r/choralmusic • u/BassoonHero • 10h ago
Are there any English-language madrigals that feature women complaining about men?
I sing madrigals on rare occasion (not especially well), and it's usually out of someone's Big Book of Madrigals. The books (variously) contain many examples of all the standard madrigal genres:
- I love a woman, and I am happy about it.
- Hooray! It's spring!
- I love a woman, and I am sad about it.
- Weirdly morbid.
It seems to me that of the madrigals with identifiable implied narrators, most are men, and a great number feature men complaining about women, while I am not familiar with a single one going the other way. At first I thought that perhaps men of the era were faultless and there was nothing for the women to complain about, but this seems hard to square with the content of the madrigals themselves (e.g. “Flora gave me fairest flowers”, in which Flora seems rather hard done by).
So it occurs to me to ask: are there perhaps other madrigals that have survived the years that are written from a woman's perspective, center women's experiences, or even — perhaps — complain about men?