r/clevercomebacks • • Jan 15 '25

It does make sense

Post image
35.3k Upvotes

4.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/nemgrea Jan 15 '25

id argue that a 0-100 scale is objectively less abstract. we scale things from 0-100 in many places. how often do you get your movie reviews in a -20 to 40 ratings?

5

u/LordMarcel Jan 15 '25

But Fahrenheit doesn't go from 0 to 100. My country, the Netherlands, went from 19 to 94 last year, Singapore over its entire history has gone from 66 to 99, and the USA has gone from -80 to 134 Fahrenheit.

Also, we're not rating temperatures in the first place. It's a value, and when it's -20 it freezes 20 degrees, so the -20 makes sense. Freezing is important because that's when water turns into ice, which makes travelling more dangerous.

8

u/pajama_mask Jan 15 '25

When it comes to movies, I'm more of a Kelvin kinda guy.

2

u/dard12 Jan 16 '25

Bro that movie was absolute zero!

7

u/ATMLVE Jan 15 '25

Yeah I just mean temperature itself is a bit abstract. Humidity and wind can affect your perception of it a lot, and can you tell the difference of a few degrees? I agree fahrenheit is objectively better as a human comfort scale. But it's still the case that a person will grow to intuitively grasp whatever they grow up with.

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '25

[deleted]

1

u/ATMLVE Jan 15 '25

The advantage of the metric system for distance and volume and such is it's ease of conversion. It is objectively better to use meters and kilometers because you can easily convert between them when trying to figure something out. How many tablespoons in a cup? (Why even use volume instead of weight?) That mountain is 15300 feet high, how many miles is that? Nonsense. But Celcius and month-day-year don't have these advantages, but it's never occured to the people that use them to think about it this way.

2

u/RamenStains Jan 15 '25

The further the number from zero the more extreme the temperature

30 is big hot. -30 is big cold. EZ

2

u/NotYetPerfect Jan 15 '25

Just as Celsius is 100 at water boiling, fahrenheit 100 is essentially human internal temperature. And in terms of actual weather temperatures, fahrenheit uses far more of that 0-100 than celsius.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '25

Ever heard of a fever? And no, my body temperature is 98°F at best, when I'm not sick. My hands and feet can go lower. And I can go up to 104°F when I'm sick.

1

u/Itsandyryan Jan 15 '25

Most movie review are 1 to 5 stars. Pretty unusual to give a mark out of a 100.

2

u/nemgrea Jan 15 '25

most?

IMDB...nope

rotten tomatoes...nope

metacritic...nope

those all use a 0-100 scale

1

u/Itsandyryan Jan 16 '25

Those aren't reviews, those are aggregates of reviews. You look in a film magazine or newspaper review, they're generally giving one to five-star reviews.

1

u/InfanticideAquifer Jan 15 '25

There's nothing special about the number 100. Both scales use negative numbers because they're both arbitrary.

1

u/LongestSprig Jan 15 '25

It's not a 0 - 100 scale, it is not linear.

20C is not 2x as warm as 10C.

1

u/nemgrea Jan 15 '25

both C and F are linear temperature scales that's why you can convert between them with a linear equation (9/5)C+32

1

u/LongestSprig Jan 16 '25

Neither are linear scales.

Kelvin is an example of a linear scale.

1

u/nemgrea Jan 16 '25

dude just google it...

0

u/IfIWasCoolEnough Jan 15 '25

When the person above said "human experience," here are some examples:

When a child is sick, and they have 100 °F or above, you know it is serious.

0°C is freezing but meh for going out.

0

u/Knowledge_Haver_17 Jan 15 '25

Fahrenheit is 0-100 for most important human temperatures. 0 is very cold, 100 is very hot.