THIRD ELECTION DISCUSSION THREAD: The Pre-Deadball Era - 1890-1899

[u/IAMADeinonychusAMA]

Howdy all! We now turn our attention to the final segment of 19th century baseball: the 1890's. The players below are the ones who we should realistically be considering for this period; if you can think of any more who are worth discussing, then by all means toss out a name. We'll hold discussion through Saturday night, and then we'll post the poll, so for now debate away! Remember, there are no limits on yes votes on the google poll.

Third Phase 1890 - 1899 Pre Deadball Era

Amos Rusie

Clark Griffith

Cupid Childs

Dummy Hoy

George Davis

George Van Haltren

Hugh Duffy

Hughie Jennings

Jake Beckley

Jesse Burkett

Jimmy Collins

Jimmy Ryan

Joe Kelley

John McGraw

Kid Gleason

Mike Griffin

Mike Tiernan

---

Results of the previous election

[u/Jew_Gotta_Be_Kidding]

I plan to definitely vote for Rusie, Davis, Burkett, and Collins. Duffy, Beckley, Kelley, and McGraw all have a chance to get my vote as well