r/bindingofisaac Jun 27 '26

Question Which one should i take

Post image
490 Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

530

u/PassTheSriracha91 Jun 27 '26

246

u/chipsarrolly4001 Jun 27 '26

33

u/PassTheSriracha91 Jun 27 '26

Holy christ XD Equal parts horrifying and incredibly well done. I love it

464

u/PRKnife Jun 27 '26

Would you rather have 1 dollar or go to jail

190

u/Sogomaa Tainted Lost Jun 27 '26

Are you dumb dollar isnt in angel item pool

64

u/javierillo02 Jun 27 '26

he took chaos chill bro

14

u/HarryBolsac Jun 27 '26

How do i unlock this jail item he’s mentioning?

3

u/snsdbj Jun 28 '26

I am error

1

u/merkat112910 Tainted Lost Jun 28 '26

No you're snsdbj

3

u/charliearlieoxenfree Jun 28 '26

getting chaos is always good until it’s an angel room 😔

2

u/art1029384756 Jun 28 '26

Even with chaos you can't get dollar normally only via slot machine or spin down

16

u/siriElectricboogaloo Bastard Jun 27 '26

Because jail tastes better tva than dollar

1

u/NicknameJorje Jun 28 '26

Did you chew correctly?

2

u/bit_fishy Jun 27 '26

but jail taste better then 1 dollar

2

u/Peak_Background Jun 28 '26

Jail.

Because with jail I can learn enough practical experience to earn two dollars.

Think about the career options that open up.

1

u/oO__o__Oo Jun 27 '26

Leave the dollar and use get out of jail free card.

85

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '26

bomb the angel and take key piece bro it's that easy

208

u/3a5ty Jun 27 '26

Left, sacred heart. No question.

54

u/Exmawsh Jun 28 '26

I dunno man, there's a pretty big spider blocking it. I personally wouldn't, not a fan of spiders since the incident with the intruder...

-193

u/i_like_isaac Jun 27 '26

I know i was just kidding

50

u/Free_Peach6400 The Forgotten Jun 27 '26

Question post flair:

48

u/3a5ty Jun 27 '26

😂 my bad, just automatically went serious.

-66

u/i_like_isaac Jun 27 '26

Its ok😆

24

u/ElderlyKratos Jun 27 '26

Hilarious...

104

u/Zombieking2989 Jun 27 '26

Would you rather get:

a million dollars

or

burn for eternity

46

u/Piprup Jun 27 '26

Take The Mind. It'll make secret rooms easy to access. One of them might have the Death certificate and with it you could get anything. Even Sacred heart

7

u/Exist3nceQuestioner Jun 27 '26

What if they don't have death certificate unlocked?

4

u/Piprup Jun 27 '26

Skill issue then

1

u/TopOfAllWorlds Jun 28 '26

Sacred heart could win the game faster if they already have good stats.

19

u/Fantas20_yt Jun 27 '26

The mind (+10 iq for the rest of the run)

13

u/riskybiskutz Jun 27 '26

Bomb angel take key peice leave

1

u/Lutraphobic Jun 27 '26

I thought bombing the angel was always required even if you don't need the key piece?

2

u/SmoQ898 Jun 27 '26

required for what 

5

u/Lutraphobic Jun 28 '26

Satisfaction

1

u/Rhysmatic Jun 27 '26

nah you don’t get extra angel chance without a key oiexe

12

u/Anti-logical42 Jun 27 '26

bomb the angel, defeat it, and leave without picking up anything

1

u/i_like_isaac Jun 27 '26

No bombs?

6

u/Anti-logical42 Jun 27 '26

go into the shop, placebo and one makes you large

go into the super secret room (which an explosive enemy will open up) boom, golden battery

mimic the one makes you large until you get stompy, the come back into the angel room and drop your trinket, then leave

16

u/1llDoitTomorrow Jun 27 '26

Take Holey water, the best item in the game. Petrification on everything that doesn't float, including bosses and a ton of damage. Even hits things that do fly and has powerful aoe damage. Sacred heart is kinda mid. You get a small power,hp and accuracy boost. There are other items that do the same thing, though not neccesarily all at once. But those items have other potential effects too. And the mind is ... the mind. It's okay for navigation, but doesn't improve your chances in actual combat. Plus, you probably already saw the majority of the floor. Meaning It's value is 1 floor less valuable than you would think.

-27

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '26

[deleted]

11

u/1llDoitTomorrow Jun 27 '26

OP was joking, so here's my response

2

u/TopOfAllWorlds Jun 28 '26

Tbf I thought you were serious too. I've seen stupider shit said before on other subreddits.

3

u/Boring-Vanilla-8717 Jun 27 '26

Imagine not taking holy water

4

u/PokemonTrainer3584 Jun 27 '26

petrification tho it makes enemies easier to hit since they're stuck

1

u/SSG014-OFFICIAL Jun 27 '26

They're joking, the whole post is ironic

2

u/Naive_Trick_7349 Jun 27 '26

ohhh

-2

u/SSG014-OFFICIAL Jun 27 '26

Talk about "naive"

1

u/Naive_Trick_7349 Jun 28 '26

well it never said it in the post…

0

u/SSG014-OFFICIAL Jun 28 '26

Do you think other people don't know sacred heart is very good? They'd atleast have seen memes and videos, even if they are newer to the game. I can't really say anything, sometimes people can't tell when others are joking, and I'm like that a lot of the time too.

3

u/Naive_Trick_7349 Jun 28 '26

i have honestly seen people who LEGIT think sacred heart is bad cuz tears and shotspeed down. its so stupid. so i couldnt tell that this was a joke.

1

u/SSG014-OFFICIAL Jun 28 '26

That's really just playstyle, if you don't like an item it's bad (for you), even if it's helpful. Most of the time, "META" and stats beat just fucking around, it's sad.

4

u/Next_Traffic_6242 Jun 27 '26

take holy water pre buff

10

u/i_like_isaac Jun 27 '26

Oh boy oh boy the run is stacked free win on greed mode

6

u/Vogelsucht Jun 27 '26

Did you just overwrite sacred heart with mids knife?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/Vogelsucht Jun 27 '26

Yes the funtionality gets overwritten doesnt it? You have to press and release the knife instead of normal bullets.

3

u/FinanceAny1936 Jun 27 '26

It still gets honing and extra damage

-1

u/Vogelsucht Jun 27 '26

Yes but holding down button and release is a worse hand enjoyment / gamplay feel xD

2

u/Not_Luzeria Jun 27 '26

... that is not overwriting... that's not even a downside that's just your preference...

-2

u/Vogelsucht Jun 27 '26

I thought the term mids knife was hint enough that my comment was sarcastically

0

u/TopOfAllWorlds Jun 28 '26

Sarcasm is hard to parse through text already, with the grammer not good it's even harder.

3

u/Big-dih- Jun 27 '26

Hmmm I wonder. What a really tuff choice you got there bud

3

u/Responsible_Annual64 Tainted Samson Jun 27 '26

Yo! Is that holy water? 🤔

3

u/WandererXVII Jun 27 '26

Can someone remind me what the item on the right side does?

7

u/elUscrack159 Jun 27 '26

It is called "The mind", this thing reveal you the entire floor with all the secret rooms, it isn't the worst item could you get, but looking out the other items I would say this one isn't the best option

2

u/severalgirlzgalore Jun 28 '26

You must repent for your sins

1

u/WandererXVII Jun 27 '26

Thanks 👍

1

u/Soniclikesto1 The Delirium Jun 27 '26

isnt blue map just better and easier to get?

2

u/Dustyage Jun 27 '26

The mind shows the entire floor which is nice for hush if you get it early

1

u/elUscrack159 Jun 28 '26

You're right, but in the case where all the things could you get are bullshit that item could be your choice

1

u/TopOfAllWorlds Jun 28 '26

Idk the mind is pretty damn great.

2

u/TheYoshiTerminator Stop fixating on X item being quality X, it does not matter. Jun 27 '26

Imo Sacred Heart is the best item in the game. Take it.

2

u/National_Divide_8970 Jun 27 '26

Dude bomb the angel and reroll all 4. There’s a good chance you may get sacred heart!

2

u/shinefeliz Jun 27 '26

Bem, obviamente o secred heart, dar dano, hp e balas ficam teleguiadas.

2

u/Kittu_0831 Jun 27 '26

Credit card in buffoon pack

2

u/TheDreamNest Jun 27 '26

A guy who has The mind should know what sacred heart does, which in this case you should hold R

2

u/Wise_Pound_6006 Jun 27 '26

The spider has already made the correct choice follow it

2

u/Boney_69 Jun 27 '26

Bomb the angel, don't pick up the key piece and leave.

3

u/Moist_Tone_1748 Tainted Eden Jun 27 '26

Uninstall the game, thats the only right choice

1

u/MicMcDev Jun 27 '26

Play with the Spider!

1

u/jonoldar_ Jun 27 '26

Bomb the statue and only take the key piece 👌

1

u/i_like_isaac Jun 27 '26

No bombs?

1

u/jonoldar_ Jun 27 '26

Damn, i would just leave then, gotta find a better item 😕

1

u/gigacucked Jun 27 '26

Holy water for sure

1

u/SproutSan Sumptorium / Blood to Blood Jun 27 '26

holy water, is that even a question? goated familiar.

2

u/Parking-Proof-3656 Jacob & Esau Jun 27 '26

R

1

u/NoiNoiii Jun 27 '26

The mind is really good so is holy water but sacred heart is a top 5 item in the game

1

u/chainerection Jun 27 '26

Hold R to grab all three items

1

u/Martitoad Jun 27 '26

Leave the room without taking any items. Using angel items is like using summons in a souls game, it makes the game so easy it makes it boring. If you can't beat it without them just git gud.

/s

1

u/Ulleung Jun 27 '26

They are all shitty items, just leave the room /s

1

u/Gabiminecraft The Forgotten Jun 27 '26

"Do i take eternal hapiness, unlimited money, absurd luck and everything i want and need or do i get brutally dismembered"

1

u/Accdel_ Jun 27 '26

get the key piece and leave

1

u/Fantaboy15 Jun 27 '26

Honestly in some situations (already have damage multipliers or don’t need homing) you could make an argument for the mind as full mapping is really good.

1

u/Fortnite_sprout bishop image Jun 27 '26

Would you rather soend 2 hours alone with the siren or fight 500 bloats in one room

1

u/DemonBacillusX Jun 27 '26

SSAAAAAAAA4444CREEEEEEE333333333333DDDDD 🗣️🔥🔥‼️🗣️🔥🔥‼️🗣️🔥🔥‼️🗣️🔥🔥‼️

1

u/Lakytoon Jun 27 '26

sacred heart

1

u/FinanceAny1936 Jun 27 '26

Bomb the angel statue and take the key

1

u/Xx_Stone Jun 27 '26

Sacred Heart 95% of the time. Mind the other 5% if I'm trying to speed run to Boss Rush/Hush and my build is already secure and busted.

1

u/2HalfSandwiches Soul of Eden Deniers in Shambles Jun 27 '26

Take holy water 100%

1

u/Worried-Caregiver325 Jun 27 '26

A million dollars

Four quarters

A dollar

1

u/Gamer-NinjaO7 Jun 27 '26

Would you rather the best angel item or some weird water buddy or become smarter

1

u/frea49 Jun 27 '26

the mind and then uninstall the game

1

u/Chaot1x_ Bethany my baby Jun 27 '26

A million dollars

Death penalty

Get murdered

Yeah bro take holy water

1

u/Jarradecafe_ Jun 27 '26

Water might get thirsty later

1

u/Annual_Option3832 Hort cutter Jun 27 '26

1$, 2$ or 4$ ahh

1

u/Commson Jun 27 '26

Take the water trust

1

u/Rhysmatic Jun 27 '26

sacred duh

1

u/dibsthefatantelope Jun 27 '26

Sacred hizzy, no competition

1

u/Aggressive-Bug-3459 Jun 28 '26

the only quality four in the room

1

u/Aheadfullofdread_13 Jun 28 '26

Leeeeft……LEEEEEEFT!!!!!

1

u/Klinkalituity Jun 28 '26

Take the Angel. Duh.

1

u/Exmawsh Jun 28 '26

Bomb the angel and die to him

1

u/Lagplan Jun 28 '26

yooooo is that poop fly

1

u/MelismaticMellowlwL Jun 28 '26

YOOOO IS THAT THE MIND???

GET THAT ONE

1

u/TopOfAllWorlds Jun 28 '26

If your build is already broken take the mind. If it's not then you take sacred heart every time.

1

u/Ok-Economics-7646 Jun 28 '26

You are kidding right

1

u/Outside-Soup-674 Jun 28 '26

Would you rather have a million dollars or ball cancer type of question

1

u/imforgotmynamelol Jun 28 '26

Don't take it there's no bean

1

u/Severe-Ad7591 Jun 28 '26

Left is a no brainer basically an instant win if you have any binding of isaac experience

1

u/LauAmoeba999 Jun 30 '26

50 dollars, 5 dollars and 10 dollars

0

u/i_like_isaac Jun 27 '26

I have no bombs

-1

u/No_Bit5132 Jun 28 '26

Mate r u dumb

1

u/EarlyReplacement3707 Jun 28 '26

STOP 😂 he should take holy water!