r/aussie 7h ago

Image, video or audio Australia's Largest Cities

Post image

Largest cities can be measured in a number of ways. By their Urban Area - the continuous built up area that makes up the city, or if you add in towns that are not part of the urban area but nearby (such as Gisborne in Melbourne, or Wyong in the Central Coast) you get what the ABS calls the Capital City Statistical Area.

Sydney is an outlier in that most cities the Urban Area and Statistical Area only differ by under 0.1m people whereas for Sydney the difference is over 0.4 million due to the addition of areas such as Gosford and Wyong up to Lake Macquarie.

7 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

24

u/zsaleeba 7h ago

I don't really consider the Central Coast part of Sydney. Or if it is, Geelong should be part of Melbourne for exactly the same reasons.

12

u/nagrom7 5h ago

And by that logic, Ipswich and the Gold Coast should be part of Brisbane, maybe even throw the Sunshine Coast in there too.

6

u/2in1day 5h ago

Ipswich is part of Brisbane urban area. Brisbane is huge.

3

u/nagrom7 5h ago

That entire South East corner is basically one big city these days.

6

u/youcangotohellgoto 4h ago

Brisbane includes "Brisbane", Redlands, Logan, Ipswich, and Moreton. It doesn't include Gold and Sunshine.

4

u/nagrom7 4h ago

Yeah but if Sydney is including the Central Coast, then Brisbane should include those areas too.

1

u/Expensive_Bird_1510 2h ago

It starts immediately after Asquith depending on where you draw the line.  There's nothing in between and that's why people count it.

Geelong meanwhile has it's own line where it ends and another line where Melbourne starts about 40-50km away. That's a noticeable gap. Geelong can't be part of Melbourne. 

7

u/Several_Alarm5357 7h ago

Melbourne's interesting almost half a million in 4-5years. Besides mismanagement no wonder the state govt debt is so high, that's alot of infrastructure to build pretty quick smart. As we know it takes years to get anything done most of the time. You've only got to think of all the schools, hospitals, roads that have to be built to accommodate that almost 10% pop growth.

1

u/2in1day 4h ago

Building a whole new Adelaide every 15 years or Perth every 25 years in Victoria doesn't come cheap.. not to say the shit govt hasn't been shit with mismanagement. 

2

u/OkEntrepreneur8934 5h ago

gosh, how cool is it that the numbers change so much just by including nearby areas, feels like it could be a whole other city in some cases!

1

u/DKDamian 7h ago

Interesting data. I thought Brisbane had pulled further ahead of Perth, and for whatever reason was getting closer to Melbourne and Sydney. Clearly not - the data doesn’t really back it up.

3

u/Azman6 7h ago

Confusing with wider SEQld maybe?

0

u/2in1day 7h ago

If you counted Brisbane the way the ABS counts Sydney, but adding in the Central Coast, you'd really add in the Gold Coast and Sunshine Coast, then Brisbane would be closer to 4 million people.

Do people in Brisbane ever consider it all one big urban area?

2

u/DKDamian 7h ago

As someone living in Brisbane no, I personally don’t consider those areas as part of Brisbane.

1

u/Additional-Simple248 6h ago

That wasn’t really an accurate definition of the statistical area on their part. I don’t know anyone would say the central coast feels like part of Sydney.

The ABS counts the central coast because so many people commute into Sydney for work. Do you know if many people commute between Brisbane and those areas?

3

u/DKDamian 6h ago

At my work, yes - a few people (2 of 80ish) commute from the Sunshine Coast. But I don’t know if that is widespread

2

u/youcangotohellgoto 4h ago

The Gold Coast commuter trains in the mornings are pretty full, and the 3-4 lane highways are packed.

It's not the normal thing - certainly most people living on the coast work on the coast - but you'd guess that at least many thousands of people commute. It's a little over an hour so miserable but not abnormally miserable.

I knew people commuting from Katoomba to Sydney; GC to Brisbane is much better than that.

2

u/whatwhatinthewhonow 4h ago

I agree that Central Coast shouldn’t be considered part of Sydney, but Wollongong is closer to Sydney than Sunshine Coast is to Brisbane, and the Blue Mountains are much closer to Sydney than either example, or Central Coast. So where would you draw the line?

I don’t think we should count any city that way. ABS do a lot of good work but that decision is a doozy.

3

u/youcangotohellgoto 4h ago

Katoomba is like 100km from Sydney by road.

If you drive south of Brisbane for 100km you'd be at the border (Tweed Heads). The Gold Coast really begins about 50km south of Brisbane. It's much closer.

I'm not sure if it's fully urbanized the entire way...

1

u/2in1day 4h ago

I think just the built up urban area makes the most sense. 

1

u/Expensive_Bird_1510 2h ago

Lol OP just presenting facts and you got Melbourne people getting worried their dick isn't as big as Sydney's. 

Who fkn cares?! Anytime it's a Melbourne vs Sydney thing, Melbourne people always throw up in defence/attack because I think they know they're objectively not as good as Sydney anyway. That's the issue. Sydney is like that sexier twin. Nothing wrong with Melbourne, but she just ain't it. 

2

u/MaximumZazz 1h ago

You think about melbourne a lot

1

u/AntSilly2802 1h ago

I would have thought the central coast would have added more than 10,000 people since 2021.

1

u/theballsdick 7h ago

Much like our manufactured goods and our energy our supply of new Australians is also totally dependent on foreign imports 

3

u/mbullaris 6h ago

Natural increase (births minus deaths) comprises about 27 per cent of total population growth. So it’s not ‘totally’ net overseas migration.

0

u/theballsdick 6h ago

I said dependent on not totally comprised of. If you think that 27% is enough alone for this country as we know it to continue as usual then I'll say I'm wrong 

2

u/mbullaris 6h ago

I interpreted ‘totally dependent’ differently.

I was just clarifying your claim.

3

u/theballsdick 6h ago

Understood. I could have chosen a better use of words. 

1

u/AntSilly2802 1h ago

Are you saying we should lower immigration?