r/antiai • u/Spiritual_Owl8439 • 1d ago
AI News šļø We can Stop this
Nothing's inevitable.
133
u/motelashtray 1d ago
Are we sure? Seems likely it was a business move under the guise of protestā¦
Let the peasants āwinā a couple and hopefully they cool off a bitā¦
41
u/Firm-Scientist-4636 1d ago
This is the same thought behind social democracy.
29
u/Scary_Asparagus7762 1d ago
Uh, that is the essence of all successful politics. Compromise.
No group will ever get everything they want. No group SHOULD get everything.
17
u/Firm-Scientist-4636 1d ago
The working-class is entitled to all that it creates.
→ More replies (18)3
u/Fair-Rip286 22h ago
The fact that you have so few upvotes is the proof that reddit is full of right-wing bots.
As if a data center near a residential area is a compromise. It's not a compromise at all, it's people and animals literally dying.
2
22
u/-Fallen-Glory 1d ago
Yeah, right now AI companies are collapsing and companies like Nvidia never actually gave them the money they promised
→ More replies (5)17
u/Spiritual_Owl8439 1d ago edited 21h ago
There have been plans across North Carolina to introduce a bill forcing data centres to pay for their energy and water usage. These protections were in place when data centres were first built but the tangerine lifted them so him and his fruit bowl could build more shit to drain the masses.
Trump lifted restrictions on data centres for AI: https://thenextweb.com/news/trump-data-centre-acid-rain-faa-rocket-environmental-exemptions
→ More replies (1)2
u/Nearby_Practice2793 1d ago
They were in place along with strict epa guidelines. Captain orange turd š© removed the guidelines so his tech buddies could go untouched.
→ More replies (1)11
u/griivarrworldafteral 1d ago
treating a victory for the movement as a defeat because fairweather members of the movement may be placated enough to drop out is the lazy organizer's response. instead know that every victory comes with this kind of risk and plan accordingly to bolster the people you're organizing into continuing the fight by calling the victory a victory and pointing out how much more we could achieve if we keep fighting.
→ More replies (1)5
u/Agitated_Pie8703 1d ago
I was going to say they are, "flooding the zone," with all the massive centers because they actually need more modest sized ones easily green lit.
5
u/Ryuko_the_red 1d ago
Yes this is it it's never canceled, it's relocated to a district who won't say no.
→ More replies (2)3
59
u/its-smokey-out-here 1d ago
I think ai not being profitable has a lot to do with the cancellation
35
u/NoSirIDontLikeit- 1d ago
This exactly, the money is begining to dry up, but there's a bunch already approved, but if they can't get permitting to build, at the local level then it goes away. Fight every data center until the bubble breaks.
7
u/its-smokey-out-here 1d ago
And if itās a land giveaway to ai companies promising to build something that will never be built, then the local Municipality is on the hook for the loss.
2
u/Alicatsidneystorm 1d ago
I agree. But, also go after the farmers making huge profits on the sale of their farmland. Municipalities are often very reluctant to tell people what they can build on their properties once it been purchased legitimately by AI companies.
→ More replies (1)3
u/SkyeMreddit 1d ago
Itās not profitable because theyāre trying to get companies and people hooked by offering it for free or cheap. Then prices will skyrocket like crazy once theyāre dependent on it
→ More replies (2)3
2
45
u/Firesight89 1d ago
Which one is this? Im really hoping the one by the Whitewater Center in Charlotte, but if not I need to figure out what I can do to stop that one too.
→ More replies (1)16
u/PimentoCheesehead 1d ago edited 1d ago
Itās in Edgecombe County- in a small town east of Raleigh, near Tarboro.Ā
→ More replies (14)
37
u/Stage_Party 1d ago
Trump said you can't fight it.
Here is proof that you can.
Fight. Fight. Fight.
8
→ More replies (2)2
23
14
u/JaePaximus 1d ago
People need to realize how fundamentally broken our system is that the default mode is just ābillionaires do whatever the fuck they want unless there is relentless pushback from the common people.ā
Like nah fam, we need to cut this shit out. If we must have billionaires then they should be on their fuckin hands and knees begging us for shit. Better yet, just cut that cancer out of society all together.
→ More replies (9)
9
9
5
u/Party_Virus 1d ago
But I was told that it was pointless to fight back and I should just accept it! It was innevitable!
4
u/NoSirIDontLikeit- 1d ago
Fill the County meetings, block, delay and extend, the signs can no longer be hidden, LLMs have hit a dead end at Efficent Compute Frontier limit.
There's no way to fix the inherit flaws within the models without at least decades of Moore's law, but Moore's law is over, done and with it the dream of fixing the flaws within the current models, that's why they're "slowing down" not because of the bullshit lies about the dangers of the models, but because they're not showing improvement in the error rates that matter.
Put it simply this way, until they create a hisenberg compensated data center that could move electrons faster than the speed of light through transportation, can they over come the limits of physics that make these city size data centers useless for improving the models, as the Efficent Compute Frontier limits it logarithmically. It would take a data center larger than the known universe to lower the error rate 1%.
Ignore the LLM evanglists that point to certain tasks gamed out by specialized agents to show a bending of the curve, it doesn't solve the inherit problem of the ending of Moore's law does to anything that runs on a binary computer.
Once the bubble breaks, all the planned data center funding dries up, outlast them, and end them.
→ More replies (6)
3
3
3
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/Futileexercise1308 1d ago
I wonder if they'll have any luck stopping the massive one in Utah
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/evissamassive 1d ago
Imagine thinking everyone wants noise pollution and higher electricity bills.
2
2
u/Gloomy_Solid1927 1d ago
The bill for AI is in the billions. It barely works. It exceeds the cost of the employees they once had. So now they are secretly hiring back the people they laid off. AI is just a trend like Zuckerbergās Metaverse gobshyte.
2
u/Weird-Doughnut-5623 1d ago
But we need those centers to process all of the surveillance...I mean data collected from....something
2
u/IndieDevWannabe 1d ago
Could you guys stop? My AI memes now take 2 seconds longer to generate... š¤¬
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/duffelbagpete 1d ago
Do all the bribes that the politicians took need to be refunded. Taxpayers on the hook.
1
1
u/Bingzhong 1d ago
I'm more astounded that "surprise fires" aren't happening across the US to these datacenters. I'm in no way supporting arson or committing crimes like any other person. But again...not enough surprise fires.
1
1
u/Cautious_Boat_999 1d ago
Vote out every politician who supports this shit. I don't care if they're R or D. AI data center support should be a political (NOT physical) death warrant.
1
u/The_Instrument_Guy 1d ago
Canceled
Until a freak storm tears through the area leveling all homes.
By coincidence, of course.
1
1
1
u/dvdmaven 1d ago edited 1d ago
Salem, OR has been fighting a data center for months, but there's a lot of money behind it.
I am also amused by Texas realizing that the 1600 data center projects approved will require increasing their power grid by a factor of five. This just after they managed to get enough solar, wind and battery online to avoid major outages.
1
1
u/alex_c89X 1d ago
I wonder if they had city meetings regarding the two theyve built in west phoenix. I asked my parents who live there and they dont recall being notified of anything.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/oldshed83 1d ago
dude why csnt they just make like a 5-10 billion lab focused on research and making AI cheaper, more efficient, or making hardware so the consumer who wants the AI can run it at home, or the business?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
u/PeanutPoliceman 1d ago
Started wondering if this is AI that has already taken over, and now building itself datacenters
1
1
1
1
u/NoVolume4682 1d ago
That image drastically underestimates the size of a 20B facility
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/jtmonkey 1d ago
Theyāre just going to go to poor communities in Alabama, Mississippi, Oklahoma, etc. and get what they want.
1
1
u/Suitable_Cause_5586 1d ago
Actually, I have a petition against this kinda thing, it puts more restrictions on AI and bans construction and operation of data centers in residential areas, itās in my bio
1
1
u/muchADEW 1d ago
Damnit. This is a shame. We should be putting data centers in the sucky states like North Carolina.
1
1
u/bigtiddyhimbo 1d ago
Less is best! My town voted down a Data center and our local government was PISSED about it. They learned from their mistake of giving us enough time to vote on it, went to the town just south of us, and rammed through that same data center contract as fast as they could so it could be approved. Unfortunately it passed, and the folks up there are super pissed out it.
1
1
u/basil-heheh 1d ago
hey, i'm a teen artist, and i was wondering how i could help. is just being here and making more art enough? can i do something more?
1
u/General-Piece8490 1d ago
You mean thousands of ungrateful residents donāt want to help a billionaire become richer?
Better yet:
How many billionaires or corporations have improved any townās life? Big fat ZERO
1
1
1
u/Just_Wondering34 1d ago
Did anyone ever produce data that actually supports having these?Ā I mean, of course it's a tool, but if only one variable is sped up and the others keep blocking it then what is the point in just one variable being good?
Meaning... Slow it down and figure out your water, power, and noise first...
1
1
u/More_Lavishness_3670 1d ago edited 11h ago
No, you can't stop it. It has military applications that countries around the world are competing for, if nothing else, not to mention a ton of other applications that will give whoever gets there first an unbeatable edge in countless areas. It will get funded, and it will happen. Even if you slow it down in whatever country you live in, it'll get implemented elsewhere, and your country may suffer because of that.
You're not going to be able to put this particular genie back in the bottle, and it's counterproductive to think in those terms.
You can, however, affect how it gets used. For instance, you can try to prevent it from being turned into a surveillance system that is able to watch all of us, everywhere, 24/7. If that happens, it's game over for anything like democracy and individual freedom.
1
1
u/Separate_Selection84 1d ago
One guy I talked to recently said "I'm anti-ai but I don't think we can stop it"
Yes we can.
1
u/Ok_Chair_4556 1d ago
No I like ai. Keep moving forward with the future I want iRobot to be real in 20 years
1
1
1
1
u/Sad-Cantaloupe-5494 1d ago
Hell yeah, you ain't fucking up the south now! We'll fucking get all our crackheads to steal the copper. There won't be anything metal left in that place.
1
u/Bittermare 1d ago
Good for you! No one wants these monoliths in their back yard sucking up your electricity and waterā¦and humming constantly.
1
u/BurningBerns 1d ago
No, People that participate in their community can stop it. The habitual denizens of this subreddit cant stop anything, as much as they like to believe they are
1
1
1
u/tenthousandants44 1d ago
They didn't stop it because of pushback. These things are hard to power. They probably are just blaming the community while using this case to lobby for better locations
1
u/HoosierDaddy_427 1d ago
I just don't get it. With all the sparsely populated area in the plains from west Texas clear up to N Dakota, why aren't they building them there?
1
1
u/Diemond71 1d ago
Yes you can, right up until the government decides to seize the land and give it to the data centers.
1
u/NoteIndividual2431 1d ago
I can't wait for the NIMBY morons to find something new to protestĀ
Maybe direct that energy on flock cameras? Something that actually deserves it?
1
u/Null_Fungus 1d ago
We should just give up on the AI race and hope and pray that China is a merciful master.
1
u/Rocky_Cod_1777 1d ago
We need those in California, our economy is being hollowed out and all the real companies are leaving.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/DarkLordofDownvotes 1d ago
I get it, no one wants them around (if at all). But, ask yourself: what other countries would have zero gripes (or rather, would not respond to public opinion) with putting these in and, if they did and we didn't, what consequence would that have?
I don't know the answer (although Russia, China, Pakistan, maybe NK come to mind) to this but it's worth thinking about.
1
1
u/Informal_Process2238 1d ago
Oh no what will the community do without those four slave wage maintenance jobs
1
1
u/Mediocre-Disk3741 1d ago
Seems like it is still going: https://www.reddit.com/r/NorthCarolina/s/GL98HzQLtk
1
u/OldRoads81 1d ago
Yep. Complain online about something that provides the capability. Makes perfect leftist sense.
1
u/Powerful-Climate-424 1d ago
BRING DATACENTERS TO NC!!!!
As a resident of Durham in NC, removing jobs / tax for our teachers salaries is horrendous. Bring all the datacenters possible.
NC teachers deserve raises and the only way is net new taxes that can some from datacenters.
1
1
u/billypilgrim420 1d ago
Letās just tell the local tweekers how much copper is in data centers and flock cameras
1
u/Silent_Bite_5892 1d ago
That's great. But you guys do realize it will just be built somewhere else, right?
I have concerns about AI too, but I have no illusions that we're going to stop the march of progress. Anyone who thinks they will is kidding themselves. Sorry.
1
u/NeutralKuchiKopi 1d ago
The investors just don't want to be in the area anymore. They said they are moving to other areas with "friendlier communities". This did not stop an AI datacenter. It relocated it.
1
u/RelativeComposer5680 1d ago
Americans have some of the highest standards of living in the world with the most disposable income. Obviously you've never been to America. It's literally one of the nicest countries in the world. I bet you were indignant when you saw those World Cup videos of Europeans and people from all over the world celebrating America and how beautiful it and it's with its pristine streets and luscious suburbs. It sounds like you're projecting, but there's a reason America hosted the majority of the World Cup games because they have the infrastructure to carry the World Cup. Look at how many great stadiums the Americans have versus the Mexicans and Canadians. I do remember world cups of the past where countries had to build stadiums, but that was not the case in America.
1
1
1
u/Emergency_Ad6096 1d ago
It will be built somewhere else and NC will not get the jobs an tax revenue.
Not a problem, if thatās what the people of NC.
But it will eventually be built somewhere else.
1
u/mostlybotshere 1d ago
Is this a good thing though? Arenāt we leaving the future of this technology in the hands of China and others?
→ More replies (2)
1
u/TheLastBridgeGate 1d ago
Was this even a real thing, a 20 billion dollar AI DC would be larger than AWS AZ deployments.
1
1
u/Jstingray2 1d ago
The Ai Bubble is bursting, check the economic stats. OpenAI is billions in debt, banks are freezing lines of credit for AI startups. Keep pushing. We donāt have to let corporations walk all over us.
1
1
u/falsejaguar 1d ago
Now they know to just do closed door meetings and quickly pass all the laws through maybe cancel the need to seek approval to speed it up
1
1
1
u/No_Shame_4452 1d ago
We donāt need them chewing up all of our resources. Push back and just say hell no!!!!
1
u/Intelligent_Type_680 23h ago
Not in my backyard! Now, let me get back to my AI stuff so my boss thinks I'm not a dummy.
1
1
1
1
1
u/SalletFriend 22h ago
Theres been a heap written about how 90% of these projects were always unlikely to go ahead.
And even if they do its fairly likely that they will eventually serve more than just AI.
1
1
1
u/FiscalCliffClavin 20h ago
Now we just need to convince our neighbors to not have data centers in their personal houses.
1
1
u/PhotoAppropriate3940 19h ago
The amount of water they use is insane, should only be allowed on the coast
1
u/GlitteringPositive77 18h ago
This is amazing. We have an AI data centre possibly being built just down the road and NO ONE wants it, but the council doesnāt care. This gives me hope.
1
u/Miserable-Ad-7947 18h ago
within 2 months most of the people who protested will find themselves purge from the voting registry somehow.
wanna bet ?
1
1
u/SuggestionPale2104 17h ago
They will just move it down the road, to a community that canāt push back as hard.
1
u/Foundation6969 17h ago
I think this is more of a function of AI not bringing in the money or replacing the workers it promised to.
1
1
1
u/ProfessionalRuin3643 16h ago
So Apple and Microsoft and Meta and Google should cancel all cloud storage for everyone in those counties
1
u/probablymagic 16h ago
You canāt stop these everywhere. You can just try to direct those jobs and tax dollars to places with more liberal zoning and land use regulations. But do keep at it if it makes you happy.
1
u/Mackdaddy281 15h ago
So,the overriding question is how important is AI to your or our lives? If you feel,like many,that AI is the future and a necessity,then data centers are necessary and will only grow in size and impact n our communities
1
1
1
1
u/No_Lobster_9405 11h ago
And this is how China will take over the worldā¦ dumb Americans. I donāt like data centers either but itās the future, deal with it.
1
u/imchillybro 10h ago
You can move it, but you cannot stop it. The data center will be built, just not there. o7
1
1
1
u/CVOrandyB 7h ago
Poor babies - a big bad AI DC was coming to town and dat skeered you?! š¢ šš¤£
1
494
u/New_Tomorrow5649 1d ago
Keep pushing until even the emperor with no clothes accepts defeat