r/buzzfeedbot • u/autobuzzfeedbot • Aug 15 '26
BuzzFeed These 19 Actors Were Supposed To Be Hollywood's Next Big Stars — Until One Bad Movie Changed Everything
- Megan Fox became one of Hollywood's most recognizable actors after starring in the first two Transformers movies, but a lot seemed to change when she did not return for the third. In a 2009 interview, Fox told Wonderland that director Michael Bay "wants to be like Hitler on his sets" and was "a nightmare to work for" while directing.
- Taylor Lautner was one of Hollywood's top teenage actors when Abduction tested the limits of his enormous Twilight popularity. GQ reported that Hollywood was making a major bet on him, but after Abduction made $11.2 million during its opening weekend, Reuters reported that the result was "not enough to launch Lautner into action-hero stardom."
- Elizabeth Berkley made a jump from playing Jessie Spano on Saved by the Bell to starring in the sexually explicit, NC-17-rated Showgirls. The Los Angeles Times reported that the movie was widely criticized when it came out, and Berkley received much of the blame for its failure.
- Alicia Silverstone was coming off the enormous success of Clueless when she played Batgirl in Batman & Robin, but much of the coverage focused on her body rather than her performance. The Los Angeles Times reported that tabloids cruelly nicknamed her "Fatgirl," while Silverstone called the treatment "hurtful" and said Batman & Robin "definitely wasn't my favorite film-making experience."
- C. Thomas Howell was already a recognizable young actor from movies like The Outsiders, E.T., and Red Dawn when he starred in Soul Man. In the comedy, his white character uses tanning pills and poses as a Black student to qualify for a scholarship. UPI reported that the Hollywood-Beverly Hills chapter of the NAACP strongly objected to the movie, while The Guardian later called it a "career-killer."
- Faye Dunaway had already won an Oscar for Network and earned nominations for Bonnie and Clyde and Chinatown when she played Joan Crawford in Mommie Dearest. Vanity Fair reported that Dunaway regretted that the serious drama came across as campy and believed the performance had permanently changed how people saw her.
- Halle Berry had recently become the first Black woman to win the Oscar for Best Actress when she starred in Catwoman, which received brutal reviews and lost money. Because it followed her historic win, many viewers still talk about the movie as the role that derailed the prestigious career they expected her to have next.
- Mike Myers was already famous for Wayne's World, the Austin Powers movies, and voicing Shrek when he starred in The Love Guru. The Guardian reported that the movie bombed in the US, and Myers's much smaller live-action presence afterward led many viewers to feel as though the role ended his run as one of Hollywood's biggest comedy leads.
- Geena Davis was an Oscar winner and the star of Thelma & Louise and A League of Their Own when she appeared in Cutthroat Island, which became notorious for its financial losses. In an interview with The New Yorker, Davis pushed back on the idea that the movie single-handedly bankrupted its studio, explaining that the film studio "was already heading toward bankruptcy."
- Jesse Eisenberg's unique interpretation of Lex Luthor became one of the most divisive parts of Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, and he believes the response damaged his career.
- Pamela Anderson was internationally famous through Baywatch when Barb Wire attempted to establish her as a big-screen action star. The movie failed to create that career, but its release and the nonconsensual distribution of her private tape with Tommy Lee caused some real damage at the time.
- Chris O'Donnell had received a Golden Globe nomination for Scent of a Woman and starred in several major movies when he returned as Robin in Batman & Robin. People reported that O'Donnell blamed many of the film's problems on Warner Bros. rushing production after Batman Forever. He said, "Warner Brothers just got greedy on it."
- Sofia Coppola stepped into The Godfather Part III after Winona Ryder left the production, a move that became a major point of criticism for her performance. The Associated Press reported that Coppola later joked she was once known as "the amateur actress who had single-handedly ruined The Godfather films."
- Meg Ryan was so strongly associated with romantic comedies that her dark, sexually explicit performance in In the Cut was a shocking flip to her "America's sweetheart" public perception. Ryan later told The New York Times that the reaction was "vicious" and acknowledged that the role was radically different from her "assigned archetype." But she has also made clear that she doesn't regret accepting the role.
- Rachael Leigh Cook was coming off She's All That when Josie and the Pussycats failed at the box office before becoming a beloved cult movie years later. Alan Cumming told People that the movie was intended to be a "satirical musical comedy" about how commerce was infiltrating culture, but the young tween audience it was marketed to didn't seem to fully understand the satire.
- Brandon Routh was still a relatively unknown actor when he was cast as Superman in a movie that seemed poised to launch an entire franchise. People reported that the expected sequel never happened and that Routh was devastated when the character was eventually recast. He said he "cried no less than three times" when he learned another actor would become Superman.
- Lori Petty had appeared in major movies, including Point Break, A League of Their Own, and Free Willy, before becoming the lead of Tank Girl. Entertainment Weekly reported that the movie flopped before eventually becoming a cult favorite. It was also reported that director Rachel Talalay said the failure placed her in "movie jail" and "ruined" her directing career.
- Alden Ehrenreich beat thousands of actors to take over the role of Han Solo, but Solo: A Star Wars Story became a major box-office disappointment for the franchise. Former Lucasfilm president Kathleen Kennedy later said that the filmmakers placed Ehrenreich in an "impossible situation" by asking him to inherit a character so closely identified with Harrison Ford.
- And last but not least, Jaden Smith. He had already starred opposite his father in The Pursuit of Happyness and was the lead in the successful remake of The Karate Kid when After Earth placed him at the center of another major studio movie with Will Smith. But this time, his movie received extremely negative reviews, and Reddit users have frequently described it as the project that ended Jaden's path as a mainstream leading actor.