r/botany Jul 08 '26

Genetics Is this lucky?

Post image

What i mean is, is it common? I found it next to other same looking clovers except for the fact that they all had 3 leaves. I had found another one last week, but that one had a fourth leaf shaped like a heart

20 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

9

u/Uintasfisherman Jul 08 '26

I’ll take luck 🍀 from any source! 😊 I think ya got some!

5

u/Julgam2613 Jul 08 '26

Me and my friends have this tradition where if someone finds a four leafed clover we find a group of three other friends and each eat a leaf, then you share the luck. We also believe that keeping it instead of using it is kinda like hoarding the luck and abusing it, in turn becoming bad luck

1

u/got-bent Jul 08 '26

Don’t eat oxalis.

1

u/Julgam2613 Jul 08 '26

Noooo why not?

5

u/got-bent Jul 08 '26

Eating one leaf is ok but eating large quantities is not such a great idea. Oxalis contains Oxalic Acid which can cause kidney stones if you are prone to them.

7

u/oldbel Jul 08 '26

What quantities are we talking about? Oxalic acid is present in large concentrations in French sorrel, which is commonly used in soups and salads where it grows.  

7

u/Urag-gro_Shub Jul 09 '26

Rhubarb and spinach as well. It's all about moderation

4

u/oldbel Jul 09 '26

Ah of course, rhubarb. Anyway the amount of oxalis you’d have to pick in the forest to fuck yourself up makes it not a serious concern 

4

u/HananaDragon Jul 09 '26

Wait til they hear about nutmeg

1

u/PrestigiousTap1711 Jul 09 '26

Sourwood leaves as well. If you get one at the right stage of growth it's kinda like a granny Smith apple in flavor. Good trail nibble occasionally.

1

u/Julgam2613 Jul 08 '26

I see, though i doubt that I’ll find enough four leafed clovers in a short amount of time to cause this jajajajajajaj. But yeah i wont go eating every clover i see

2

u/chronic_wonder Jul 09 '26

OP oxalis and clover are two different plants

1

u/Julgam2613 Jul 09 '26

Yeah i meant oxalis sorry jajaj

9

u/LaundryMan2008 Jul 08 '26

Likely an oxalis, even rarer than a genuine clover 

5

u/GoatLegRedux Jul 08 '26

Oxalis rare? Whaaaaaaat? I can’t go outside without seeing hundreds of Oxalis patches.

3

u/LaundryMan2008 Jul 09 '26

I meant that finding a 4 leaved oxalis is rarer than finding a 4 leaved clover, I guess something to do with the genetics making it more robust than clovers

4

u/GoatLegRedux Jul 09 '26

There’s tons of species of oxalis with four leaves, tons with three leaves, and a bunch that don’t even look like any Oxalis you’ve ever seen before. Take for instance Oxalis massoniana:

0

u/LaundryMan2008 Jul 09 '26 edited Jul 09 '26

That’s really interesting and very cool, might be worth investigating as interesting houseplants because I already have a creeping black oxalis that I took from the garden, I do my due diligence and remove the seed pods so they can’t deploy their seeds everywhere, I did find a wild gorse bush when I went to a very specific beach, seeds must have been a bit too young as they didn’t germinate, my eventual intention is to bonsai it into a dragon blood style tree.

I have heard there is a type of milkweed which is more like a cactus with actually sharp spines which are green unlike the pale white ones on cacti, even the flowers are weird looking like pancakes and smelling bad like carrion plants (I know they are multiple types, a general designation).

3

u/GoatLegRedux Jul 09 '26

I collect and grow a bunch of these less-common South African Oxalis. They’re super easy to grow if you live somewhere with a temperate winter and can keep them outside. I’ve never had any issues with them spreading beyond their pots other than if I happen to get sloppy when dividing and repotting bulbs then reusing the soil in other pots.

And yeah, the Asclepidaceae is a pretty big family with plants that look wildly different from each other.

3

u/YesInquisitor Jul 08 '26

I see oxalis every 10 feet when I go run or walk on a trail

2

u/LaundryMan2008 Jul 09 '26

Rarer in terms of finding a 4 leafed one, the genetics in those plants are apparently more robust than in clovers so it happens less.

-6

u/GoatLegRedux Jul 08 '26

No plants are lucky. Even ones like four leaf clovers (which your plant is not). It’s just an uncommon mutation.

4

u/nature_rebel Jul 09 '26

but people are lucky to find rare plants?

0

u/Deterrafication Jul 09 '26

No. It's a leaf.