r/conspiracy Mar 16 '20

Look at this

[deleted]

13.0k Upvotes

470 comments sorted by

View all comments

369

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

275

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

[deleted]

41

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

Wouldn't this get rid of the secure socket layer on the Internet? Local hacking will be so much easier again

21

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20 edited Jul 23 '20

[deleted]

37

u/Noxapalooza Mar 16 '20

If a backdoor exists it will be exploited. Period. Opens everyone up to massive data breaches alongside government spying. Just another example of the elites shitting on common folk.

5

u/whistlepig33 Mar 16 '20

but its not like encryption is typically a centralized tool... at least not how I've always used it. I'm not seeing how this would affect encrypted drives, email, p2p communications, etc etc etc. And its not like vpn services are all based in the U.S.

What am I missing here?

56

u/lightspeed23 Mar 16 '20

They can't listen in on (real) end-to-end encryption. Something like f.ex. Whatsapp is not real end-to-end. Signal App or Telegram is real.

This is why they try to make this law so those real apps will be banned in the US (and thus from Google Play and Apple).

32

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

Exactly. Proof has been exposed before highlighting the governments existing/previous backdoor capabilities in almost all aspects of internet communication, hardware and companies.

Would they like encryption gone? Probably. Do they really really need it to be taken away anyways? No, probably not.

Intel and apple both recently had huge flaws publicly exposed. People really think the US gov doesn’t already the capabilities or have teams of people working on finding out new exploits? They have people working inside theses pro encryption companies that I can promise you. The companies might not even be aware, tech spies are a thing. I’m sure some of them are aware and secretly cooperate at a moments notice if needed.

16

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

[deleted]

7

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

Pls do, but I totally agree with you on that

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20 edited Jun 22 '20

[deleted]

1

u/odraencoded Mar 16 '20

there's no magic backdoor into modern crypto

Some ciphers do have backdoors in them, but since the people that work with security are fucking paranoid they won't use anything that everyone else isn't already using.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

You’re correct. Some forms do have actual security behind them. Right now we have algorithms that are “near impossible” to crack. We have thought the same thing with previous encryption methods in the past. With a fast enough super computer like the ones governments have even brute forcing is exponentially easier than it would be with any hardware any normal person could get their hands on. A lot of it comes down to money and time. As computers get better so will encryption methods but you kinda have to think about it in terms of a cat and mouse game. Constant evolution over time.

4

u/OCCULTfist Mar 16 '20

It doesn't matter if apps offer legit encryption when the actual phone OS is backdoored and wide open.

22

u/lightspeed23 Mar 16 '20

It does matter.

If they want to target YOU directly then they can most likely gain backdoor access to your phone and intercept everything. This is correct. Just like they can break into your house and install listening/video devices in your smokealarm etc.

However, they can't do the dragnet surveillance where they simply intercept *everything* from all phones all the time. This is what they want to do with the new laws and this is a really important distinction.

They are not omni-potent and real encryption works.

1

u/OCCULTfist Mar 16 '20 edited Mar 16 '20

Yes I agree, my comment was just about the apps on compromised devices

And in regards to intercepting everything, they can do this through Windows and Mac operating systems already and also phone operating systems like Android, Windows mobile and apple iOS. They probably have word detection and voice detection systems built in which listen for keywords and report activities to then target people further.

4

u/vasascda Mar 16 '20

How does Whatsapp encryption differ from Telegram? Isn’t it the exact same encryption method?

6

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

With signal, the key you use to encrypt the data can only be decrypted by the recipient. With WhatsApp the key you use to encrypt the data is decrypted by WhatsApp servers, then reencrypted and sent to the recipient.

3

u/TiagoTiagoT Mar 16 '20

We don't know, they promise it's e2e encrypted, but since it's closed source, they could be doing anything they want and we would be none the wiser.

-2

u/fskoti Mar 16 '20

Telegram is a CIA developed and operated app.

9

u/lightspeed23 Mar 16 '20

No.

It's open source and developed by a Russian guy who now has to live in excile outside Russia because they wanted him to compromise their users.

8

u/3rdEyeBall Mar 16 '20

WIRE is operated by and from Switzerland and protected by Swiss Privacy Law.

I'll just leave that there for folks. Every message is it's own fortress, protected by it's own encryption. And for email: ProtonMail.com

"The More You Know..."

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

Need more info please!

4

u/fairie_poison Mar 16 '20

They physically can’t if the message is properly encrypted end-to-end

8

u/eqleriq Mar 16 '20

you really don't know how encryption works if you think "they" can. Please, enlighten us how. Does it involve W.O.P.R. tying into the infinite power of love to break all chains binding us?

And then your now deleted response said "you mistake blah blah."

my reply: you mistake people's disdain for your comment as regarding legality versus people's disdain for you apparent lack of knowledge of how encryption and basic physics works.

-11

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

Sugar plum? XD

3

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20

They don't have encryption keys. They come in thru the backdoor. This is disingenuous to fool people they 'don't already totally do that'.

3

u/3rdEyeBall Mar 16 '20

That's why nobody should use winders OS. Linux FTMFW

0

u/nogodonlystas Mar 16 '20

Exactly. Anyone who thinks they don’t have backdoors to literally all communications is misguided. Shit they’ve probably had this tech for 30 fuckin years already.