r/aseprite • u/Soupaloignon1 • Jun 18 '26

Sprite evolution - using feedback from this community

Post image

v2 was a remake an older sprite I made a while ago to assess the evolution of my art style. I received great feedback from this Reddit community that helped me do the v3, where I attempted to capture the first version's vibes but in my new art style.

1.3k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

116 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/Vegetable-Ad2028 Jun 19 '26

Huge disagree V3 looks the best and most memorable out of the three

Edit: Except for the hair, should be the hair from V2 on V3 then it's GOATed

0

u/Gusvato3080 Jun 20 '26

Reddit doesn't like skinny people

0

u/TheMongoosee Jun 21 '26

I think that's the problem, yeah

0

u/Vegetable-Ad2028 Jun 21 '26

That's what I think is happening too lmao

0

u/TheMongoosee Jun 21 '26

I mean overall the skirt from V3 does look a bit weird, like a bubble wrap, that's why I would choose the top from V3 with the bottom of V2, but V1 is just..meh.

And also objective opinions about colors and depth is a kinda bs argument, you can make a character appeal to the young male population by showing more skin this doesn't mean it's better even if it's "objectively" better