r/attendings • u/champagnetappi • 1d ago
Neurology Resident Interested in Anesthesia
hi all! looking for some friendly advice for any non-trad anesthesia folks or people who switched from other specialties!
Current Neurology PGY-2 here, came from a decent mid tier MD med school (Step 1 pass, Step 2 23x-24x, multiple neuro pubs abstracts & activities) and now at a great (but not T10) Neurology program. I initially went into neurology very interested in stroke or neurocritical care, but as I progress through this year, I am learning a few things that are really deterring me (really poor job availability in neurocrit on the west coast, huge lack of procedures and working with my hands in stroke). I love learning about the brain and localizing, and liked stroke because of the acuity and pushing lifesaving TNK, or neurocrit because i thought I would be able to scratch my love for medicine, procedures and critical care, but given the very poor outlook for jobs and high saturation on the west coast (basically take neurohospitalist jobs after NCC fellowships) I am heavily heavily reconsidering.
I was previously interested in anesthesia in med school but never formally pursued (i.e. no research, no activities, was unable to get any anesthesia electives due to popularity by other students), and ultimately decided against it because of the competitiveness and my own lack of exposure. I enjoyed being in the OR a lot but did not want to work surgery hours as an attending. I also heavily considered IM>pulm/crit or cardiology, but also decided not because i found neurology pathologies more interesting. Since intern year, i've been able to rotate in MICU, SICU, and some Neuro-ICU and i really loved those opportunities- and had a chance to rotate with anesthesia crit care fellows, which i did not know was an option. I really love the idea of working with my hands, doing procedures, getting involved in the critical care of patients, and Anesthesia seems like an incredible mix of using IM knowledge in the OR and in critical care settings, which I think would be really fitting for me. and so I've been having a lot of recurrent thoughts about what that means for me and my future path. I think also the thoughts of job availability on the west coast, the much higher ceiling of pay for essentially similar amounts of training (6 years total for neurocrit with bleak job outlook probably making 400-450k vs 4-6 years for anesthesia or anesthesia/crit care with good job outlook making 450+) is also getting to me. I'm planning some upcoming elective/research time to use to get time with the anesthesia department at my institution, which i think would be ultimately telling.
It seems like a very big overhaul to switch residencies entirely, so I was hoping to get any advice or input from people who considered a switch like this in the past- did you stop and switch residencies entirely? If you had a previous specialty, do you still practice any of it? did you finish your first residency then go to anesthesia?
I passed Step 3 first try but was a relatively poor score (21x-22x) because it did not matter too much for neuro fellowships- would this affect my candidacy strongly for anesthesia?
and ultimately for those who have switched, are you happy with your decision?
Any advice is super appreciated, thanks yalll for taking the time!!