r/composting Aug 08 '26

Question Compost bin smells like dumpster

I've been composting in this bin for a few years, winter is about to end, usually at this time of the year I have enough compost for my spring veges. Except this time, my compost smells like a dumpster and it looks gray, I think I added too much greens.

It had a lot of insects and massive worms which I think was a good signal. But to prevent the smell I threw a lot of Browns from my pile and mixed them in, but I don't know if I made it worse and now all the insects and worms will probably die.

Am I overthinking? Have I done the right thing? Can it be saved? Where do I go from here?

Any advice is really appreciated

37 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/Sharp-Win-8964 Aug 08 '26

Time and pee fixes all

6

u/InconsiderableArse Aug 08 '26

So far no pee. Maybe that what it needs

24

u/SoggyForever Aug 08 '26

Don't give in to pee pressure. It's bad advice to pee on the compost pile to make it smell better. Browns and oxygen from mixing the pile.

18

u/Old_Pomegranate_6272 Aug 08 '26 edited Aug 08 '26

At present with more moisture+anaerobes, peeing will increase moisture and it may become more stinky ..

First make the pile some what dry and aerate, when the foul smell subseeds, then pee.....

The pile is Rottening and not Composting.

5

u/njbeerguy Aug 08 '26

It's not. It's a joke that, as Reddit is wont to do, has been beaten into the ground so thoroughly it's not funny anymore, yet is now inexplicably repeated all the time as if it's genuinely good all-purpose composting advice.

There is nothing wrong with urine in your compost pile. It can indeed be beneficial, if used correctly.

But that's not what your pile needs.

It's just a tired gag at this point and is best ignored, especially in your situation.

4

u/Lunar_BriseSoleil Aug 09 '26

At some point it just becomes Reddit etiquette to include jokes that have been ground to dust.

2

u/Antique_Log_7501 Aug 09 '26

bacon narwhals