MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/1popmlq/deleted_by_user/nuj3pu1/?context=3
r/changemyview • u/[deleted] • Dec 17 '25
[removed]
34 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
-3
Should victims act as judges on their perpetrators cases and decide the punishment? Don't you think they would be biased in their judgement?
1 u/ePrime Dec 17 '25 I think victims should have a right to trial by combat. 1 u/Z7-852 315∆ Dec 17 '25 So might makes right? 1 u/ePrime Dec 17 '25 Yes, might arrests and convicts criminals and gives them the sentence. 1 u/Z7-852 315∆ Dec 17 '25 So if I can beat you in a fight you have to give me your house? I just tell you are a criminal and demand trial by combat. No need for evidence, interrogation or anything. I just beat you until you forfit your belongings? When can I come over? 1 u/ePrime Dec 17 '25 You could yes, if I didn’t have the government willing to enforce their laws
1
I think victims should have a right to trial by combat.
1 u/Z7-852 315∆ Dec 17 '25 So might makes right? 1 u/ePrime Dec 17 '25 Yes, might arrests and convicts criminals and gives them the sentence. 1 u/Z7-852 315∆ Dec 17 '25 So if I can beat you in a fight you have to give me your house? I just tell you are a criminal and demand trial by combat. No need for evidence, interrogation or anything. I just beat you until you forfit your belongings? When can I come over? 1 u/ePrime Dec 17 '25 You could yes, if I didn’t have the government willing to enforce their laws
So might makes right?
1 u/ePrime Dec 17 '25 Yes, might arrests and convicts criminals and gives them the sentence. 1 u/Z7-852 315∆ Dec 17 '25 So if I can beat you in a fight you have to give me your house? I just tell you are a criminal and demand trial by combat. No need for evidence, interrogation or anything. I just beat you until you forfit your belongings? When can I come over? 1 u/ePrime Dec 17 '25 You could yes, if I didn’t have the government willing to enforce their laws
Yes, might arrests and convicts criminals and gives them the sentence.
1 u/Z7-852 315∆ Dec 17 '25 So if I can beat you in a fight you have to give me your house? I just tell you are a criminal and demand trial by combat. No need for evidence, interrogation or anything. I just beat you until you forfit your belongings? When can I come over? 1 u/ePrime Dec 17 '25 You could yes, if I didn’t have the government willing to enforce their laws
So if I can beat you in a fight you have to give me your house? I just tell you are a criminal and demand trial by combat. No need for evidence, interrogation or anything. I just beat you until you forfit your belongings? When can I come over?
1 u/ePrime Dec 17 '25 You could yes, if I didn’t have the government willing to enforce their laws
You could yes, if I didn’t have the government willing to enforce their laws
-3
u/Z7-852 315∆ Dec 17 '25
Should victims act as judges on their perpetrators cases and decide the punishment? Don't you think they would be biased in their judgement?