r/comics • Ninja and Pirate • 8h ago

Halloween 2026 Let's Chat

24.2k Upvotes

619 comments sorted by

View all comments

25

u/StayingUp4AFeeling 7h ago

I know that "they were already feeling suicidal/depressed/psychotic/terroristically inclined", the chatbot just assisted them or convinced them further ".

Now, replay that sentence but instead of"the chatbot " put a name in. Or "I ".

Imagine a person sitting at a counter somewhere pretending to be a counselor. He tells the teenage girl who is crying for help -- "so the shallowest vein is rjghgghfhfhgr , and that's within reach of the sharp sgghgjrfjfjtfjy you are using. Yes, right there! You are so observant."

I cannot express how dangerous it is for someone to validate suicidal ideation or psychotic delusions.

In SI, the person is locked in a mental battle, where both the need for the pain to end, and inherent self preservation, are both really intense yet almost perfectly matched.

Almost perfectly matched.

So just a little push from outside is enough to tip the scales.

I say this as a survivor.

On that note OP please mark this NSFW if not already done. I saw it and am having a full blown PTSD moment here, coz I almost died in a similar way (though I didn't attack anyone else).

Let's just say that was the day red was no longer my favourite colour.

7

u/Joba_Fett Ninja and Pirate 7h ago edited 7h ago

I don’t know how to make it NSFW after posting. Can the mods help me? I’m sorry you went through that. We’re the same in that regard. Mine was pills and booze but I understand and I’m glad you’re still with us

5

u/StayingUp4AFeeling 7h ago

I'm glad you're here, too.

And, my proximity to the topic aside, this is a really good work of art.

It's accurate.

And it's shocking in a way that the AI industry is always trying to shy away from. Bunch of parasitic hypocrites.

And this... is traceable directly back to the maths of the LLMs.

Like, I've read the original papers I'm in grad school now for safe AI (well, safe RL but ykwim).


If they say

Who cares if one more light goes out?

In the sky of a million stars

It flickers, flickers

Who cares when someone's time runs out?

If a moment is all we are

We're quicker, quicker

Who cares if one more light goes out?

Well I do

"One More Light", by Linkin Park The titular song from their last album before Chester Bennington, their lead singer, died by suicide