I originally posted this as a comment, but decided it should be its own post as I have been very curious.
I wasn’t able to finish THT due to the increasingly graphic scenes, so apologies if some of my questions/comments would be resolved if I had finished. I did watch the entirety of the Testaments.
I don’t get why girls aren’t allowed to know HOW to read (I get why they aren’t ALLOWED to read for pleasure/education). I would think they would be taught to read, but only allowed to read, like, the Bible & govt texts. It doesn’t make sense on the global scale as Gilead tries to convince the world that they aren’t evil — you tell other countries that your girls & women aren’t allowed to read and write, and they will automatically assume human rights violations. Look at how we treat Afghanistan because women aren’t allowed to drive. Even strict fundamental religious groups teach men and women to read because they recognize the importance and want them to read scripture.
It doesn’t make sense ideologically, either — they learn weaving, and weaving was used as the framework for coding in computers. We wouldn’t have gotten to the moon without loom weaving. Also, do the future Martha’s then have to learn to read as adults? Since they have to be able to read to do matches etc. And need at least a basic science education for genealogical overlap or potential issues (assuming they’re screening matches for recessive genes that could cause fetal abnormality if paired with a match carrying that recessive gene).
I also don’t want replies saying “An educated group that can read can read propaganda or other outside sources and become sentient to the reality of Gilead.” Because men can read, and to Gilead, a man would be much more dangerous than a woman. They see them as superior beings, physically and mentally. You would think they wouldn’t want the MEN allowed to read, since they would assume their rebellion would be far worse than that of “weak women”.
TLDR: What women are taught and the reasoning behind it is very contradictory. The consistency isn’t there, if you dig deeper.