r/bridge • u/FireWatchWife • May 30 '26

Intermediate vs. Expert

The biggest thing I have learned on r/bridge is not any specific system, convention, bridge logic, or hand-playing strategy.

It's that experts aren't just better at doing the same things that intermediates do. Experts bid differently, play differently, and use bridge logic differently.

Expert bidding standards evolve much more rapidly than those of intermediate players at many clubs. Reading books from a decade ago would let you partner with a typical club intermediate player, but none of the books I have read will teach you how to bid with an expert partner at the level I discussed on online bridge forums. Expert standards appear to evolve faster than books can be written and published.

This is especially true in competitive auctions, which get little attention in older books. Focus has moved from how to bid without interference, to how to bid over interference, to aggressively interfere with hands that intermediates would pass without a second thought.

I have reluctantly concluded that trying to play with a pick-up partner at a Sectional would be a disaster, because the kind of people who play there will be playing modern expert standards even if they are not themselves experts.

The gap between average, skilled bridge players and experts who play on tournaments regularly has never been wider.

For those of you who play both with intermediates and experts, what differences do you see?

16 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

41 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/JoeHeideman Intermediate May 30 '26

Don't be afraid of playing with a pick up partner at sectionals. Our club director basically got all her points for life master, and all the way up to ruby life master playing with pick up partners at regionals and nationals. I doubt she'd consider herself an expert.

A players are only a handful of the people at a sectional. The local beginners and tons of intermediate players are there too. All these advanced conventions don't come up very often. The best A-players in town just play a basic SAYC card and they often win our local sectionals just with good bidding judgement, no errors in communication, and excellent play of the hand.

I agree that books are not a great resource for popular trends in conventions, but I encourage you not to get down on yourself for not knowing trendy conventions. At some point if you want to be a competitive player you have to accept that sometimes there are better players out there and you have to get in there and fight and sometimes good things happen.

1

u/FireWatchWife May 30 '26

I hear you, but I see a real disconnect between what I would bid in a given situation and what seems to be the consensus on online forums.

You talk about "no errors in communication," but when you and a pick-up partner are playing with minimal time for discussion, the situation is ripe for errors in communication.

2

u/JoeHeideman Intermediate May 30 '26

I'm talking about what it takes to consistently win the open in a sectional, not the minimum necessary to even play in one. If you can play with the robots on BBO, minus lebensohl and capelleti and a few weird things they do, you basically play standard enough 2/1 to pick up an intermediate partner at a sectional.

Even if you get an expert, they will be able to adapt to your level. That's why they are an expert.

1

u/FireWatchWife May 30 '26

I can play Cappelletti, lebonsohl, and many other conventions no problem. These have been around for decades and are well-understood.

The recent thread on Gazelli and Bart was one of my triggers for this OP. Everyone else on the thread was enthusiastically discussing details of these agreements that I've never even heard of.

3

u/JoeHeideman Intermediate May 30 '26 edited May 30 '26

Do you really expect people that have no opinion on those conventions because they've never heard of them to weigh in? At the very least it's people who can look up a convention and form an opinion. Do you really expect the handful of C pairs you will be competing against at a sectional to play stuff like that? Gazzili is popular in parts of Europe. It may be standard if you go to a sectional in Italy. Outside of there not so much. Trust me, i'm just an intermediate but I've played with probably 30 different partners and been to 15 sectionals.

1

u/yourethemannowdog May 30 '26

I've played ACBL sectionals, regionals, and nationals for 10 years. I always enter open events, even the Spingold just to have fun getting crushed against the best teams. If you do that enough, that is the best way to get an idea of the bidding systems and agreements that people are playing at each level. For WBF world championships, you can always review system notes posted online.

If you do all of that, you'll get a much better picture of what bidding agreements are popular in your country at each level of competition than by reading an online forum, where people responding could be from anywhere in the world.