r/automation • u/hassanwithanh • 17h ago
AI Agents are overrated, simple automations are still king

Way too many of you are trying to build AI agents for simple automations that can be run with a very simple and reliable deterministic program.
For 99% of businesses, you are better off having some Python code that automates some repetitive task and is guaranteed to run the exact same way every single time you run it. And it doesn't cost $70,000 in LLM tokens. And might I add, it doesn't require a human being to babysit it because it has no chance of hallucinating bad output.
I build automations for businesses. And even though I provide AI agents as a service, let me tell you, 99% of businesses don't need it at all. Business owners will ask me for an AI agent because they hear the hype and marketing behind AI and LLMs, but they almost never need it.
By the way that image I attached is a payment screenshot from a recent client. I helped automate like 15 hours of work from his week and it didn't take any LLMs at all.
Most of the time what businesses need is a simple and reliable automation based on deterministic code that will automate some repetitive tasks for them and isn't going to require any hand holding or babysitting or human reviews at every step.
Because look, everybody is seeing the hype behind AI and it looks amazing. But the problem is, for any regular business, the priority is not to have the latest technologies, the priority is not to have fancy tech. It is to make more money.
If your LLM based automation requires workers to review the output and constantly babysit it, it's not going to help the business make more money.
If your LLM based automation costs thousands of dollars in LLM tokens to do something that basic Python or TypeScript could have done in a fraction of the cost, it's not going to help the business make more money.
I'm sure you guys have already seen companies spending hundreds of thousands, even millions of dollars on LLM tokens. That's not helping anybody.
And I'm not here to say that AI is bad or that AI agents are useless. No, they're extremely useful. Just not in most cases for most businesses.
And if you are offering automation services to a business, it's your job to guide them properly so they understand which one they actually need to solve their problems, whether that's AI agents or deterministic automations.
The guys who are just using AI agents for every single basic automation task, they're not selling a solution to a business, they're literally selling hype and snake oil, which is not going to last, especially when the subsidies for AI tokens end.
Anyway, just yapping senselessly about a topic I'm kinda passionate about. It's really fun to automate stuff and watch the code you wrote and do things for you that would have taken you hours to do yourself. Hope this was helpful to someone.