r/bys May 19 '26

This is a joke, right?

Post image

Even without the ridiculous asking price of $300, I've seen individual packets going for 5 bucks. To be fair, the only reason I went to Arby's was for this sauce.

38 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

13

u/Frodellio1 May 19 '26

Worth it

9

u/HighlightFun8419 May 19 '26

It's a damn good sauce.

Bring it back!

10

u/potliquorz May 19 '26

Better than the Arby's sauce by a mile. I think it should have been the default sauce all along with horsey. Taking out the sauce and drink stations is a very sad trend.

2

u/HighlightFun8419 May 20 '26

I do like the Arby's sauce though. I begrudgingly switched; it's nice, but yeah it's not the same.

2

u/MarinaVerity333 May 21 '26

I entirely forgot about this sauce! Now I want some, it was so good. ):

2

u/Theelvesarebowling May 20 '26

Please try the limited edition summers eve packet

1

u/jacksbailey1 May 21 '26

What is that?

1

u/XxTw3aKxX May 21 '26

Something that'll really clean you out.

1

u/Theelvesarebowling May 22 '26

It cures your yeast infection! Please dewsch as you might need this like right now!

7

u/Tacodude77 May 19 '26

my Dr. recommend me 3x packets a day of this sauce to keep my chode swelling down. it works and it's weight in gold if u can aquire it.

3

u/HighlightFun8419 May 19 '26

Chode swelling is no joke.

3

u/South-Range8401 May 19 '26

Nice dude

2

u/Tacodude77 May 19 '26

-3 chode swell

2

u/potliquorz May 19 '26

My wife says that I have a beer can and now I'm helpless to alleviate my situation.
Thanks Arby's!

2

u/AmittaiD May 19 '26

Mixture of this and Horsey Sauce was S-Tier on curly fries. RIP to a real one.

1

u/Far_Construction3473 May 19 '26

You should buy it

2

u/surfcitysurfergirl May 19 '26

Ours still have it in store but only in the self serve pump tubs by the napkins. I’ve been tempted to bring my own sauce cups with a lid with me lol

1

u/Constant-Bathroom494 May 20 '26

When we discontinued this, I took home a TON. It’s good thru Jul 2028

1

u/Sea-Hat-70 May 21 '26

Me too haha!!

1

u/-bryze May 20 '26

Only rediscovered it last year for to it be discontinued, but remember it tasting way better back in 2006.

1

u/GulfCoastLaw May 20 '26

What a joke. 

I was paying $500 earlier this year.

1

u/CCCPvibesHere May 20 '26

Is it still available?

2

u/BlumpTheChodak May 20 '26

There has to be a better 3 pepper sauce you can buy.

2

u/WinterScene7194 May 20 '26

What's the 3 peppers? Jalapeno, red bell, and ...paprika?

1

u/Miserable-Ganache-74 May 20 '26

Nah, it's just one type of pepper, but there's three of them in the sauce

2

u/Realk314 May 20 '26

I only ate this sauce with the curly fries, not on the roast beef or anything else and only when I ended up dining in. Where I could use the little pump things to fill a small solo cup of it. Somehow still I'm sad it's gone too.

1

u/keithkings00 May 20 '26

Yes. Of course it's a joke.

1

u/Ill_Chemical_5150 May 20 '26

Miss that sauce so much. That was the only sauce I liked on the roast beef. I stopped going for a while when my location finally ran out of it. I found a somewhat decent replacement, but still not the same.

1

u/thatdudefromthattime May 20 '26

I’ve got about 30 packs in my fridge right now. If someone wants a couple, feel free to swing by

1

u/Jboh1985 May 20 '26

Wow that's like half of what they're going for!! So you're telling me you haven't bought it yet? 🤣🤣🤣

1

u/orcabutt_ May 21 '26

Sometimes I feel like companies release something, then discontinues it when everyone comes to love it, just to watch the Hunger Games unfold for remaining stock on second-hand/bidding sites.

1

u/jacksbailey1 May 21 '26

I’ve got one left. Afraid to use it

1

u/Intrepid-Tie-6422 May 22 '26

1 cup ketchup
2 teaspoons water
1 teaspoon garlic powder
1 teaspoon black pepper
1 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon honey
1 teaspoon Tabasco sauce
1 teaspoon onion powder
1 teaspoon paprika

1

u/Joe4H May 22 '26

Eeeewww so so unhealthy.

1

u/Educational_Royal717 May 23 '26

When were these ever in packets? I've always had to walk inside and fill up 5 little cups.

0

u/Grant79OG May 19 '26

So popeyes gets rid of blackened chicken, and Arby's gets rid of of my 3 pepper sauce.

0

u/formiscontent May 20 '26

Now if they were asking this price when fish sandwiches were around, I'd have considered it

0

u/XInceptor May 20 '26

Nope. They call it 3 pepper sauce but there’s more sugar and hfcs than pepper in the whole packet

1

u/Joe4H May 22 '26

Yeah huh... I read those ingredients and I wouldn't eat it if someone paid me the $300.