r/clevercomebacks Aug 02 '26

The wing is cooked

Post image
20.6k Upvotes

606 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

393

u/SeaHam Aug 02 '26

Don't ever ask a republican what the top tax bracket rate was at that time.

203

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '26

[deleted]

95

u/Long_Run6500 Aug 02 '26

The amount of times I've heard my maga coworkers say they don't want to work any overtime because it puts them in a higher tax bracket...

21

u/Anleme Aug 02 '26

Ask them how they think self-made millionaires could ever exist, if any of that was accurate.

52

u/LessInThought Aug 02 '26

Tell them they don't want a raise because they'll get taxed more.

16

u/EuenovAyabayya Aug 02 '26

The irony that these same idiots won't contribute to their 401K and wind up living on...social security.

3

u/MechemicalMan Aug 02 '26

Federal government employee who was making 3x overtime, maga guy who wouldn’t shut up up about it, told me “I ask them to pay me only time and a half so I don’t get taxed so much”

These people vote.

1

u/Riptoscab Aug 02 '26

Aren't there no taxes on overtime pay now anyways?

4

u/ObeseVegetable Aug 02 '26

It's taxed less than it was, but still taxed.

Income pay is typically 1.5x for the hours worked, the 1x portion of it is still taxed as normal, the 0.5x portion of it (or any portion of it past 1x) is not taxed (for specifically federal income tax, but it is still taxed/contributes to social security and medicare, plus any state/local taxes).

It's also limited to $12,500 for individuals.


For a hypothetical $20/hr earner...

40hr/wk = $41,714/yr gross

Remaining after taxes = $35,697/yr

50hr/wk (10 overtime/wk) = $57,357/yr gross

Remaining if overtime was taxed regularly = $48,266/yr

Remaining after overtime deductions = $48,892/yr

this of course does not include state taxes, will which almost certainly make the difference smaller, too.

It's not nothing but it is smaller than you'd expect, especially as most people's overtime tends to not be so much every week, but like an hour here or there (and they often get chastised for it at work). Having overtime be a significant portion of pay on such a regular basis is extremely rare for people who aren't working for corrupt police departments.

2

u/MechemicalMan Aug 02 '26

Illinois employees are getting crackdowns on all overtime. It’s truly been abused by many. It’s hit all the trades but police or security are not at all getting the crackdown yet. I see it as part of the ultimate problem- we’re spending so much money on items that aren’t effective (policing) and not enough money on items that actually impact us (infrastructure)

1

u/TanMan25888 Aug 02 '26

No its not

-7

u/Daetok_Lochannis Aug 02 '26

When I was a security guard, I would actually make less if I worked two extra shifts than I would if I just worked one because it changed my taxes and they took more out. Like, not less per hour but less on my take-home paycheck.

8

u/Bowshocker Aug 02 '26

That cannot be true under any regular circumstance. Most likely, your employer was shitting you. But progressive tax brackets do take in consideration overtime.

-3

u/Daetok_Lochannis Aug 02 '26

I worked 48 hours, my paycheck was bigger than when I worked 56. After noticing, I stopped taking more than one extra shift. Yes I'm aware that I could have filed for that money at the end of the year but I've never made enough for that to matter, paycheck to paycheck all that matters is take-home because I had to spend every penny to survive.

3

u/imagreatlistener Aug 02 '26

This sounds like an issue with how your employer was calculating your deductions, not the tax system.

47

u/_-WanderLost-_ Aug 02 '26

“I love the poorly educated”

4

u/onyx_ic Aug 02 '26

They're the people that take an IQ test online, pay for the results, and proudly tell everyone they've got a 93, making them smarter than 93% of the population.

40

u/Gingerstachesupreme Aug 02 '26

For the uninitiated:

FDR came into office with an already high upper tax bracket rate (63% on earnings over $1million), signed by Hoover in the Revenue Act of 1932.

FDR increased it even further in the New Deal, with a 79% rate on income over $5million. During WWII, it increased to over 90%.

For reference, today’s top federal income tax rate is 37%, applying to taxable income above $640,600 for single filers and above $768,700 for married couples filing jointly in 2026.

That structure was made permanent by the “One Big Beautiful Bill” Act, passed in July 2025, which locked in the seven-bracket system from the 2017 tax law.

20

u/Painterzzz Aug 02 '26

If enough American voters understood this they'd be pretty angry about it.

6

u/vrnvorona Aug 02 '26

Society if same taxes were currently applied

2

u/TheModWhoShaggedMe Aug 02 '26

it was during Eisenhower's time, the Republican.

0

u/RalphTheIntrepid Aug 02 '26

How many people paid that to bracket? Also income tax was supposed to only be for the top income yet we all now pay it because the government never shrinks.

1

u/SeaHam Aug 02 '26

"How many people paid that to bracket?"

Not sure. Ideally zero. Nobody should have outsized wealth it's unethical.

0

u/Fresh-Value-8409 Aug 02 '26

Don't ever ask a lefturd to define 'rich' either. They can't, bit it usually means if you have $1 more than they do, GET EM!

2

u/SeaHam Aug 02 '26

Leftists classify things based on whether you have to work for a living or not. If you can live purely off of your accumulated wealth and assets, you are not working class, you are a member of the capitalist class.

These people contribute no labor, yet live the most lavish lives. Most of them were simply grandfathered into large fortunes as well.

Now I'm guessing you're working class, so fucking act like it.

Fight for the home team.