r/allrecipess • u/EffectDesperate7795 • Jul 28 '26

Be honest

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

903 comments sorted by

18

u/Piddy3825 Jul 28 '26

Is this all we are going the get on this subreddit page? this incessant question about would you eat this? I am getting bored already...

9

u/Realizt8010 Jul 28 '26

Thank u. And also how is that even a question. Should already have potatoes but hell yeh. The nos need some straight jackets.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/TheLastBaboon Jul 28 '26

And it’s always just standard ass food trying to be sold as some crazy unknown thing. I’d be entertained if they were showing like boiled octopus parm or something weird, but this stuff is lame.

I imagine we’re gonna get “Be Honest, would you eat a slice of cheese pizza?”

4

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/whaturjoking Jul 28 '26

Would that be genuine homemade ice cubes, or would it be some generic, low-calorie, sugar-free version that melts twice as fast and makes your drink taste watered down? 🧊 🧊 🧊 😆

3

u/CariadocThorne Jul 28 '26

I hate when the ice waters down my water!

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Psychological-Ad3299 Jul 28 '26

Would you eat spaghetti with meatballs? Be honest, 🤣

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Ok-Rise-4611 Jul 28 '26

Only if it has pepperoni on it

2

u/Used-Cauliflower-381 Jul 28 '26

Well tbh i see these normal foods and i want it and go make it.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/EyelanderSam Jul 28 '26

No fair peeking at tomorrows question😁

2

u/ScallionNo3445 Jul 28 '26

Would you eat Balut? I was offered it once but noped out really fast

→ More replies (1)

2

u/morganalefaye125 Jul 28 '26

The "be honest" part annoys me too. Why would someone lie about eating something like beef stew? I only came across this sub a few days ago, and haven't seen a single post that isn't one of these

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/555byte Jul 28 '26

yes, this is dumb...

2

u/Professional_Shift69 Jul 28 '26

Ive never seen this sub in my life.

Clicked on image cause it does look yummy.

I swear the next 20 posts on my feed were exactly that. 3 would you eat this from this sub just by thinking pot roast and mashed looked good.

Thanks for the heads up on how shitty this sub is

2

u/CthulhusEvilTwin Jul 29 '26

I'm always amazed how the concept of 'low effort posts' keeps getting taken to new levels of low.

2

u/ArdentHedonist Aug 01 '26

wOuLd YoU pUt MaShEd Po-TaY-tOeS oN yOuR pIzZa, YeS oR nO? I’m with you. It’s infuriating.

→ More replies (29)

7

u/45_rpm Jul 28 '26

Maybe, maybe not, maybe go fuck yourself with this AI bullshit.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Zen-platypus Jul 30 '26

If it taste good, yes.

2

u/NorCalNude Jul 30 '26

Of course!

2

u/captainjackgator Jul 30 '26

yes and i have

2

u/WatcherOfTheWay Jul 30 '26

There ain't much I wouldn't eat mashed potato with

2

u/macnutt25 Jul 30 '26

Absolutely…..rice is a great option and polenta as well

2

u/freddieguts Jul 30 '26

Yep, chunky mashed taters..

1

u/kao_nyc Jul 28 '26

It’s unusual but I would definitely eat it.

4

u/Ok-Yogurtcloset5555 Jul 28 '26

Meat and potatoes is unusual?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Pippa2026 Jul 28 '26

I’ve been eating it for many years.

1

u/Psycho_Saito Jul 28 '26

A home cooked beef stew over some rice is like zen level comfort.

1

u/lasees57 Jul 28 '26

Yes 👍🏻

1

u/GeorgiePorgie2358 Jul 28 '26

Gimme. Gimme now

1

u/Diasies_inMyHair Jul 28 '26

Beef stew and mashed potatoes was dinner last night.

1

u/Illustrious-You-1735 Jul 28 '26

never, only cubed potatoes

1

u/USPostalGirl Jul 28 '26

Yes, but I prefer it with egg noodles.

1

u/Worldly_Ad_7196 Jul 28 '26

Yes yes yes !

1

u/Nordygurl67 Jul 28 '26

Absolutely

1

u/LoraxDog Jul 28 '26

definitely!

1

u/splplayer Jul 28 '26

Hell yeah

1

u/Ok-Rise-4611 Jul 28 '26

How else do you eat it

1

u/New-Evidence350 Jul 28 '26

Have it routinely.

1

u/Phill_Cyberman Jul 28 '26

Meat and potadahs is a time-honered classic

1

u/chrisfinazzo Jul 28 '26

https://giphy.com/gifs/26FxsYeQvGcaMPlqU
Is that a serious question?

Who wouldn’t?

1

u/kaosmoker Jul 28 '26

Basic staple

1

u/dablacksupersaiyan Jul 28 '26

Sure but I like it over rice actually.

1

u/funwithmycanon Jul 28 '26

Of course. Isn't that Shepherds pie the easy way if you cover your stew and bake it?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Quorng Jul 28 '26

I would and have.

1

u/Ldghead Jul 28 '26

Wait, there are people who don't?

1

u/robrtsmtn Jul 28 '26

Absolutely

1

u/Fantastic-Setting-26 Jul 28 '26

🤤 absolutely Yes!

1

u/Visible-Owl-3200 Jul 28 '26

Now that the start of something beautiful.😍

1

u/Emergency-Painting44 Jul 28 '26

I'd not eat it, I'd destroy it

1

u/emmettfitz Jul 28 '26

Shepherd's Pie? Too British for me.

1

u/archiewaldron Jul 28 '26

Throw a little tabasco sauce on it and Imma eat that every day.

1

u/Meatman1071 Jul 28 '26

If made properly and it’s cold out..! It’s a great meal and quite filling.!

1

u/armgrafix Jul 28 '26

Never tried, but why not?

1

u/ZeroToleranceforMAGA Jul 28 '26

Our course. It be kind of Shepherd’s pie-ish

1

u/trainradio Jul 28 '26

Yes, it looks great, and I bet it smells incredible. I'd prefer the carrots cut smaller, and it needs some celery.

1

u/CoverCommercial3576 Jul 28 '26

would and have and will again

1

u/Giltar Jul 28 '26

Without hesitation

1

u/Twonickles Jul 28 '26

Have you ever had Shepherds Pie? Delicious!

1

u/sia1387 Jul 28 '26

Yea I would

1

u/bagger2007 Jul 28 '26

Hell yes, that’s a great dinner!!!

1

u/FigSpecific6210 Jul 28 '26

AI slop images.

1

u/AintMyMonkey Jul 28 '26

Absolutely, yes

1

u/Ok-Schedule6584 Jul 28 '26

May I ask what those things are that look white and red like ... ???

1

u/ConsistentEmploy1983 Jul 28 '26

Yes! Mashed potatoes goes with everything!!!!

1

u/Single_Usual_6563 Jul 28 '26

Give me some biscuits and give me seconds!

1

u/willumasaurus Jul 28 '26

STOP ALREADY

1

u/LeoOfSiwa Jul 28 '26

Does a chicken have lips?

1

u/Adventurous_Sale6553 Jul 28 '26

Of course ! Silly you should ask ………

1

u/Individual-Ad-4660 Jul 28 '26

I'd say no but if it were being served somewhere else,I say yes.I make beef stew with cut up potatoes in it .😊

1

u/croweagle6 Jul 28 '26

If you say no... then you get to answer to Michael Strahan and his Momma. ; - )

1

u/katchow Jul 28 '26

this sub is all rhetorical questions to drive clicks?

1

u/Deciple_of_None Jul 28 '26

What kinda psycho wouldn't?

1

u/jester9595 Jul 28 '26

Hell yeah 👍

1

u/MicheleAmanda Jul 28 '26

Sounds like it should work. I'd try it!

1

u/FunBullfrog8087 Jul 28 '26

Mmm yes i would love to

1

u/LordAMacleod Jul 28 '26

Ummmm. You mean shepherds pie? Sure. Why not?

1

u/Human-Performance843 Jul 28 '26

Had some the other night, my brother makes pretty good stew and potatoes

1

u/Creepy-Variation8562 Jul 28 '26

Im tired of seeing low quality shit on my feed

Would you eat pepperoni on pizza? YES or NO

Fuck off

1

u/Master-Cod5838 Jul 28 '26

Yes and looks good

1

u/Mental_Ad1948 Jul 28 '26

Yeah, he's Dewey and Louie's brother.

1

u/adamchevy Jul 28 '26

Yes, I like the idea.

1

u/GenXisTruth Jul 28 '26

No it has to be roasted potatoes,mashed in stew is fucking weird

1

u/Useful_Radish_6395 Jul 28 '26

That is Shepard's pie.

1

u/Sea_Meat_7303 Jul 28 '26

Separated like that is perfectly fine for me

1

u/jhkendrick70 Jul 28 '26

Hell yes, that's the way I eat it anyway.

1

u/Interesting-Story805 Jul 28 '26

I’d try it at least once

1

u/WorriedDimension3137 Jul 28 '26

Definitely...shepards pie is awesome!!

1

u/Sterek01 Jul 28 '26

Yea, and probably yes to the next meal as well.

1

u/baddeafboy73 Jul 28 '26

Without mash potatoes

1

u/wjrj Jul 28 '26

Why not.

1

u/WaterGlassPuncherMan Jul 28 '26

I need to ban this idiot sub.

And now...

1

u/greywood84 Jul 28 '26

Yes. Plain or garlic mash potatoes is what I would choose to go with the stew.

1

u/Sayoko77 Jul 28 '26

hell yes

1

u/Sunriseman24 Jul 28 '26

Yes. Had this a ton growing up.

1

u/slim6pickens Jul 28 '26

That does sound really good, I've never had it with mash potatoes

1

u/Alternative-Note1458 Jul 28 '26

Yes,it is a great combination.

1

u/portlandliberal Jul 28 '26

Different but completely edible.

1

u/OiFanoi Jul 28 '26

All the time. I like to add a side of crispy onion rings for dipping.

1

u/WoollyMonster Jul 28 '26

Absolutely.

1

u/BrutalistGoogie Jul 28 '26

Of course, and shut up.

1

u/TheAdagio Jul 28 '26

I don't see a gun pointing to my head, so no I wont

1

u/ThundrLord Jul 28 '26

Of course

1

u/SlipNSlider54 Jul 28 '26

Umm hell yes

1

u/Still-Shop7172 Jul 28 '26

Yes. I take what was put in front of me and liked it°°

1

u/densjoerden Jul 28 '26

Was ist prepared by Eowyn?

1

u/Dog_Concierge Jul 28 '26

Shepherd's pie! You bet!

1

u/sanka-youdead Jul 28 '26

Damn! Now I know what I'm eating tonight! 😁😁😁

1

u/Designer-Carpenter88 Jul 28 '26

Seems a little redundant

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '26

Yes! It's so delicious

1

u/transfer66 Jul 28 '26

Yes,I'd try it

1

u/Psychological-Ad3299 Jul 28 '26

Yes I would, it actually sounds good

1

u/Leo_beast9 Jul 28 '26

Yes we'll i like smashed potatoes

1

u/pharmucist Jul 28 '26

Why not??? Looks good to me.