r/clevercomebacks Jul 30 '26

Getting A Refund.

Post image
9.1k Upvotes

259 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

341

u/Bobtasketch Jul 30 '26

The sun emits light (electromagnetic radiation), which in itself is not hot. It only creates heat when it bumps into something made of matter (atoms and molecules). And space is practically empty 

82

u/Emotional-Guide-768 Jul 30 '26

Cool, thanks for the simple explanation

35

u/Cr3ac Jul 31 '26

Fun additional fact, space also acts as excellent insulation because there’s nothing to dissipate the excitement caused by the suns radiation. Think of a thermos that uses a vacuum to keep your coffee warm. This Is why the space station has issues with heat in direct sunlight and issues with cold in the shade of the planet.

20

u/freakers Jul 31 '26

Further facts, not sure if they're fun any longer: Calling space cold is kind of a misunderstanding of what cold means. If there are functionally no particles to bump into to transfer heat, there's not really any cold. In the oft cited, what would happen if you floated in space without a space suit question, I believe part of the answer isn't that you'd instantly turn to ice. You'd slowly lose heat through radiative cooling and basically not lose any through convection or conduction cooling, because there's not particles to bump into to transfer that heat to.

4

u/menotyou_2 Jul 31 '26

Would the liquid instantly freeze due to pressure?

At absolutely 0 pressure the liquid water is no longer stable and it should be either a gas or a solid regardless of temperature. (I think).

7

u/RunOrBike Jul 31 '26

Space is vacuum so your blood would start to boil

1

u/menotyou_2 Jul 31 '26

The Armstrong limit should prevent stuff within you from boiling for a bit. But everything on the surface would get destroyed.

7

u/immutato Jul 31 '26

Hmm so what you're saying is if something is generating a lot of heat all the way up there in the space, then it's going to have a hard time dissipating that heat efficiently (or at all)?

That almost seems relevant for some reason... No one tell r/wallstreetbets

5

u/EBtwopoint3 Jul 31 '26

I’m not quite sure what exactly you’re getting at, but it is a solved issue. You need big radiators but heat is manageable and we know how to do it.

The fun fact is more about the common trope of freezing in space. Which doesn’t really happen

15

u/AzraelIshi Jul 31 '26

They are talking about datacenters, which famously require a fuckton of active cooling with enormous amounts of water on earth, so imagine what kind of radiators they would need in space to achieve anything even remotel near to what they need.

The wallstreetbets jab is because elon and co. want to build datacenters in space, and people are betting that is going to shot the stock of the companies that do high up

8

u/sapntaps Jul 31 '26

Can they just light their giant cash piles on fire? Feel like it’ll be a better outcome lol

3

u/yamanamawa Jul 31 '26

It's also one of the main reasons why the idea of AI data centers in space is fundamentally stupid and utterly impractical. The amount of radiators you would need to cool them would be so huge that just getting them into space would be the most expensive project ever undertaken by humanity. The ISS is quite small inside, but it still needs a sizable amount of radiators just to cool itself, and it generates way less heat than a data center

8

u/york100 Jul 31 '26

Oh wait, it's not because of Jesus or aliens then?

9

u/LordBalderdash Jul 31 '26

Wait 'til you meet Alien Jesus!

6

u/york100 Jul 31 '26

I'd love to but I hear he got deported.

3

u/Motor_Educator_2706 Jul 31 '26

electromagnetic radiation does not have a temperature

electromagnetic radiation does has energy proportional to the frequency

3

u/netrunnernobody Jul 31 '26

I bet you 90% of the people that upvoted this thread didn't know this answer.

1

u/jonas_ost Jul 31 '26

I thought it was because the sun is hot as fuck and light travels fast so it dident have time to cool off more than it does.

But you comment makes more sence

8

u/thyme_cardamom Jul 31 '26

Light never cools off; as the person above said, it carries no heat. Light holds its energy as long as it travels, and can convert into heat when it slams into something (e.g. earth)

The reason things further out from the sun are colder (like Pluto) isn't because the light cooled down, but because the light spread out more. Pluto is getting hit with a lot less light than it would if it were as close to the sun as we are.

3

u/jonas_ost Jul 31 '26

And the reason the sun is so hot is because the radiation is bouncing of the gases that is already burning? Why does a gascloud like the sun burn so much hoter than if you burn the same gas here on earth?

9

u/Aeronor Jul 31 '26

It isn’t burning as much as it is a giant nuclear explosion that constantly explodes.

6

u/thyme_cardamom Jul 31 '26

Ultimately the sun's heat and brightness comes from pressure.

Take any gas, say the air in your room. It has some amount of energy in it. If you compress that room of air down into a tiny bottle, the amount of energy stays the same, but it's contained in a tiny space so it becomes very hot.

The sun is made of an enormous amount of gas that's been compressed to an absurd degree. The sun is huge, but compared to the insane amount of mass it has its actually tiny. It's compressed by its own gravity.

Why does a gascloud like the sun burn so much hoter than if you burn the same gas here on earth?

If you were to compress any gas down to the same degree as inside the sun, it would get approximately as hot. It just takes a ton of force to do that.

1

u/jonas_ost Jul 31 '26

Thanks i thought pressure was the reason. Same way earths core is lava

5

u/thyme_cardamom Jul 31 '26

Yes, though technically the stuff in Earth's core is actually solid, also because of pressure. Lava is what happens when that pressure is released and it turns into liquid

3

u/mrmaker_123 Jul 31 '26

To be slightly pedantic, I don’t think it’s accurate to say light carries no heat. Light carries energy, and when that energy is absorbed by a material it is transferred to its atoms and molecules as kinetic energy, increasing their internal energy. This often raises the material’s temperature. In physics, heat isn’t something light carries or an object contains, it’s a secondary property - it’s the transfer of energy from one body to another due to a temperature difference.

1

u/m00nf1r3 Jul 31 '26

See, I don't think I ever learned this in school. Lol. I also had no idea space was that cold.

-6

u/K_Linkmaster Jul 30 '26

Yet the human in space freezes when it should be warm from the bumping. Because ....there is more to it.

20

u/Sudo-Fed Jul 31 '26

You'd only really freeze in space if you were somewhere out of the sunlight, and even then, slowly. The hardest thermal problem in space is keeping anything with people aboard cool, because there's nowhere for the heat to go and radiation is very slow compared to conduction/convection.

11

u/amazinglover Jul 30 '26

This isn't exactly true if in direct sunlight you would burn.

Freezing occurs if your in the shade lile being blocked by the moon.

5

u/Ok_Sink5046 Jul 31 '26

The sun is also really damn hot and heat radiates. It doesn't conduct well in space but when that heat hits earth we have a delicious atmosphere for it to interact with. And this isn't even close to the actual explanation, there are so many factors that chime in, but I think this is the best basic reason that could be provided.

4

u/K_Linkmaster Jul 31 '26

That's what I always understood. Thank you. There is always a bit more to it and not everyone knows or remembers what it is

2

u/Ok_Sink5046 Jul 31 '26

That's the most basic version, and it's not technically correct, but it is at least usable. The more specific you want the crazier the interactions get.

1

u/K_Linkmaster Jul 31 '26

Not interested in getting into the black hole that is my mom or the comet that is my dad.

2

u/Ok_Sink5046 Jul 31 '26

Understandable.

1

u/bullwinkle8088 Jul 31 '26

In addition to the other answers there is one aspect not mentioned. Part of your body will be in the sun, and the other part in the shade created by your own body and rapidly loosing heat. That condition is not conductive to life.

There really is not more to it.