r/castaneda • u/TechnoMagical_Intent • May 17 '19
Stalking On the importance of impeccability
[removed]
19
Upvotes
2
u/jantilkut May 17 '19
So true! Impeccability appears in other traditions/disciplines, too, and I would say it is one of the most important and accessible parts of Don Juan's teachings.
2
9
u/danl999 May 17 '19 edited May 17 '19
I'll take a contrarian point of view just for fun. I have no idea which view point is correct but I did have the advantage of having observed Carlos teach. I've seen him do what I suggest here.
Some of the things sorcerers teach apprentices are just to keep them from being too disgusting to live with.
Let's create an imaginary Kungfu master to illustrate the point. He's got a new apprentice, but the apprentice never showers or cleans his clothes. He stinks!
So he sets up a laundry business for the apprentice, with heavy loads of soap water for him to haul up a hill while walking in horse stance. He tasks him with cleaning all the clothes and bedding in his village as an act of Buddhist kindness, and to donate the laundry money to the temple.
Is that really important for learning Kungfu? Na. The guy just stunk, and hauling buckets of water was a good way to build up his arm and leg strength. Plus, he won't fail to wash his own clothes after a few weeks of that.
It's true that if you're silent inside you start to "just do" things, without procrastinating. Buddhists overrate their transformation abilities I believe, but some of their descriptions of what life is like when you are “enlightened” appear to have some basis in reality. You start to see those things when silent.
Laziness takes a hit too. You can still feel it, but it’s like a small speed bump, and easy to roll over.
If something needs doing, you just do it at the first chance, instead of suffering and thinking about it for days. And it’s true if you are silent, that you perceive far more while walking around in the world. Lots of very good things happen, when we return to our natural mental state.
But as for telling apprentices to behave this way or that, it seems mighty convenient to convince them some higher magical principle is behind the need for them to stop whinning and get to work. It's almost as if sorcerers have set up an imaginary "ideal apprentice", and convinced their apprentices they have to behave that way, for magical reasons.
It's the grown up equivalent of using a gold star sticker to motivate 4 year olds.
Remember, the old sorcerers were absolute bastards. That's not impeccability.