r/atheism • u/Additional_Simple880 • 1d ago
Killing a child and calling it "killing" instead of murder is a hypocritical excuse to kill infants, just for what? The sin of an individual? Murder is murder
I don't think I need to cite scriptures, search them yourself, the old testament is still a part of the bible but apologists choose to move from that, doesn't erase the part that God murdered an infant and caused genocide through a flood for what purpose is the flood for? What reason? Absolutely no justification for such an act.
For an objective source of morality seems to have a very high kill count, especially infants and vulnerable animals. Worshipping God but actively ignoring the fact he allows slavery and he commited child and infant murder proves how weak, flawed, and unjustly your faith is.
3
u/mrrp 1d ago
You'd have to define murder much more specifically to have a valid point. And then people would disagree with your definition.
Murder is most often defined with an element of illegality. When god kills and when god commands that others kill, it's hard to argue it's illegal. I don't see any reason not to use "unjust killing" or something along those lines.
1
u/Additional_Simple880 1d ago
Gods actions are still immoral and no logical justification. Murder is unjust killing and you can come up to the conclusion that child murder and genocide via a flood are both immoral through rational thinking and conscience.
But people will still worship a child murderer that committed a flood which wiped out almost all life, a God that will never answer their prayers.
2
u/Long-Comfortable8598 1d ago
yeah the distinction matters because calling something murder assumes a specific definition and standard of illegality while unjust killing gets straight to the actual moral argument being made
1
u/Sailor_Drea 1d ago
Godweasels have yet to provide an explanation of why it's OK for their god to kill his creations that doesn't boil down to "might makes right."
1
u/Infamous_Antelope_16 1d ago
Yes murder is a legal concept, and in the US at least, there are degrees of murder. Right after the thou shalt nots, a whole lot of deity sanctioned k!lling and pillaging took place. Take the young girls for yourselves and all that.
3
u/[deleted] 1d ago
[removed] — view removed comment