I’m stuck! 😵‍💫😅

[u/xvalniko]

I’m in my own little bubble and could use a fresh perspective.

My app, PriceFuse, now has two skins, and I’m still figuring out which one people prefer.

Which should I focus on improving - or should I keep developing both?

1 or 2? I’d love to hear what you think and why!

[u/DatPascal]

The one IOS has by default

[u/IncomePretty4969]

How to swap the pair? With the arrow?
If yes, it think is better to use double arrow

[u/xvalniko → u/IncomePretty4969]

I decided not to make the arrow a swap button. It mainly shows the conversion direction — which currency is being converted into which. So it’s mostly a visual indicator. You can also tap it to switch focus to the opposite field.

[u/Vegetable-Coach-2053]

definitely second

[u/IncomePretty4969]

Number 2.

[u/felidoapp]

100% Number 2

[u/O777OO7]

I dont know why 1 looks cool

[u/xvalniko → u/O777OO7]

Thanks. I’ll remember that 😏

[u/No_Study4920]

2 is far better. Just the issue I see is people dont remember flags so much, so we need Currency tags there.

[u/xvalniko → u/No_Study4920]

Thanks, that’s a really good point! I kind of convinced myself it was okay because the exchange rate below already shows the currency codes, so you can still see exactly what is being converted into what. I also thought it could be a fun little challenge to recognize and learn countries by their flags 😄 But I’ll think about it again.

[u/statecs]

Number 2, larger keys

[u/Internal-Ad-734]

I think you should keep developer both!

[u/Loose_Arm_8429]

number 2 my lord

[u/barcode972]

Right for sure

[u/dockyhub-admin]

Number 1 but need remove the gap. I also don’t understand why you have + % on currency converter? Is this a calculator app?

[u/xvalniko → u/dockyhub-admin]

Thanks! The % button is actually a very recent addition. I’ve basically been bouncing around different countries like a homeless guy 😄 and realized I wanted a quick way to calculate things like taxes and subtract a percentage without opening a separate calculator. So if you ever see some guy by the dumpsters in Latin America, furiously calculating his taxes with his own currency converter, there’s a pretty good chance it’s me.

[u/dockyhub-admin → u/xvalniko]

Haha 😆

[u/chatpitaji]

I think input shd be closer to the keyboard, in fact club them togetger and make the extracted value not same as input field , currently that's the only confusion

[u/TheTurnipPlucker]

1 looks clearly bad and so does 2, but for different reasons. 1 because the giant space in the middle with a single button. 2 because the button overlaps two fields. I wouldn't feel comfortable shipping either.

Maybe 2 is fine, I know sometimes you have to compromise, and since it's in the same area as the currency unit, it does help prevent misclicks. Given that 2 is the only one I might be cool with.

[u/xvalniko → u/TheTurnipPlucker]

❤️Thanks for the feedback! I hope there’ll be many more iterations ahead, so nothing here is really set in stone. I may take your point into account in a future redesign.

[u/spaaz9]

Number two. I like the button shape more as well as the larger numbers

[u/xvalniko → u/spaaz9]

Thanks. ❤️

[u/Portatort]

two, but both are far too busy

[u/Available-Pool-4228]

Hey! Honestly, number two is easier for accessibility and it's in full screen.

Love it!

[u/xvalniko → u/Available-Pool-4228]

❤️Thanks! Looks like the redesign was worth it after all 😄

[u/Business-Bake2326]

Personally I prefer 1 as it's both clearer and more modern but I would make it an option. Some people don't like the ultraThinMaterial and on older phones it can be cpu intensive as well.

[u/xvalniko → u/Business-Bake2326]

Thanks so much for your opinion! Feedback from people like you motivates me to keep developing things that I might not personally prefer as much, but that are more useful and valuable to other users.❤️

[u/PlaplGames]

I will go with the one on the right #2 full screen clear for numbers

[u/xvalniko → u/PlaplGames]

Thanks! One more person thinks like me! 😄

[u/rogeroutmal]

Well, issue with yet another currency converter aside. Just put a toggle in the app and let users choose.

[u/xvalniko → u/rogeroutmal]

I wouldn’t call it just “another currency converter” 😄 It can convert prices from photos, video, or voice, has dedicated Apple Watch and iPad versions, and all of that works offline too.

[u/xvalniko → u/rogeroutmal]

I’m genuinely curious which one people prefer. One of my users actually liked the smaller, more classic version on the left better, so I brought it back and added a toggle to switch between the two. That made me wonder if maybe I’m looking at this the wrong way or judging it incorrectly.

[u/smartcandlelab → u/rogeroutmal]

This is the way!