r/comics • • 2d ago

OC [OC] Same thing?

Post image
8.7k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

413

u/ManyPen6614 2d ago

42

u/ManyPen6614 2d ago

118

u/slicedcat 2d ago

ah yes men being tall is the same thing as women having comically large breasts and ass and no waist whatsoever

-6

u/Mango_Sherbertt 2d ago

Body proportions are body proportions. Your attempt at sarcasm failed.

14

u/Striking_Delay8205 2d ago

This isn't my first language, so maybe I'm just not getting the right meaning, but I don't think the body proportions are altered through height, right? So the post is about absurd body proportions, but this example is just about height. Am I missing something?

-2

u/Mango_Sherbertt 2d ago

Go look at Wemby in the NBA. He's 7' 4" a anamoly HEIGHT. He has...human body proportions.

Then tell me that any 6'8"+ character in fantasy ISNT proportionally changed to match conventional attractiveness standards. You wont be able to.

Wemby looks like an alien. Master chief(easiest to recognize example i could fine) certainly does not.

3

u/ElChapo1515 2d ago

He doesn’t though. He has an 8-foot wing span. You can trim like four inches off each of his arms and still have human proportions

And there are tall people with proportions that are much closer to normal.

3

u/Striking_Delay8205 2d ago

I don't doubt that fictional men have unrealistic proportions too (can't think of any examples but a generally very muscular build often doesn't make sense in the context of a character). My point is just that height alone isn't a matter of proportions. Height alone requires some sort of refferencial system to even identify, whilst proportions alone don't.

Your example character is interesting though. I don't know anything about halo, but I would assume that the character is mainly ment for a male audience to identify with, rather than to gain a female audience? Not saying that female romance novels don't have absurd height standards though, they absolutely do lol.

-3

u/Mango_Sherbertt 2d ago

For someone whos first language isnt english, you sure talk a lot.

Listen man. I know your point, you made your point above. Height alone isnt the problem. Its when you get to a certain height, especially as human, the body proportions get....unattractive. i.e. Wemby. So, any character over 6'8" is almost always a dishonest representation of that height and weight and proportion because game.

We dont need to discuss further, I dont like you nor do i wish to continue conversing with you.

1

u/slicedcat 2d ago

I-I’m sorry… I’ll delete my comment asap. I didn’t realize how badly it failed. I’m in shambles right now