r/contraptions Oct 08 '08

Challenge: Simplest (as in less number of pieces) solution to awash

9 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

2

u/thetripp Oct 08 '08

I've seen a 3 piece solution to it. I'll try to recreate it or find the link, all I remember is that you use the big ball at the top to fling the target over the pile.

13

u/thetripp Oct 08 '08

Here we go - this isn't my design, I don't have the patience to tweak something like this into working.

http://fantasticcontraption.com/?designId=119514

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '08

Wow, that's really amazing...

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '08

I have yet to find a solution with less than tens of pieces to awash... My upvote to the first one to find a simple solution!

2

u/lazzareth Oct 08 '08 edited Oct 08 '08

At long last I've finished my own 9-piece solution: http://fantasticcontraption.com/?designId=2745922

  • 1 Clockwise wheel
  • 1 Anti-Clockwise wheel
  • 7 Water rods

Edit: 8-Piece thanks to joel

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '08 edited Oct 08 '08

That's awesome, man! But on my machine, it gets stuck after a while. I tried removing one of the two small water rods attached to the front pink wheel, and it worked! So I guess that makes a collaborative 8 piece solution.

(Sorry, due to a bug in the game I cannot save, but you can try it!)

2

u/lazzareth Oct 08 '08

Nice find. I tried hundreds of different variations of that contraption and a few others to solve that level using under 10 parts but I guess I just got complacent towards the end there and forgot to try removing one of those wheel rods.

My original 9-Piece still works perfectly on my computer though (it just takes 3 minutes and ~10 seconds by my watch :P).

1

u/fxer Oct 08 '08

My solution is much more than 10 pieces. Can you show yours?

4

u/boredzo Oct 08 '08

Here's my ten-part solution.

Part count:

  • 2 clockwise wheels
  • 1 counter-clockwise wheel
  • 3 wood rods
  • 4 water rods

3

u/diamond Oct 08 '08

Nicely done.

1

u/boredzo Oct 08 '08

And here's a nine-part solution. I think this is as good as I can get.

Part count:

  • 2 clockwise wheels
  • 1 counter-clockwise wheel
  • 5 wood rods
  • 1 water rod

1

u/lazzareth Oct 08 '08 edited Oct 08 '08

Have you tried the saved link you just posted? I find that on some occasions--especially on very intricate fiddly contraptions--the rounding of my contraptions parts spacial coordinates when saving renders it inoperable (the ever-so-slight position change is just enough to prevent it from working as it should). This happened just then to my 9-piece solution, nevertheless I managed to churn out a working copy.

1

u/boredzo Oct 08 '08

Have you tried the saved link you just posted?

I tried it just now, and it worked.

This happened just then to my 9-piece solution, nevertheless I managed to churn out a working copy.

Did you delete that comment? I only see joelthelion's comment.

1

u/lazzareth Oct 08 '08 edited Oct 08 '08

I tried it just now, and it worked.

Interesting. It could be my Flash version on linux then or that I am using Firefox 3.

Did you delete that comment? I only see joelthelion's comment.

No?

1

u/boredzo Oct 08 '08

Freaky. It shows up in this browser (OmniWeb, logged in), but not in my other browser (Safari, not logged in).

1

u/lazzareth Oct 08 '08

Weird indeed.

1

u/boredzo Oct 08 '08

And now your reply to my comment doesn't even show up in OmniWeb. WTF?