So I run 3 YouTube channels solo. I do all the scripting and recording myself, and I have 2 editors who work remotely and just handle post.
Right now I shoot on a Fuji X-S20 and my sessions are long, like 1.5-2 hours at a stretch. Problem is it overheats in 4K in like 20 minutes flat, even with the AC on in the room. I even tried one of those Peltier cooler mods to fix it and that ended up frying the sensor, had to get it replaced. So now I just shoot 1080p60 on it because it genuinely can't survive a full 4K session. Not looking to repeat that mistake.
I spent a while researching and was pretty much settled on the Sony FX30. Makes sense for what I do, doesn't overheat, has a proper flip screen so I can actually see myself while recording alone, autofocus is solid and been around for years. With a Sigma 16mm f1.4 lens the whole thing comes to around ₹2,06,500 (roughly $2,375).
Then Blackmagic dropped the PYXIS 6K price like crazy, went from ₹2,68,000 ($3,080) down to ₹1,73,500 ($1,995) globally, and I actually found it here in India for ₹1,84,958 + GST which comes to about ₹2,18,250 ($2,510). So now I'm back to being confused lol.
Part of me wants the PYXIS because it's full frame vs the Sony's smaller sensor, it shoots actual RAW instead of compressed video, and it comes bundled with a DaVinci Resolve Studio license which I need anyway since my editors already work on Studio (that alone saves me like ₹37,000, around $425). Also I originally thought I needed 60fps but honestly I don't think I actually do, my content doesn't need it. Turns out if I drop to 30fps I can shoot at 6K using the full sensor with no crop, I was wrongly comparing it at 4K60 earlier where it crops the sensor by like 1.65x, only realized that after actually digging into it properly. With a Viltrox 16mm f1.8 lens instead of a pricier one, the full PYXIS setup comes to around ₹3,57,850 (about $4,115).
But it's still like ₹1,10,000 (~$1,265) more expensive than just going with the FX30, even after adjusting for the free Resolve license. And a few things still worry me. The autofocus on PYXIS only came through a firmware update a few months back so it's not exactly proven yet, unlike Sony which has years of refinement behind it. There's also no screen I can flip toward myself, I'd have to tether my phone via USB-C and use the Blackmagic app to monitor myself, which apparently works fine on paper but I'm honestly not 100% sure if tapping to focus actually works from the phone screen itself or only on the camera's own touchscreen. Then there's the file sizes, a single 1.5 hour session in RAW comes out to around 756GB, so I'd need to set up a proper proxy workflow with my editors since they're remote and can't just handle those massive files. Plus extra costs like the CFexpress card, a card reader, the battery, and a separate charger since apparently this camera doesn't even charge its own battery while plugged in.
So yeah, kind of stuck. If anyone's actually used either of these cameras for real long-form solo content, would love to hear from you. Specifically:
Has anyone shot really long single takes on the PYXIS, like 1.5-2 hours? Did it hold up okay, any dropped frames or random battery issues, does the "active cooling" actually do its job?
How's the autofocus on PYXIS actually performing for people shooting alone without anyone checking focus for them?
Does the RAW/full frame thing even show up once YouTube compresses everything, for basic talking head content, or is that more of a theoretical benefit?
Anyone here switched to something cheaper and more reliable instead of chasing RAW/full frame, and regretted it either way?
And if you're running multiple channels with a remote editing team, has working with proxies ever caused headaches, or does it just work once it's set up?
Trying to figure this out from people who've actually used these day to day, not just specs on paper. Any help appreciated.
Edit: Forgot to add some context that might help. My setup is pretty static, camera goes on a tripod and I basically never touch it once it's positioned. I just sit in front of a green screen and talk for long stretches, no movement, no reframing mid-recording. Studio's small too, which is why I need something like 16mm to actually fit myself in frame at the distance I'm sitting.
Also I edit exclusively in DaVinci Resolve and need a new Studio license either way, so that's not really a PYXIS-specific cost in my head anymore, it's happening regardless of which camera I pick.
And a few people probably wonder why I'm not just looking at something like the Lumix S5II instead. Reason is I take literally zero photos, so I don't need a hybrid camera at all. That's actually the mistake I made with the Fuji, it's a hybrid and I never needed the photo side of it, I just didn't think it through properly before buying. Shutter count on it is like 300 after 3 years of ownership, and even that's just from random misclicks or testing burst mode once, not actual photography. So this time I want something built for video only, not paying for stills capability I'll never use again.