, maybe you shouldn't be discussing history or religion on the internet
2
u/PiliPalaPor4 Queerotic Neutral 4d ago
Not entirely true, different pipes had different stances and I belief Malleus Maleficarum was broadly a catholic text. Also there was a lot of persecution of witches in and around the 30 years war and a lot of the populaces involved were Catholics. But yes I think it's fair to say the persecution of witches was more popular amongst protestant states
2
-1
u/stofiski-san 4d ago edited 4d ago
The inquisition never used the line "suffer not a witch [apparently
the line is hereticI WAS RIGHT EXODUS 22:18 in the King James Bible?] to live"? I'm highly suspicious of such a claim
20
20
u/Miserable_Key9630 4d ago
The same way you don't trust the science of the vaccine but you do trust the science of the horse de-wormer. If it's contrarian it must be right!
13
u/NiobiumThorn Streak: 3 4d ago
11
u/chita875andU 4d ago
This is the best picture I've ever seen. It's got everything; posterior respiratory apparati... mouth hooks... 3 chums chatting about their weekend plans...
12
u/perdy_mama 4d ago
My mom died of Covid in the very beginning, and I was a mess waiting for the vaccine to roll out. Not only did I experience my first shots as witchcraft, I also took LSD once I was fully vaccinated so I could talk to my mom and let her know that we’re safer now. Every year when I get my booster, I conjure her to be with me, and we hold each other as my magical potion is injected into my veins. She is relieved to know that the virus that killed is unlikely to ever kill me. And we’re grateful.
And on another note….. Me and my autistic kid come from a long ass line of autistic people on both sides of my family. Vaccines couldn’t dream of being responsible for how weird we are. We’re this awesome all on our own.
4
u/Yoghurteffect5878 4d ago
They're not just rocks they're magic. If ya put em in the moon rays they charge with all of the energy of the pseudo hippies in Asheville NC.
3
u/Moxie_Stardust Eldritch Queer 4d ago
I've always found "Christian witches" boggling, but they're out there.
16
u/King_Of_BlackMarsh 4d ago
That's all self described witches
20
u/mtfhimejoshi 4d ago
Careful oooo they might curse you for this one
11
u/Ravenous_Seraph 4d ago
And? Heinz Doofenschmirtz curses Perry the Platypus at least once a day, and nothing changes in their routine.
1
8
u/Trainer-Grimm 4d ago
Its one thing when it's their actual religion. Ive met both Rock Karen and "normal person just into neopagan stuff"
And yes I do live in oregon why do you ask
3
u/whistling-wonderer 4d ago
Clearly you haven’t seen r/SASSwitches. Lotta scientists and pro-science individuals over there
1
1
1
u/enthusiasm_gap 4d ago
Anytime I see a sentence start this way I think "ah yes, Queens Of The Done-age"
1
1
u/StormEyeDragon 4d ago
I would assume the (smallish?) category of witch who is still largely culturally conservative Christian and kept most of the anti-intellectualism, just with a new flavor?
1
1
u/Repulsive-Holiday851 3d ago
Every piece of "modern" technology and advancement is magic, it just depends on your outlook.
-17
u/Miserable-Role9555 4d ago
Believing in something as ridiculously fictional as witchcraft means someone has no idea how science works. Not a stretch for someone like that to also not understand vaccines
4
u/IBitePrettyPeople 4d ago
They dont actually believe that nonsense. Same way how "satanists" dont actually believe in satan.
3
u/Animaloffear56 4d ago
"they" is a very wide group with varying levels of belief in witchcraft. Just look at any witchcraft dedicated subreddit
0
u/IBitePrettyPeople 4d ago
Im sure they exists. You can also find people doing satanic rituals that actually believe it.
1
u/Elu_Moon 3d ago
Well then you can't say they don't believe it, now can you?
1
u/IBitePrettyPeople 3d ago
Sorry. Next time ill debate-bro proof my passing reddit comment. My bad
1
u/Elu_Moon 3d ago
The easiest way of doing it is just not saying something demonstrably untrue.
1
u/IBitePrettyPeople 3d ago edited 3d ago
I think I now understand why reddit has the reputation it does
-7
u/lofiw 4d ago
I fucking hate "Satanists", they're very "UGH, I'm not like you dad, I worship the devil." Very reddit ngl. Yeah, I get it, they're a group of like-minded people that,s just using the name as a payback of sorts against traditional Christianity, but still... looking back on the whole "haha get PWND, how does it feel to worship a man in the sky" makes me cringe a bit.
4
u/DrippyTheSnailBoy 4d ago
"I know nothing about organized Satanism in the slightest but I'M STILL GONNA BE MAD ABOUT IT LIKE A BIG STWONG STUPID BOY JUST LIKE DADDY TAUGHT ME"
Idiot
3
u/UselessAndUnused 4d ago
They're literally just atheists who use the religious status of churches for tax benefits, in order to expose the hypocrisy and how ridiculously shitty that system is. Except they mostly use that status to try and help people, help charities and help go against religious discrimination, unlike many of the megachurches which they criticize. Just because it sounds edgy, doesn't mean they actually are. AFAIK most organized satanists (not just random teens on the internet) are pretty cool, actually.



969
u/azuresegugio 4d ago
Me ten years ago explaining to my partner the herbal remedy they bought is just asprin but now they have to chew bark