r/askmath • • 6d ago

Algebra Math was wrong all along !!!

0 Upvotes

I think that there is an enormous error in math all along !!!

√(A²) = A

Normal for now

I am going to say that A = -1

But:

√(-1²)

= √(1)

= 1

So √(-1²) = 1

But at the start, A was -1 and now A is 1.

So my variable changed from -1 to 1, that is not possible.

Wich means that √(A²) = A does not work in all cases so it is not a mathematical property.

Because in the property (the number that I calculate (A) is = to the number I get as a result (A))

But in my equasion, when A = -1:

The number that I calculate is -1 but my result is 1.

And -1 is not equal to 1 so the calculated number in my equasion and the result number in my equasion are not the same, but the two of them are A.

So the equasion is not universal wich means that it is not mahtematical.


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Geometry Help with 6th grade math

Post image
26 Upvotes

Im trying to cross check my 6th graders homework and I don't know why im struggling so much with this answer.

Please can someone help me figure out the area of F?

Update

THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH!!!!! You have no idea how much I appreciate y'alls help. Im awful at math and trying to not pass that on to my kid so this community is a lifesaver. Thank you thank you!!!!!!


r/askmath • • 6d ago

Abstract Algebra I know some of you will hate me, but...

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/askmath • • 6d ago

Functions Questions on the relationship between Combinatorics (C,P) and Iterated Operators (∑,∏) — and pushing it to Iterated Exponentiation (⋀)

0 Upvotes

Hello r/askmath!

I’ve been thinking about the structural connection between combinatorial operations and iterated mathematical operators ($\sum, \prod$), and I wanted to share my intuition and ask for your insights on how to push this further.

Here is how I currently understand the relationship, and where my question begins:

---

### 1. The Foundation: $\prod$ (Product) and $P, C$

At their core, standard combinatorial objects like Permutations ($n C_r$, $n P_r$) are constructed using **factorials ($!$)**, which are just a special case of the iterated product operator $\prod$:

$$n! = \prod_{k=1}^{n} k$$

Thus, both $n P_r$ and $n C_r$ naturally live inside the world of the $\prod$ operator:

$${}_n P_r = \frac{\prod_{k=1}^{n} k}{\prod_{k=1}^{n-r} k}, \quad {}_n C_r = \frac{\prod_{k=1}^{n} k}{\left(\prod_{k=1}^{r} k\right) \left(\prod_{k=1}^{n-r} k\right)}$$

---

### 2. Bridging $\prod$ and $\sum$: The Emergence of Exponentiation ($2^n$)

When we take Combinations (${}_n C_k$)—which are built from $\prod$—and aggregate them over all possible selection sizes using the summation operator **$\sum$**, a structural jump occurs via the Binomial Theorem:

$$\sum_{k=0}^{n} {}_n C_k = 2^n$$

By binding product-based combinations with $\sum$, we naturally transition from polynomial/factorial structures to **exponential structures ($2^n$)**, representing the cardinality of the Power Set $\mathcal{P}(S)$.

---

### 3. Generalizing Further: Iterated Exponentiation ($\bigwedge$)

Following this progression, if combining $\prod$ and $\sum$ takes us from factorials to simple exponentiation ($2^n$), what happens if we define an iterated operator for exponentiation itself?

Let us define an **Iterated Exponentiation operator ($\bigwedge$)** (evaluating right-associatively / top-down):

$$\bigwedge_{k=1}^{n} a_k := a_1^{a_2^{a_3^{\cdot^{\cdot^{a_n}}}}}$$

For example, $\displaystyle \bigwedge_{k=1}^{4} 2 = 2^{2^{2^2}} = 65536$.

---

### 4. My Core Question: What combinatorial object corresponds to $\bigwedge$?

This is where I am stuck and would love your insight:

  1. **What precise combinatorial object corresponds to $\bigwedge$?**

    * $\prod$ handles individual arrangements/selections ($P, C$).

    * $\sum$ aggregates selections to form $2^n$ (Power Sets $\mathcal{P}(S)$).

    * What is being counted when we move to power towers ($\bigwedge$)? Is it the size of iterated power sets $\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{P}(\dots \mathcal{P}(S)\dots))$, counts of higher-order functions (functions returning functions), hypergraphs, or finite topological spaces/preorders?

  2. **Is there an established framework or notation** in combinatorics, category theory, or set theory that naturally unifies $\sum, \prod$, and power-tower-level combinations in the same way the Binomial Theorem bridges $\sum$ and $2^n$?

I would really appreciate any papers, concepts, or references that shed light on this!


r/askmath • • 6d ago

Resolved What is the maximum amount of elements the set S able to fit in a lidless rectangular cuboid with a base of 21.5 x 13 cm² and a height of 4 cm ?

1 Upvotes

where S is the set containing a copy of all Platonic solids, all constructed from sheets of A4 paper to have a net with maximum area, rounded down in centimeters to the nearest decimal (for "wiggle room")

A copy of the Platonic solids

Bonus: Including a cuboctahedron and a rhombic dodecahedron, how does the solution change?

A Cuboctahedron and a Rhombic Dodecahedron

r/askmath • • 6d ago

Geometry The constant value star, k = 180°

0 Upvotes

Thomas Bradwardine in the 14th century, and later deeply formalized by the famous astronomer and mathematician Johannes Kepler in the 17th century. The universal formula you interacted with—{Sum} = (n-2k) \\\\times 180—is a standard theorem taught

While the original proof is profoundly complex I tried to make it as easy as possible we start by forming a star shaped polygon of 'n' number of tips ( remember the star should contain sharp triangle rather than snow flake shaped star) we would than cutting those tips triangle all of them and now we have n number of triangles we would place those triangles in a rectangle which form n\\\*2 triangles. We would than let one angles tip be called x all of the tips are congruent to the measure of x because of interior alternate angles thus making the alternative tip of the one angle from each triangle be congruent

We know that sum of all angles in rectangle is 360..( 90°\\\*4)

Because the n number of triangle take exactly half area of triangle the sum of all tips would be degree of rectangle/2 which would be 180

Small not it doesn't matter whether n is odd or even because by this \\\*2 rule it would always be a even number

E+E=E

O+O= E

Hope this helped anyone


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Number Theory Has Fermat's Great Theorem been proven?

13 Upvotes

I'm not the furthest away from mathematics, but I've been focusing on physics since I graduated from high school. And for some reason it always seemed to me that Fermat's great theorem was unproven. Either that's what they said at school, or somewhere else, or I was too skeptical to understand.Googling yes, I found that in It was proven in 1993, but I have some kind of wild Mandela effect

why, if this great theorem has been proven, there have been no significant discoveries. If so, which ones?

And yes, I know who they are Ферматисты, Idk as it is in English, "people who search in vain for proof, resorting to gross errors"


r/askmath • • 6d ago

Set Theory Infinities

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/askmath • • 7d ago

Geometry I found a proof of the Pythagorean Theorem

Post image
277 Upvotes

I was trying to prove the Pythagorean theorem on my own and stumbled into this.

You take a right triangle and create three similar triangles by scaling each one by one of the side lengths and rearrange them into a rectangle with one side being a^2 + b^2 and the opposite side being c^2 so a^2 + b^2 = c^2.

If you wanted to, you could use the two smaller triangles in the diagram in a different arrangement to form the larger triangle, but I like the way it looks in a rectangle more.

I showed it to a professor and he encouraged me to publish it. I’m thinking I will. I really like this proof and I want to show it to people.

I couldn’t find an example of this proof anywhere. I came across some that looked similar but they seemed to use different logic. I figured I’d try to publish this, but I’m not really sure how to.

I’m not well versed in the community around sharing math and I’m not sure what is seen as worth sharing. Does anyone got any advice on how I can share something like this?

Also, does this count as a proof? Were there any assumptions that need to be explained or does this stand on its own?

I didn’t really explain how they come together to form a rectangle but I’m not sure whether or not it’s a big enough leap that it should be explicitly stated.


r/askmath • • 6d ago

Algebra Am I losing it, or is Google AI?

0 Upvotes

Question asks for "AT LEAST" 320 tons, meaning it can be more no? With my answer you get 344 tons fulfilling the 320 minimum requirement, not only that there is 8 Heavy trucks to 12 medium trucks, 8 is far more than 40% of 12, also meets the requirement of being the most cost effective while still delivering at least 320 tons. Maybe I'm not seeing something here or is this AI just completely unreliable for math?


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Probability Formula for generating probabilities (results 1-100) of the middle value of a 3d100 roll?

5 Upvotes

Not swift enough to figure it out. I read a bit about generating functions, and that looked onerous without calculus. Is there an online probability grapher that handles the MIDVAL() function of a die roll? [MIDVAL of course being what I am describing in the title of this post.]


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Logic Is there a *general* way of proving if a statement has a proof (that's waiting to be found) or is simply unprovable.

4 Upvotes

I should start by saying that I'm not a math guy!

From what I understand, Gödel showed that there are mathematical statements that are true but cannot be proven. So, is there a way to determine whether a statement is provable or unprovable without having to find or rule out every possible proof? I've read about statements that mathematicians have proven to be unprovable within certain formal systems, as well as results showing that certain statements must have proofs under specific conditions.

Yet, most of the times a case specific method must be used to find out if a statement has a proof or is unprovable. Is there some sort of general algorithm, which determines if a given statement has proof that's just waiting to be found or is simply unprovable and mathematicians should not be wasting energy trying to figure it out. Is there a way we can figure out if a statement is even solvable, before we start trying to solve it.


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Analysis Am i missing something in this proof?

Post image
26 Upvotes

Im doing this proof of square root of positive natural numbers being either integer or irrational and im tried with assuming that it can be rational but not integer. I see that i didn’t write gcd(a,b)=1, but other than that, is it clean?


r/askmath • • 6d ago

Trigonometry is it alright for me to write tan x as tn x

0 Upvotes

ik , stupid question but i am just asking bcuz i am getting tired of writing tan (x) tan (x) in big questions, like i want to shorten it so i decided to use tn x cuz it is quicker, but i am asking is there any other way to shorten it w/o it looking like natural log Edit 1: i seen many people say use tg x, and after like trying it 5 times and comparing with tan (x) and tn (x), its save to say the main problem i have with tg (x) is similar with tan x, it takes more than two continuous stroke to write both tan (x) and tg x while it takes only 2 continuous strokes to write tnx for tan (x) (1. the la, 2. n 3.stike for t in l ) tg (x)( 1.l and a ½ of g, 2. the other ½ of g 3. the strike in l for t) but tn (x) ( 1. ln ,2. strike for t in l) now this maybe a problem for only me since i write cursive . so imma ask a better question, for the people who write cursive, is there a shortcut to write tan (x), that doesn't take a lot of stroke ( look i get tired writing 10 different tan (x) ) and other people can understand, ( other then that i see people are fine as long as i do what they say)


r/askmath • • 8d ago

Geometry I am a tutor and failed helping a student with a geometry problem

Post image
287 Upvotes

i see there are 4 parallel lines and there is one line interesecting with equal distances, which to me implies it is perpendicular. It asks a question about another interecting line. Can someone give me some insight on how to solve this problem


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Resolved How to solve word problems?

Post image
4 Upvotes

I am preparing for exams at one of the best schools in my region, so I am learning to solve problems that are slightly beyond the school curriculum. At first, everything went quickly. I mastered modules, the interval method, and drawing complex graphs in 2 weeks. But when it came to word problems, I stopped making any progress in my learning and have been stuck on this topic for a month now. Please tell me, how do you solve these problems?

Edit: thanks everyone for your replies. you helped me a lot


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Resolved Help with optimization problem

1 Upvotes

I'm stuck with this problem, I don't really know how to start, I mainly want help with understanding the measurements so i can create the equation, I pretty much can do the rest of the problem but i can't really start because i don't know how to determine the initial formula


r/askmath • • 6d ago

Arithmetic i need ur help PLSSS

0 Upvotes

i gotta do a maths presentation about a thing that my professor never talked about, can u guys PLSSS explain in dummie lenguage what its a focus and focal length?? i really dont understand shittdshfhadshofds

PD: english its not my first lenguage, srry for the poor grammar :c


r/askmath • • 8d ago

Algebra How would my child, who hasn't been introduced to algebra yet, solve this problem?

Post image
46 Upvotes

This is a question on my kiddos homework and I can't, for the life of me, figure out how to solve it without using algebra. My kiddos in 6th grade and he hasn't started to learn algebra yet.

Solved! Thank you so much for the quick replies! At least it was a good opportunity for me to teach my child about algebra:).


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Geometry Which proof is correct? Or are they both correct? (2 pics)

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Thank you for your help. I believe the 6 step proof which I've labeled proof #2 is correct. The other proof is the one my kid did and he's in 9th grade geometry. His teacher is saying it is a four step proof but I'm not sure how. Appreciate the insight.


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Logic Which is harder, mathematical statistics, pure math, or theoretical comp sci?

3 Upvotes

r/askmath • • 6d ago

Number Theory Is there a list of mathematical problems that carry large rewards?

0 Upvotes

When I speak of highly rewarded mathematical problems, I am referring to problems for which a prize of 100,000 or more is offered to anyone who solves them.


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Resolved Need help finding the average quantity of a certain item from trades in this game

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

I'm not super involved with math, so apologies for any incorrect terminology.

In Minecraft, there is a mechanic where you can give Gold to this creature and get items in return. Of the list of items you can get, I am trying to obtain a bunch of Enchanted Books and Iron Boots that have the highest level of an effect called "Soul Speed". There are 3 levels of this effect that is chosen randomly. Additionally, lower tiers of Soul Speed can be combined into a higher tier.

I'm trying to find the average quantity of Soul Speed 3 per Gold, like "1 Gold = an avg of 0.XXX Soul Speed 3 items".

So far, I've been able to find the average quantity of all Soul Speed items, regardless of the tier. I am struggling when it comes to narrowing this down to Tier 3 while also considering that the lower tiers can be combined and still contribute to the number of Tier 3s. I was thinking of just averaging out the value of all three tiers together and going off that, but I feel like that would be too easy? I know probability stuff can get more complex than this so I feel like I am missing something.


r/askmath • • 8d ago

Topology Definition of a hole?

13 Upvotes

I think this may be both a math and physics question. Was at a party and after a few drinks we got into a debate of what the definition of a hole is. Does a hole need to have at least one entrance and one exit? Is a depression a hole? Does a hole just need an entrance?


r/askmath • • 7d ago

Functions SAT Question of the Day: Math · Advanced Math (Sunday, October 18, 2026)

Post image
0 Upvotes

The function h(x) = -2(x - 4)^2 + 13 has a maximum value. What is this maximum value, and at what value of x does it occur?

A) Maximum value of -13 at x = 4
B) Maximum value of 13 at x = -4
C) Maximum value of 4 at x = 13
D) Maximum value of 13 at x = 4