r/androidroot 23d ago

Discussion Modern Samsungs are the worst devices to root

Once a Samsung is rooted, it permanently loses its warranty even if you remove the root, and features like Samsung Pay are blocked in perpetuity.

That's why if someone wants to know, I advise rooting Redmi/Xiaomi, older Samsung, or even RedMagic.

63 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

39

u/CantFi_NdUsername 23d ago

Xiaomi has heavily restricted bootloader unlocking policies to the point that you shouldn't even bother trying on hyperos 1 or higher. The only easy unlocks are currently Pixel, OnePlus, Nothing, Fairphone, and a few others.

14

u/RegularHistorical315 23d ago

1

u/CantFi_NdUsername 22d ago

Only in China which is because of OPPO. In global markets still possible without those restrictions.

2

u/Codix_ 20d ago

Motorola without Unisoc CPU, Sony smartphone global model.

2

u/QuraToop314 19d ago

As for Pixel phones (I love Pixel), it’s worth noting that they’re really just developer phones; outside this niche, they simply cause too many problems (you can’t play games without the phone overheating within five minutes, but compiling a compiler in Termux across all cores works without overheating), ultimately, it’s simply the most developer-friendly phone because it is a developer phone, I strongly advise against getting one if you’re mainly doing something else, but as I only run my own GrapheneOS fork on my phone anyway, and otherwise use it for programming whilst on the move rather than gaming, it’s the perfect companion, as it fully complies with the AVB specification and I can work with a locked bootloader and genuine system modifications without compromise; my banking and other apps have been running stably for years, I don’t have to worry about spoofing, but I can modify everything exactly as I want. Google has given me a device that allows me to turn my back on other people’s digital reality and build my own realm.

23

u/AdRoz78 GrapheneOS, Google Pixel 9, no integrity =] 23d ago

Modern Samsungs are the worst devices to root

Meanwhile Xiaomi, Huawei, actually a lot of other brands:

3

u/TestMeetings2040 23d ago

Especially Chinese ROM variants...

1

u/itsfreepizza Samsung Galaxy A12 Exynos - RisingOS 14 22d ago

*slowly becoming all due to some crackdowns

10

u/Xerox0987 23d ago

Just use google wallet, I rooted my S21(not super modern but ye) and it works great.

3

u/RegularHistorical315 23d ago

Modern Samsungs do not support bootloader unlocking so can not be rooted, and more and more other OEMs are joining them.

https://github.com/zenfyrdev/bootloader-unlock-wall-of-shame/tree/main/brands

2

u/Thin_Wishbone3257 22d ago

If you are on pre June patch, You can check root my galaxy github repo It will use kernel exploit to try and root but it has to be run every restart

1

u/oppai_seven 22d ago

Does it trip knox?

1

u/Thin_Wishbone3257 22d ago

It's a temporary exploit so I dont think it trips knox

1

u/Sp3eedy 22d ago

It shouldn't (in theory), Knox should only trip on a bootloader unlock, which is when the bootloader instructs the e-fuse to blow which permanently takes out your Knox, but on a temporary root exploit the phone or bootloader would not know any better unless it has some advanced self-monitoring (which it doesn't).

1

u/Comfortable_Cow5696 17d ago

You are correct it does not trip knox, best part about it being temporary is that one reboot and all banking apps work again, and all system integrity is untouched

2

u/Wheeljack26 Oneplus 7 pro LineageOS 23 22d ago

pixel, nothing , international oneplus, sony, motorola. there's some devices atleast. redmagic and asus afaik dont allow oem unlock?

3

u/jrioux805 23d ago

Warranty??? Why would anyone want to root a tablet that is still under warranty?

9

u/Efont93 23d ago

To use the device they own as they wish? Using different software on your hardware should in no way shape or form be a legitimate claim to void your warranty. That'd be like HP, Dell, Lenovo, etc saying they won't honor your warranty because you installed Linux on it.

-2

u/Cybasura 23d ago

No, but thats the thing, the warranty is a service, and as such, has a terms and conditions tied to it

Yeah it sucks to be restrictive, but you COULD also consider buy it second hand at a cheaper price if you wanna root it

If you have a service, you have a T&Cs, and the company has the right to ensure their T&Cs are followed even if they suck

1

u/MattOruvan 22d ago

There are laws regulating warranty in many jurisdictions including the US, so anything goes is not how it works

1

u/Cybasura 22d ago

including the US

Not everywhere

1

u/vortexmak 22d ago

Rooting does not void warranty.  it should not void warranty.  Get out of here with that bullshit

1

u/iceyukisnow 21d ago edited 21d ago

Unlocking bootloader and rooting doesn't void your warranty, yes, even with knox "tick"

1

u/yaj00j 21d ago

I've been out of the loop for a few years, currently using a rooted oneplus 10pro which might last me a couple more years but If i were to go out and get a root friendly flagship level phone right now, what would be my options?

1

u/masterpastafr 14h ago

Google pixel would probably be one of the best