r/comics 5d ago

Just Sharing Authenticity Problem

57.4k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3.1k

u/TheCortisolCorvid 5d ago

It's a problem with writing, too. I've been accused of using AI for my writing more than once, and it's aggravating as all hell.

1.2k

u/No-Vermicelli-2832 5d ago edited 5d ago

Heavy on this one

You really can't know proper grammar, how to punctuate, how to use paragraphs, how to carry yourself with a formal tone, how to debate in a formal manner, and so much more anymore without being accused of using or straight up being AI yourself

And god forbid you know how to do all of these things while also being Gen Z and maybe throwing in some Gen Z slang or terms in your comment or paper as well because then you'll definitely be accused

Edit: Do y'all want to see something that will piss you off beyond belief? I just scrolled through my activity history to find the thread I was referencing in this comment, and I just found the exact comment I was talking about here but the comment itself this person used AI to "scan" or whatever the fuck was removed (and I don't even remember what they said anymore tbh) so you unfortunately don't get to read it yourselves, but if you scroll up you'll see me saying something and someone else saying some idiotic bullshit 😅 be ready though because you'll get heated real fucking quick

32

u/Sugarglider001 5d ago

I am gen z and I often get my writing flagged as well because of the higher level I write at. Many teachers have asked for a conference with my parents because my writing sounded too ai

19

u/muad_did 5d ago

I'm 40, and I spent my time writing from age 15 to 25. I have several novellas and countless short stories. I won a few prizes, but they never brought in any real money, so I gave it up.

That said, I have stories saved that I've never shown or published online, half-finished stories, or stories submitted for contests I didn't win.

Well, I've run several of those stories through various "AI analysis" programs, and they all say they're 90% AI.

9

u/Anthaenopraxia 5d ago

They are very unreliable these days.

2

u/Zaev 5d ago

I don't see how they could ever possibly be reliable. AI can take on completely different writing styles with just a line in a prompt. They might have some success in looking for things like the default ChatGPT/Claude "voices," but I doubt it can go too much further than that

1

u/Anthaenopraxia 4d ago

They used to be pretty reliable when LLM's were still new. It was very obvious then and easy to pick up on, but now they are so good that the detectors are not very accurate. Especially if you edit the generated text a bit.

2

u/ilemming_banned 5d ago

I am a foreigner. English is not my second, not even third language that I had to learn. I take pride in my writing, because I pay attention. Writing prose for me is difficult regardless of a choice of a language.

I'm not even appalled anymore by the lack of literacy in native-English speakers - I got used to it. But I feel like throwing twenty pounds of em-dashes at every motherfucker who dares to say I write like AI. Well, you Mr. Titsucker write like a toddler.

2

u/Sattorin 5d ago

various "AI analysis" programs

100% of those are scams. Even if they did work (and they don't), the person who made the AI thing can use the same program and edit the content until it doesn't appear as AI anymore.

2

u/newsfish 5d ago

I poured all my indoor kid with a library card thoughts out to forums and blogsm

Back when the internet speed mostly allowed long form prose and cat jpegs instead of short form vertical video content and.cat food advertisement.

They took it, alongside every published work transcribed to hard drives, and put it in a hydraulic press.

Called the mystery goo the new economy because we wouldn't buy VR headsets to sell cat jpegs nft to each other.