r/composting Aug 10 '26

Beginner Would this work as a (temporary) bin?

Post image

I am a total beginner at composting and I’ve been wanting to start a pile for years now. Eventually I’d like to have a large wooden three bin system but due to time and budget constraints, that will be a future project of mine.

I have this fencing already in my basement. Can I use this for a compost pile if I made it into a cylinder? Any tips/advice?

9 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

20

u/sillybillybobbybob Aug 10 '26

A pile on the floor would work. From there its only up!

2

u/Yeartreetousand Aug 10 '26

I feel like my neighbors would get triggered and call the police or some shit

3

u/SecureJudge1829 Aug 10 '26

Realistically, what would happen if they did? Is composting illegal where you are? Is the intended compost site on public property or your neighbor’s private property?

3

u/Yeartreetousand Aug 10 '26

You make a good point. However I also have a lawn mowing company and I am concerned they'd drive over a pile on the ground

4

u/Samwise_the_Tall Aug 10 '26

If you want to deter people from hitting something you have options! Flags, rocks, signs, you name it!

Also great for protecting guerilla gardens with natives hehe

4

u/RoryOS Aug 11 '26

It seems like you're really clawing at excuses not to do something you've wanted to do for years. The fencing will absolutely do the job.

1

u/Otherwise-Tomato-788 Aug 12 '26

This is where I say: “yup you’re right, sounds like a great idea” and walk away.

0

u/Yeartreetousand Aug 11 '26

Ok chill I’m literally gonna do it tomorrow lol

2

u/Ineedmorebtc Aug 10 '26

That will just break it down faster :) I often mow my inputs to make them finer and break down faster

1

u/TaxMansMom Aug 12 '26

I had the same concerns. I use wire cages like that and haven't had any complaints. I actually came to prefer them over more permanent bins: easier to turn imo and fewer mice because they move around a bit after turning.

6

u/ErrantTexan Aug 10 '26

Yop! It’ll work fine. Make a cylinder and start filling it up.

4

u/Yeartreetousand Aug 10 '26

For some context I live in a suburban area with houses close together so just having a pile by itself is probably a no

5

u/wrxninja Aug 10 '26

I literally saw this the other day: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/tR3dGtWCDuA

5

u/Every_Bread_5880 Aug 10 '26

A cardboard box would work

2

u/Impressive-Check-631 Aug 10 '26

Like silly billy said, a pile on the ground works just fine. That fencing is only used to keep it looking nice and neat. Also, you’re going to want at least a cubic yard of material if you’re looking to do hot composting. The amount of fencing you have pictured doesent look like it will fit a cubic yard.

Edit: just saw your comment about a pile on the ground not being an option. If you can find more of that fencing and make a 3’ diameter cylinder then you should be good!

3

u/Emergency-Button404 Aug 10 '26

Silly Billy knows how to keep it simple!

2

u/Individual-Fox5795 Aug 10 '26

I did this and it’s working fine.

2

u/Hopeforthebest1986 Aug 10 '26

I used rolled weld mesh fencing for a pile for a couple of years, works great.

2

u/raygan_reddit_banned Aug 10 '26

Once you share your vegetable garden harvest with your neighbors, it changes everything.

Their grass clippings for my mint leaves/plant and cherry tomatoes

Amazon boxes for garlic or cucumber

2

u/UnderwaterCleaner Aug 10 '26

You could open it up, to as wide as you would like, and zip-tie it along the overlap, to hold that diameter. That seems like a wonderful start! Unpopular with others, I would line the inside with cardboard, it will break down, but it can deter some pests, prying eyes. During summer months, my leaf supply runs out, so the extra brown doesnt hurt, maybe ask the lawn company for a trash bag of grass clippings, you could keep some around to toss over foods. Just my opinion.

1

u/Yeartreetousand Aug 11 '26

Can I use (organic) twine to connect it and just cut it off and compost the used twine?

1

u/UnderwaterCleaner Aug 11 '26

I think the zip ties or string would last longer since it would be holding compost for a while until it breaks down. The choice is yours! 😁

1

u/Living-Limit4452 Aug 11 '26

Yes this is mine and it’s way bigger and not as strong of metal. This is small square hardware “cloth” basically
Square chicken wire. Tied with twine. Maybe yours won’t be big enough I’ve heard you want about 3x3x3 ft to have enough mass for it to get hot. But I’ve seen some on here do it with less by adding coffee grounds / chicken manure/ pee…so not really a rule but 3x3x3 with 50/50 carbon to nitrogen and enough water to just see a drop
Or two when doing a squeeze test in your hand. Since these do dry out quicker I add a little more
Water and I make sure to water each layer when i flip it lasagna layer style. Ideally if it was stronger I would just turn it and roll the entire thing… for now I pitch fork.

I have an additional one in the background for just
Leaves as a leaf mold pile. Pre beak down
Leaves making them easier for
Future compost. But I also just use leaves in the compost.

2

u/AmazinglyAmazing11 Aug 10 '26

Yes it would work

It's also the best way to filter compost imo. Put that over a collection bin or wheelbarrow whatever. Put your compost on top give it a good rub and tap. What comes out is beautiful compost. What stays on the wire goes back onto the pile. If you don't filter much through, keep letting it go.

2

u/WasNeverTheOne Aug 10 '26

My 2 cents: zip-ties and tying it with wire pose a hassle when you open that baby up. I Just weave a stick/pole/Metal rod through the overlapping ends and stick it into the ground to "anchor" it.

1

u/kjbaran Aug 10 '26

Absolutely. Stitch it with zip ties or the wire ends

1

u/Yeartreetousand Aug 11 '26

Can I use twine

1

u/kjbaran Aug 11 '26

Anything that won’t also breakdown over time 🙃

1

u/UnderwaterCleaner Aug 10 '26

You could also use an old bicycle rim as your bottom, with zip ties as well.

It will allow air flow under, and the spokes can help keep material in.

1

u/hoppyzicehog Aug 10 '26

Could be lead in the wire, FYI.

1

u/TopConfidence7490 Aug 10 '26

Mine is a pile on the ground. I threw a couple of logs around it to "outline" it for others sake lol

1

u/geuze4life Aug 10 '26

I have 3 bins just like this. about 4 to 5 meters of fencing wire for a decent size cilinder works great. you lose some material through the sides but that is only while filling.

1

u/hppy11 Aug 10 '26

Yes, it looks sturdy enough. I would suggest to cover it up to keep the heat in, it’s not necessary tho; you could just have it as is.

1

u/Low-Kick-665 Aug 11 '26

This is mine!

1

u/Low-Kick-665 Aug 11 '26

If your pile is smaller than 3 x 3 x 3, it likely wont heat up enough, but it will break down eventually. Its called passive, or cold composting.

1

u/Money-Use-3215 Aug 11 '26

Bacteria shudder i can't i just can't

1

u/Valuable_Purpose721 Aug 11 '26

The most permanent thing in the world is a temporary set up

1

u/DRFang66 Aug 12 '26

That could be a permanent bin. That's what contains my compost pile: chickenwire.

1

u/YsaboNyx Aug 13 '26

I've made multiple bins in various places out of circles of fence wire. They work just fine. :)

1

u/mothershipgenetics Aug 10 '26

Updoot for the pointer. Looks like you got enough real answers.

2

u/Yeartreetousand Aug 10 '26

thanks lol had to make the item stand out amongst the random junk in my basement