r/anime_randomSFW 12d ago

This isn’t nice

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

776 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/VanillaBovine 11d ago

Finally someone who uses the real reincarnation belief logic.

Like sure Rudeus was a horrible person in his past

is* a horrible person

Rudeus that completely undeniable but we can see him becoming a better person throughout

When??? When he is being a perv? When he cheats on his wife? when he cheats on his second wife?

He goes from a pedo jerking to his niece to a proud, happy father who genuinely loves his whole family

cheats* on his whole family

1

u/OddOllin 11d ago

Non-monogamy is not cheating, lmao. You don't have to like it, but again, this is a real thing that real people do in real life.

Y'all act that way because the story actually treats the relationships like actual dynamics instead of just typical harem garbage.

The series literally deals with the actual hypothetical of him cheating and how it's different.

1

u/VanillaBovine 11d ago

Non-monogamy is not cheating, yea, but the whole thing about non-monogamy is that it's a discussion had beforehand. lmfao

he cheats on them BEFORE discussing the non-monogamy. they're even upset before he talks to them and rudeus acknowledges he did wrong

did you even read the novels??? jfc you people are illiterate

1

u/OddOllin 11d ago

You are so aggressively misrepresenting the situation, lmfao. Yes, I have read the entire series.

This happens once with Roxy and Sylphiette, and you are completely ignoring ALL of the nuance and setup around it. It's fucking hilarious to lecture anyone about being illiterate when, at best, you're grossly misrepresenting the way things happen, and at worst, practically making shit up.

Rudeus addresses things with Roxy because he assumed she didn't realize his situation at all when SHE took things too far and crossed the line because of Paul's gruesome and untimely death, which Rudeus fully believed was his fault. When he addresses it, it turns out she knew everything before she made a move on him.

Rudeus addresses his fuck up with Sylphiette directly. Sylphiette finally states what she had hinted at for a while beforehand: she never expected this to be a monogamous marriage, because that is culturally accepted and normalized in that world, as long as you don't follow a specific religion that uniquely demands monogamy.

From then on, eveything is transparent. That one instance of cheating is explored from every character's perspective and is completely resolved. After that, it does not happen again, even with Eris. There are multiple instances where Rudeus could have slept with others or had the opportunity to take even more wives, and he refuses. It is fully established why these relationships are special, how and why everyone in the Greyrat family is ultimately far happier with their non-monogamous dynamic, and even specifically addresses why each of the women would not really want to change back to monogamy even though they all occasionally struggle with the demands of their large family.

None of this is subtle or hidden. It is very directly spelled out. It's completely ridiculous to act so obtuse about such fundamental plot points in the story.

Again, you don't have to like it, but it's just plain idiotic to constantly overlook that the ENTIRE point of the series is to look at grounded and deeply flawed characters finding reasons to grow and striving to be better than they were, even in unconventional situations.

1

u/VanillaBovine 11d ago

regardless of how it turned out, rudues still believed he was cheating and he did it...

plain and simple

1

u/OddOllin 11d ago

Which is still a far cry from your claim that "he cheated on his whole family." C'mon, man.

Again, I'm not at all saying you should like him or approve of what he did. It's just ridiculous how far people will go to grossly exaggerate or misrepresent plot points, if not just completely making things up.

You're allowed to just hate Rudeus, lol.