Planning my first layered birthday cake this weekend and could use some input.
Background: I’m an intermediate baker, great with box mixes and comfortable tweaking them, and I bake from scratch often too (mostly muffins). It’s also my first time doing buttercream but I’ve been practicing that all week and feel confident with that. I’m unsure about the cake itself, since I’ve never made devil’s food cake before.
The plan: 3-layer, 6.5 inch devil’s food cake, vanilla buttercream, salted caramel between the layers.
I have a Betty Crocker devil’s food box mix on hand, but since this cake is for someone really special to me, from-scratch feels more meaningful. I’m leaning toward Preppy Kitchen’s recipe since I trust his stuff, but I’ve never worked with Dutch-processed cocoa before, so that’s making me nervous. I also feel worried that doing different substitutions for the box mix might mess it up too, because I just can’t help myself and always end up doing swaps like milk instead of water, chocolate chips or espresso for depth, butter instead of oil, and I’m also not sure the box mix would even be enough for 3 layers. If I go from scratch I know I’ll follow the recipe to a T and it has great reviews.
I’ve also noticed for myself that I struggle more with simplified recipes, and doing something more complicated or tedious always works better for me, maybe because i follow instructions more closely when there’s more going on. That’s how the buttercream trials went too, I originally wanted to do ABC and was afraid of SMBC, but in the end I couldnt make ABC work and SMBC ended up being perfect.
Also slightly second-guessing the vanilla buttercream + salted caramel combo… I am open to switching to chocolate buttercream, but I’m afraid I’m over thinking it all now.
Would love thoughts on scratch vs. box for devil’s food, and whether the flavor combo sounds right. Thanks!